Sony Music Loses Bid for Secrecy in Dr. Luke-Kesha Libel Trial

Records from the 7-year-old legal battle between Dr. Luke and Kesha will be publicly disclosed soon.

10/22/2021 3:00:00 PM

Records from the 7-year-old legal battle between Dr. Luke and Kesha will be publicly disclosed soon.

A New York judge rejected Sony Music's concerns in the Dr. Luke/Kesha legal battle and ordered that various contracts, business plans and other financial records be unsealed within days.

Jennifer Schecterrejected Sony Music's concerns and ordered that various contracts, business plans and other financial records be unsealed within days.Dr. Luke, a hugely successful pop song producer, is suing Kesha after she accused him of rape. She's countersuing on the basis that his claims of defamation and breach of contract have no merit and are subject to a New York law designed to protect free speech from frivolous litigation. The parties are getting ready for trial, and Schecter will soon make evidentiary determinations on what's admissible and what's prejudicial.

Covid-19 Vaccines or Infections: Which Carries the Stronger Immunity? Omar Seeks Action Over Far-Right Congresswoman's Islamophobic Remarks Steal His Style: How to Rock Harry Styles’ Pearl Necklaces, Funky Sweaters & More

To prevail at trial, Dr. Luke will not only have to convince a jury that he didn't drug and rape the budding pop star 15 years ago in a hotel, he'll also attempt to show damage from her accusations. Kesha is now making a bid to preclude testimony on lost business opportunities. As such, court exhibits include financial experts opining about the music business plus what's said to be"reams of data regarding his earnings and revenue," which could be revelatory considering he's worked with artists such as Katy Perry, Britney Spears and Miley Cyrus.

Artist MentionedDr. Luke Suffers Blow on Road to Libel Trial Against KeshaAdditionally, the contractual relationship between Dr. Luke's companies and Kesha is front and center in this case. What she's been paid for her work recording"Tik Tok" and other hits has been a secret, as has all information relating to Dr. Luke's joint venture with Sony, Kemosabe Records. headtopics.com

Much of this could soon be seeing the light of day.In a bid for continued secrecy, Sony argued that the release of information including royalty rates, artist advances, producer fees and recording budgets would cause"substantial harm" to its business interests.

And as for the confidentiality of Kesha's recording agreement, Sony told the judge that if the terms"were made publicly available, Sony's competitors would likely use it to encourage artists and producers to sign with other record companies, instead of Sony."

"That is a stunning admission of the unreasonableness of Sony's deal terms for Kesha's albums," responded Kesha's attorneys at O'Melveny in slamming the secrecy demand."Sony, at bottom, may be embarrassed about the terms of the deal under which it is requiring Kesha — a Grammy-nominated artist who has generated enormous amounts of money for the label — to continue to work, but that is not a valid basis on which to keep the information confidential."

Kesha Seizes on New Free Speech Law for Counterattack Against Dr. LukeIn fighting the request, Kesha's team also foreshadowed trial strategy."Dr. Luke is suing Kesha for breaching her contract with his production company, and Kesha will show at trial that the paltry deal terms and nearly a decade of never-actually-fulfilled promises to improve the contract is one of the manipulative tools that Dr. Luke used to coerce Kesha into keeping silent about his abuse," continued a brief. headtopics.com

It’s Time to Get Rid of the IT Department 1st injectable, bimonthly HIV treatment approved in UK Bus driver shortage hurts D.C. region’s ability to return to pre-pandemic transit service levels

In her latest order, Justice Schecter is allowing Sony to redact personal identifying information and contact information of its employees upon the music giant's discussion of a public backlash to this case. But otherwise, she sees no good reason to keep the info under wraps.

"Any other asserted privacy interest Sony has in its records, many of which are quite old, is overwhelmingly outweighed by the public's right to fully understand the parties' contentions regarding the substantial damages sought by plaintiffs," Schecter writes.

The lengthy dispute between Dr. Luke and Kesha, which was filed back in 2014 and preceded the #MeToo movement, has consistently produced legal precedence on all sorts of topics ranging from interpretation of gender-motivated crimes to the definition of public figures. And it continues to be influential. On Monday, for example, in a separate libel battle over a sexual misconduct claim, Donald Trump's attorneys pointed to how Kesha was allowed a counterclaim against Dr. Luke. The ex-president is looking for similar treatment in an upcoming trial against an 

Apprentice alum who accuses him of smearing her by publicly denying inappropriate behavior. Read more: billboard »

Jury finds Kyle Rittenhouse not guilty on all counts

A Wisconsin jury found Kyle Rittenhouse not guilty on all counts after the Illinois teenager shot and killed two men and wounded a third at a protest last year.

great news. Sony and other big music industry companies maybe will start to feel fear as they should, in case they mistreat their sing-up artists. Remember George Michael vs Sony thing?

Sony Music Loses Bid for Secrecy in Dr. Luke-Kesha FightAs the 7-year-old libel suit over a rape accusation nears trial, a New York judge is opening the books on pop music dealmaking. FreeKesha Nice, some (forced) transparency inside the business - “In a bid for continued secrecy, Sony argued that the release of information including royalty rates, artist advances, producer fees and recording budgets would cause “substantial harm” to its business interests.” With all the production done to pop singers voices it’s a wonder they get paid at all. Other than a heavily curated look, dance moves to distract, pop music is the most popular thanks to heavy promotion, but least talented genre.

Ozzy and Sharon Osbourne Love Story Getting Feature Film at Sony Pictures (EXCLUSIVE)The lives and epic love story of rocker Ozzy Osbourne and manager and personality Sharon Osbourne will be the subject of an upcoming feature film. The untitled project comes from Polygram Entertain… Long overdue! Ozzy is one of the greats

HHS' Dr. Rachel Levine sworn in as US' first openly transgender four-star officerDr. Rachel Levine, the assistant secretary for health at the US Department of Health and Human Services, made history Tuesday as the first openly transgender four-star officer across the nation's eight uniformed services Stolen valour, she's a Walt Acosta Clown world Remember when she sent seniors to nursing home to die during the pandemic? A real hero.

Dr. Rachel Levine sworn in as first openly transgender four-star admiralAssistant Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine made United States history Tuesday as the first openly transgender four-star officer in any of the nation's eight uniformed services. Minorities & DEMS, Please get the vaccine-We NEED U 2 Help Preserve Democracy in the USA-trumpRepubs R trying 2 keep U from voting-U can't vote if ur covid dead-VAXup Blackhawk_SQDN INDOPCOM Bluestarfamily_ 1AD_CAB DepSecDef AirForceAssn 1stArmoredDiv MIArmyOSM business

Jason Manford and Dr Alex slam Steve Allen after he calls Tilly Ramsay 'chubby'Comedian Jason Manford and Love Island's Dr Alex George have slammed radio host Steve Allen after he called Strictly star Tilly Ramsay 'chubby' live on air RealityOfRapture TheMessiahIsComing BeHoly BeRighteous RepentRepentRepent RealityOfRapture 우리가 받은 구원은 사람이 아닌 하나님으로 말미암았습니다 Wats wrong with that Tilly is 'chubby' anyone can c that, say it how it is! As he so hot 😷😬😬

Dr Alex takes action after Strictly's Tilly Ramsay body-shamedStrictly Come Dancing star and Gordon Ramsay's daughter Tilly was called out for her weight live on LBC Radio, and Dr Alex George has made a stand.