Opinion | 'Queer Eye' in Japan reveals how tone-deaf Western LGBTQ advocacy can be

  • 📰 NBCNews
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 47 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 22%
  • Publisher: 86%

United States Headlines News

United States Latest News,United States Headlines

Opinion | Netflix's 'Queer Eye: We're in Japan!' highlights a big problem with mainstream LGBTQ advocacy. - NBCNewsTHINK

for several years now alongside the so-called “Fab 5:” Four gay men and a masculine-presenting nonbinary person. But season five has also revealed some of the show's shortcomings and blind spots.features a Japanese gay man struggling to come out — a classic trope of the show. But in this case, the Fab 5 descend upon a society with disparate and complicated cultural norms to tell the man, Kan, how to be “out” and “proud.” At best, it was a culturally tone-deaf exercise.

The LGBTQ movement is supposedly built to empower diversity, and yet the irony of mainstream queer advocacy is that it remains quite rigid and homogeneous in its worldview. The paradigm of sexual identity tends to come in the form of a binary: One is either out of the closet or in it, proud or ashamed, open or repressed. Embedded in this paradigm is a righteousness, a belief that somehow there is a “right” way to be out. But Western culture is highly individualistic, and what pride and empowerment looks like for an American, say, often doesn’t translate in places that are comparatively more collectivist, or where there is a larger emphasis on familial relations.

The “Queer Eye” experts are trying to do something they think will be positive, that much is clear. But conflating the coming out experience for men and women as one that is equally liberating can be harmful and sometimes even dangerous.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

THINK in depth stuff here, reccomend reading the whole article

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 10. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

'Queer Eye' star Karamo Brown helped his sons survive bullying with words every parent should memorizeWhen his sons came home saying 'I don't want to be me,' Karamo Brown had a mantra for them. Now, he's written a children's book about it.
Source: Yahoo Lifestyle - 🏆 365. / 59 Read more »

Here's How Young Queer Couples Are Redefining 'Straight' MarriagesThe institution has been due for disruption; for queering, even in seemingly heterosexual partnerships
Source: MTVNEWS - 🏆 479. / 51 Read more »

In Broadway's Powerful Queer Epic 'The Inheritance,' Matthew Lopez Bridges an LGBTQ Generation Gap.matthewlopeznyc bridges an LGBTQ generation gap in Broadway's powerful queer epic inheritanceplay TheInheritance
Source: billboard - 🏆 112. / 63 Read more »

Chrissy Teigen Apologizes For Making ''Tone Deaf and Icky'' JokeChrissy Teigen is expressing remorse after revealing that her mom buys a few pairs of expensive AirPods every month I can’t believe I saw that tweet but I missed the apology NotASupermodel I don't understand WHY ppl are so quik to jump on Chrissy n her comments or post's..I never realized the absolute idiots n their shallow hateful a**lives being SO perfect that they need to pick on her..My thoughts n sentiments, if u don't like her..DON'T FOLLOW HER..EASY PEASY..
Source: enews - 🏆 466. / 52 Read more »

In Broadway's Powerful Queer Epic 'The Inheritance,' Matthew Lopez Bridges an LGBTQ Generation Gap.matthewlopeznyc bridges an LGBTQ generation gap in Broadway's powerful queer epic inheritanceplay TheInheritance
Source: billboard - 🏆 112. / 63 Read more »

https://people.comGet the latest news about celebrities, royals, music, TV, and real people. Find exclusive content, including photos and videos, on PEOPLE.com.
Source: people - 🏆 712. / 51 Read more »