Eli Lilly and Johnson & Johnson have paused COVID-19 vaccine trials. Why experts say that's reassuring, not frightening

Experts say the pause on COVID-19 vaccine and treatment trials isn't unusual but shows scientific safety processes are working.

10/14/2020 2:16:00 PM

Recent pauses to two large-scale COVID-19 vaccine trials and a treatment study should reassure people — not frighten them — vaccine experts said.

Experts say the pause on COVID-19 vaccine and treatment trials isn't unusual but shows scientific safety processes are working.

They lifted the hold a week later, but it has continued in the American arm of the study.These occurrences should serve as a reminder that scientific research can be unpredictable, disappointing and time-consuming, specialists said.“After four decades in vaccines, I expect the unexpected,” said Dr. Gregory Poland, director of the Mayo Vaccine Research Group and editor-in-chief of the journal Vaccine. “The nature of vaccine development is there are always surprises and the unexpected. Everybody’s looking for them, but time has to pass before you actually know.”

According to a new pollfrom Informa Pharma Intelligence, a business intelligence provider, and research firm YouGov, 35% of Americans don’t trust how quickly the COVID-19 vaccine clinical trials are moving, and 23% say they don’t think pharmaceutical companies have consumers' best interests in mind.

The public may have unrealistic expectations of a vaccine that's"100% effective and 150% safe," said Alan Barrett, director of the Sealy Institute for Vaccine Sciences at the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston.USA TODAY Editorial Board: headtopics.com

Some Mail-In Ballots Rejected After New Laws Take Effect

Don't inject politics into vaccine policyHe said the companies have shown an impressive attention to safety, including the trial pauses. “We can’t afford to have a mistake,” Barrett said. “The public has to have confidence that any vaccine given to them is going to be safe and effective.”

About 31% of vaccine candidates make it all the way from Phase 1 clinical trials to market,according to a study published in the Oxford Academic last year.There are 49 COVID-19 candidate vaccines in clinical trials around the world, nine of which are in large, late-stage studies, Barrett said. Only three people out of the roughly 300,000 volunteers in all those trials are known to have suffered serious side effects. “It’s not a big number,” he said.

The challenge with vaccines, compared with treatments: Vaccines are given to people who are healthy. Though a patient dying of cancer might be willing to take a medication with lots of side effects, a healthy person shouldn’t be subjected to a risky vaccine, said Gostin, a law professor at Georgetown. “That’s why we need to be super careful that our vaccines are safe and effective before we deploy them.”

Cavaliers are the NBA feel-good story the Knicks were last season

Vaccine trials on pauseJohnson & Johnson announcedit was pausing a trial of its COVID-19 candidate vaccine, JNJ-78436735, while it investigated an “unexplained illness” in a trial participant. The company, as well as an independent Data Safety Monitoring Board, will review the participant’s case before deciding whether to resume the trial. headtopics.com

About half the 30,000 trial participants received a placebo and half the active vaccine. Only the Data Safety Monitoring Board members will know which shot the volunteer received. If it was a placebo, the trial is likely to be restarted quickly; if the problem could have been caused by the vaccine, an investigation will take longer.

A similar trial by the pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca was stopped in September after a second trial participant developed an unusual neurological condition.I volunteered for a COVID-19 vaccine trial in New Jersey:Here's what it's been like since the shot.

Alex Trebek’s longtime, final LA home lists for $7 million

In the United Kingdom, where the volunteer lived, regulators examined her case and decided the trial could resume. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration kept the U.S. trial on hold as it investigates her case.Little has been revealed about her problem, which may be something called transverse myelitis, a spinal inflammation that can cause temporary paralysis. She and the other person who suffered a serious side effect, a woman who had a flare-up of previously undiagnosed multiple sclerosis, have apparently recovered.

If the adverse event in the Johnson & Johnson trial was some type of nerve issue, there is a theoretical, but by no means proven, reason it could be linked to the way the vaccine delivers its immunological payload, said Dr. Otto Yang, a professor of medicine and associate chief of infectious diseases at UCLA's David Geffen School of Medicine. headtopics.com

Both the Johnson & Johnson and AstraZeneca candidate vaccines use a platform based on a harmless human virus called an adenovirus. The ones they use are uncommon in nature, so most people have not developed immunity to them.A tiny number of people who are naturally sickened with adenovirus develop transverse myelitis, a neurological disorder of the spine that can cause paralysis.

Experts:Politics will have a hard time getting in the way of a safe, effective COVID-19 vaccine“Nobody knows why it happens, but it appears to be some type of immune response. Perhaps the immune system is reacting to the virus, and that’s causing a cross-reaction,” Yang said.

He cautioned that the possibility of a link is extremely theoretical and there is no data to support it at this time, but he said it certainly warrants a pause while the companies investigate.“Transverse myelitis does happen very rarely all by itself,” he said. “So if it’s a 1-in-100,000 event and you see it in one person, then OK. If you see it in two people, then it starts to be suspicious.”

Barrett, of the University of Texas, said he doesn’t think virus delivery systems can explain the problems.Treatment trial put on holdEli Lilly released a brief statement Tuesday explaining the pause in its trial of a monoclonal antibody, which mimics the natural immune response to the virus.

“Safety is of the utmost importance to Lilly,” according to the statement, released by company spokeswoman Molly McCully. “Lilly is supportive of the decision by the independent D.S.M.B. to cautiously ensure the safety of the patients participating in this study.”

Last week, Trumphe was given a day after his diagnosis with COVID-19. That drug is made by Regeneron, a Tarrytown, New York, company.The Lilly antibody trial,led by the National Institutes of Health,was to have enrolled about 300 volunteers with mild to moderate COVID-19 who have been sick for less than 13 days. Half the participants would receive the antibody via infusion and half a saline infusion. Plans are to expand the trial to an additional 700 participants, including more severely ill patients if the antibody performs well.

The antibody, called LY-CoV555 or bamlanivimab, was isolated from the blood of a recovered COVID-19 patient.Wednesday,Lilly released a statementthat only the Data Safety Monitoring Board, not the company, has reviewed the data. This trial, called ACTIV-3, is different from others in the company's portfolio, because patients are sicker and receive the highest dose of the drug. The remaining trials of bamlanivimab continue.

"Individuals in the ACTIV-3 study have been infected with the virus for a longer period of time and may have more severe symptoms than patients studied in other bamlanivimab trials," according to the statement."Hospitalized patients receive different treatments for COVID-19 than earlier stage patients, including treatment with the antiviral medicine remdesivir."

Gostin, who directs the O’Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law at Georgetown, said he’s troubled by this second hold.“The two medical interventions that are most likely to dig our way out of COVID are vaccines and monoclonal antibodies,” he said. “It shows us that science is miraculous, but it’s not foolproof and it doesn’t always win over Mother Nature.”

Gostin said we just have to"be patient. Let science take its course.”Contact Elizabeth Weise at eweise@usatoday.com and Karen Weintraub at kweintraub@usatoday.com

Read more: USA TODAY Health »

EXCLUSIVE Renault, Nissan, Mitsubishi to unveil 2030 EV plan this week

Renault SA , Nissan Motor Co and Mitsubishi Motors Corp plan to triple their investment to jointly develop electric vehicles (EVs), two people with knowledge of the plan told Reuters. Read more >>

Johnson & Johnson Halts COVID-19 Vaccine Trial After Mystery IllnessIt's the second time testing has been halted on vaccines because of an illness. Everything will happ in time for the election watch From Johnson & Johnson, the company who brought you Cancer Baby Powder 😑

Johnson & Johnson Pauses COVID-19 Vaccine TrialJohnson & Johnson has paused dosing and enrollment in all of its COVID-19 vaccine clinical trials due to an unexplained illness in a study participant. Ah, no ‘cure’ yet ImpeachedTrump .

Johnson & Johnson pauses Covid-19 vaccine trial after 'unexplained illness'Johnson&Johnson said its Janssen arm had paused its coronavirus vaccine trial after an 'unexplained illness' in one of the volunteers testing its experimental Covid-19 shot. No way in hell will I be taking any vaccines that are rushed like this! That’s code for not only did it not work but also had bad side effects..... Welp better open everything up

Johnson & Johnson Halt All Covid-19 Vaccine Trials Over ‘Unexplained Illness’The pause includes late-stage stage trials for the group’s single dose Covid-19 vaccine. Uggh Normal..I’m pretty sure it was the same for EVERY Vaccine, Antibiotic, cure every created🤷🏽‍♂️😐

Johnson & Johnson Paused Trials on Its COVID-19 Vaccine Due to Subject's 'Unexplained Illness'Johnson & Johnson started Phase 3 human trials on a COVID-19 vaccine in September, and it was paused a month later due to a participant's illness.

Johnson & Johnson Pauses Covid-19 Vaccine Trials Due to Sick SubjectThe company says an independent committee is reviewing the subject’s illness, and it will review the medical information before deciding whether to restart the studies realDonaldTrump told Bob Woodward how dangerous and even airborne the Virus was! But he hid it from us all! That was in Feb of this year! 214,000 Americans perished since! Then he told us not to fear covid19 after families across the Nation lost their loved ones! Must end this! It never fails....as soon as the stock market goes up something like this comes out