Barnabas Xulu, Judicial Service Commission, South Africa (Country), Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe

Barnabas Xulu, Judicial Service Commission

Hlophe’s attorney found in contempt of court - The Mail & Guardian

The high court said Barnabas Xulu acted with impunity and contempt in the saga of getting him to repay millions in state funds

2021-05-05 06:40:00 PM

The high court said Barnabas Xulu acted with impunity and contempt in the saga of getting him to repay millions in state funds

The high court said Barnabas Xulu acted with impunity and contempt in the saga of getting him to repay millions in state funds

, was handed a R30 000 fine and 30-day suspended sentence after he was found in contempt of six court orders relating to the repayment of R20-million in disputed legal fees to the state.In a ruling handed down on Tuesday, Acting Judge Mas-Udah Pangarker said Xulu and his law firm BXI flouted section 165 (5) of the Constitution, which makes court orders binding on all persons to whom it applies. 

President Ramaphosa to address the nation at 8pm ANC staff to strike over salaries COVID-19: Vaccine rollout will not be hindered - Mabuza

“They have acted with impunity and the utmost contempt and it is of great concern that an attorney has conducted himself in continued wilful defiance and bad faith … My view is that Mr Xulu has conducted himself in a manner totally at variance with the integrity and utmost good faith principles inherent to a person who is an officer of the court.” 

In a dispute that dragged on for just under two years, Pangarker found that Xulu and BXI had repeatedly placed themselves in contempt by flouting successive orders relating to the preservation of the funds and attachment of property while litigation on the return of money to the department of environmental affairs was ongoing.

The matter dates back to mid-2019, when BXI got a court order compelling the department to pay it more than R20-million for services rendered to the Marine Living Resource Fund. After its failure to pay, writs of execution were issued and funds taken from various departmental bank accounts to honour the law firm’s invoices.

But in August that year, the department approached the high court in the Western Cape to have the service level contract, the settlement agreements and the wits set aside. BXI and Xulu, in his professional and personal capacity, was then given until April 2020 to refund the money.

Xulu unsuccessfully sought the recusal of Judge Owen Rogers and Ashley Binns-Ward as well as leave to appeal. His stance has remained that only Judge Philip Zilwa, of the Eastern Cape division, was allowed to adjudicate on the matter as per a request from Hlophe to Justice Minister Ronald Lamola that no judges in the Western Cape should be allowed to hear it. 

BXI had been ordered to transfer R3.4-million of the disputed fees earned from the department and held in a forex account into an attorney’s trust investment account by way of preservation, while Xulu challenged the validity of orders pertaining to his personal liability. Instead, the money was largely dissipated.

Magashule says ANC & co only responded to his arguments in part - The Mail & Guardian SA moves to lockdown level 3, with changes to alcohol sales & curfew President Ramaphosa announces 'family meeting' for Tuesday night

Similarly, BXI was ordered to maintain the balance of its trust account at no less than R380 000 but it dipped below this minimum on seven occasions.Eventually the department approached the high court for a contempt order, a suspension of further litigation order and a fine and suspended jail term for Xulu. The department indicated that it did not seek imprisonment per se, but only should the attorney fail to respect an order to surrender his Porsche 911 Carrera.

The court had, on 5 October 5 last year, ordered that R3.4-million plus interest be paid to the state attorney by the end of the day.In the same month, it also issued an order that, pending the final determination on Xulu’s challenge regarding his personal liability to ensure repayment of the R20-million, the sheriff of Cape Town must attach the vehicle.

Farce ensued as four attempts by the sheriff to serve a writ of attachment on Xulu failed, prompting the court to authorise the sheriff to enlist a tracking service to locate the car. But attempts, both to find the car and to contact Xulu, including through his lawyers and his wife, proved fruitless.

In November, the deputy sheriff confronted Xulu at his home in Fresnaye, at which the attorney sped off in another car.Referring to the matter as “the Porsche saga”, Pangarker said Xulu was obliged to comply with the court order to surrender the car, regardless of whether he agreed with it, and it was alarming that he fled from the deputy sheriff seeking to execute the writ.

Xulu did not dispute that orders were granted against him, or deny that he and his law firm failed to comply with these. Hence, Pangarker said, the court had to decide whether the third requirement of contempt, namely that orders be flouted wilfully and in bad faith, was present.

Regarding the attachment order, he found that the deputy sheriff’s account of Xulu absconding plainly proved mala fide conduct  His law firm had in dissipating funds similarly wilfully disobeyed a court order, the judge said.“It is not open to a litigant, including an attorney or law firm, against whom an order is granted, to pick and choose whether he wishes to comply with the court order. 

COVID-19 in SA: Randburg taxi rank complains of commuter non-compliance COVID-19 Vaccine: 300,000 doses for teachers have arrived Mr. Mayor, where are you while Joburg is falling apart? | The Citizen

“The conclusion is that BXI and Mr Xulu have violated the integrity and dignity of the court through their conduct. Mr Xulu’s refusal to surrender the Porsche was contumacious and his conduct is to be deprecated. Ultimately, the conduct displayed by the respondents undermined respect for and obedience to the law.” 

Xulu was given until noon on Friday to surrender his Porsche. Either he or his law firm have to pay the fine by the same deadline. His prison sentence was suspended for three years.Pangarder said he would send a copy of the ruling to the Legal Practice Council.

The ruling comes exactly one month beforeon a finding by its conduct tribunal last month that he committed gross misconduct in 2008 by attempting to influence two constitutional court justices in favour of then aspirant president Jacob Zuma.The JSC has to decide whether to endorse

Xulu has told the media that Hlophe could challenge the finding in court.Subscribe to the M&GThese are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.TheMail & Guardian

Read more: Mail & Guardian »

LIVESTREAM: Presidency's budget plans for 2021/2022

President Cyril Ramaphosa presents the Presidency's budget plans for the year 2021/2022. The budget outlines the

They only respresent JP Hlophe? IFC_org BBCWorld WHO EU_Commission eu_eeas AusGov NewZealandGov EnglandGov MoodysInvSvc stat_world questCNN MinPres NEDemocracy en_germany UKParliament DailyMailUK SwedenUN swiss_un FBI FitchRatings UN Minor setback I owe you an apology to ever doubt your sincerity and professionalism. It’s was just like a dream to me when I received my first payment. After my second payment it became a reality now after several payments it has become a way of life. LISATOWNSENDC

Qasim’s dream of 2015 – Prophet Muhammad SAW said, Qasim convey this message to the whole Ummah, whoever stands with you is just like a person standing with me, and whoever supports you its just like they support me. More at Words alone won’t express how thankful I’m recommending you all to you LISATOWNSENDC investing with you has been a good opportunity for me and my family I just received my profit within seven days of investment .