had an impeachment clause that tracked the U.S. Constitution’s almost word-for-word except that the list of impeachable offenses for state officials is shortened tomisdemeanor: “The governor, and all other civil officers under this commonwealth, shall be liable to impeachment for any misdemeanor in office.” Thehad an impeachment provision virtually identical to that of Pennsylvania.
The proceedings of the Constitutional Convention strongly indicate that one of the most influential framers of the Constitution, James Madison, understood “misdemeanor” as having a different and broader meaning than criminal acts. In the waning days of the convention, on September 8, 1787, Virginia delegate George Masonto add “maladministration” to the existing list of impeachable offenses—at that point, only “Treason or Bribery.
The Trump defense team has seized on Mason’s substitution of “high crimes and misdemeanors” for “maladministration” as supporting its contention that impeachment must be based on commission of a crime. However, the story looks quite different if we—literally—turn the page.
Madison’s statement seems to tell us two things: First, he did not see “misdemeanor” in the amended impeachment clause as a term with well-defined limits, as would be the case if it instead said statutory violations or crimes. Instead Madison suggested that many kinds of acts “might be called” a misdemeanor. Second, Madison saw inclusion of “misdemeanors” in the impeachment clause as giving the Senate greater discretion to remove the president than just the phrase “other High Crimes.
In the end, both advocates and opponents of impeachment might be focusing on the wrong word, “crimes.” Abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, as alleged in the House’s articles of impeachment against Trump—even if not crimes—could well be considered “misdemeanors,” meaning “misconduct,” specifically misconduct in office. This could provide the basis for impeachment and removal.
HIGH CRIMES..... who wrote this garbage?
Dershowitz defended Epstein cuz Dershowitz was in cahoots misusing underaged girls. AlanDersh was defending himself!!
Politico was a Russia Hoax cheerleader.... So...
Of course, everyone keeps going back to “crimes,” because lay persons have a fundamental misunderstanding of the legal meaning of the phrase “high crimes and misdemeanors.”
I am offended that Allen opens up his mouth he is the criminal a pedophile ConvictAndRemoveTrumpNow
What pisses me off is that there were actual crimes that he has not been charged with, such as obstruction of justice in the Comey affair. Mueller all but handed it to Congress on a platter, but amazingly they only brought these two charges against him. Should have been more!
A good faith analysis of this Dershowitz argument is a waste of time.
Hypocrite
Semantics
Truth
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Source: TheOnion - 🏆 724. / 51 Read more »
Source: Women's Health - 🏆 475. / 51 Read more »
Source: latimes - 🏆 11. / 82 Read more »
Source: CNBC - 🏆 12. / 72 Read more »
The One Where Courteney Cox's Friends Throwback Will Bring Tears to Your EyesCourteney Cox shared a behind-the-scenes look at a cast dinner before filming the last episode of Friends.
Source: InStyle - 🏆 103. / 63 Read more »
Source: Food52 - 🏆 113. / 63 Read more »