Despite court rulings, South Dakota's Noem pushes for school prayer

The promotion of Biblical values are the responsibility of families and churches. So why does Kristi Noem want to get the government involved?

9/18/2021 11:02:00 AM

.MaddowBlog: The promotion of Biblical values are the responsibility of families and churches. So why does Gov. Noem wants to get the government involved?

The promotion of Biblical values are the responsibility of families and churches. So why does Kristi Noem want to get the government involved?

BySteve BenenIt's hardly a secret that South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem is trying to raise her national visibility and score points with the Republican base ahead of the 2024 election cycle. What's of greater interest, however, is how the GOP governor is trying to advance her ambitions.

Vaccines, masks? Japan puzzling over sudden virus success All the Details on Travis Barker's 'Emotional' Proposal to Kourtney Kardashian - E! Online Travis Barker and Kourtney Kardashian Are Engaged: ‘Forever’

In July, for example, Noem spoke at an event in Iowa, where she told conservatives she doesn't recognize the United States anymore."When I grew up, people were proud to have a job," the governor."They weren't confused on the difference between boys and girls. We prayed in schools – which by the way, in South Dakota, I'm putting prayer back in our school."

The South Dakotan took a similar message to a conservative outlet called Real America's Voice,arguingyesterday that Americans should look at officials' actions to determine whether they"line up with the word of God" and"see if they're Biblical."

Of course, given that the United States is a democracy, and not a theocracy, officials' actions are supposed to line up with the Constitution and the rule of law, not how some people interpret scripture.But in the same interview, Noem went just a little further. Right Wing Watch posted

this excerpt:"We've seen our society, our culture, degrade as we've removed God out of our lives.... When I was growing up, we spent every Sunday, every night, every Wednesday night in church. Our church family was a part of our life. We read the Bible every day, as a family, together.... I don't know if families do that as much anymore, and those Biblical values are learned in the family, and they're learned in church.... We in South Dakota have decided to take action to really stand for Biblical principles.... I have legislation I'll be proposing this year that will allow us to pray in schools again."

The governor, wholly indifferent to the separation of church and state, added that an emphasis on"Biblical principles" will help"re-center" children who attend public schools.I won't pretend to know how well Noem understands the law and relevant court rulings pertaining to religious liberty. Perhaps the governor knows the truth and uses rhetoric like this to advance her political ambitions; perhaps she's genuinely confused.

Either way, the Republican's position is badly flawed and in need of a fact-check.For example, when Noem said she'll introduce a proposal to"allow us to pray in schools again," she's pushing for a right that already exists. Voluntary school prayer was never removed from schools.

Kim Kardashian Shared First Look at Kourtney’s Engagement Ring From Travis Barker Afghan Taliban's victory boosts Pakistan's radicals J&J recipients should 'feel good' about booster recommendation: Fauci

What the governor seemed to be suggesting, however, isn't a system in which students pray on their own, but one in which school officials intervene in children's religious lives. In the United States, that's not legal: As my friends at Americans United for Separation of Church and State

recently explained,"The South Dakota Supreme Court struck down mandatory recitation of the Lord's Prayer in the state's public schools in 1929. The U.S. Supreme Court invalidated school-sponsored prayer and Bible reading in public schools in 1962 and '63."

Noem may believe the Supreme Court's new conservative majority is open to dramatic societal changes, but there is no scenario in which the federal judiciary allows a state to try to"re-center" children through the imposition of"Biblical principles."

But perhaps most important is the degree to which the governor's argument contradicts itself. At one point in yesterday's interview, Noem argues,"Biblical values are learned in the family, and they're learned in church." Moments later, the governor – who is ostensibly a proponent of small government – added that she believes it's important for the government to get into the religion-promoting business.

The promotion of Biblical values are the responsibility of families and churches – except in South Dakota, where Noem believes the responsibility should also shift to government officials. Read more: MSNBC »

Vegetable Hot-and-Sour Soup Recipe

This healthy Vegetable Hot-And-Sour Soup gets flavor from mushrooms, tofu, ginger, and more. Get the recipe at Food & Wine.

MaddowBlog Because the US Constitution is a book too long for these people to read. MaddowBlog My soul. My choice. MaddowBlog Exactly what religion would they be teaching? Go to church or Sunday school for that kind of instruction. Leave public schools out of it. MaddowBlog Gov Noem’s is a liar. This is not about religious values, it is about being re-elected, as it is with all politicians. She succeeds in denying “religious freedom for all” by coming out on the side of Christian monotheism and faith practice insecurity for all others.

MaddowBlog Maybe because the media has no values….. you can relate MaddowBlog Their praying to get rid of noem. Gnome. MaddowBlog This woman should be prosecuted for purposely putting citizens at risk MaddowBlog Prayer has not been removed from schools. Everyone is allowed to pray. The only restriction is that no one is compelled to pray.

MaddowBlog Because she is pandering to her supporters culture war. Populism.

Australia approves Whitehaven mine despite court ruling on climate obligation to kidsAustralia's Environment Minister Sussan Ley on Thursday approved an expansion of a Whitehaven Coal mine - a decision which comes despite a historic court ruling that she had an obligation to children to consider the harm caused by climate change.

Key senators eye the exits ahead of 2022 midterms: 'It's a six-year commitment'As the midterm election season begins to take shape, party leaders are closely watching the decisions the five senators make about their political careers

Minnesota Supreme Court Allows Initiative on Replacing Minneapolis Police Onto BallotA Minnesota Supreme Court ruling will allow voters to decide whether to replace the Minneapolis Police Department with a new public safety agency, a proposal stemming from the killing of George Floyd And people wonder why cops have become even more defensive, reject vaccine mandates. Left wingers spout Defund Police & wonder why they end up with such little power or influence. I'm sure minnesotans will get exactly what they deserve This won’t be a disaster at all

S.Africa's top court rejects' ex-leader Zuma's bid to overturn jail sentenceSouth Africa's top court ruled on Friday that former president Jacob Zuma had failed in his bid to have his 15-month jail sentence for failing to attend a corruption inquiry overturned.

Minnesota high court OKs ballot question on Minneapolis PDThe Minnesota Supreme Court has cleared the way for Minneapolis to vote on the future of policing in the city where George Floyd was killed Defunding the Police is stupid, it's counterproductive And they will learn the hard way as their crime and murder continues to set new records

Antivaxxers Gargling With the Antiseptic BetadineAntivaxxers are pushing false claims that gargling with the common Betadine antiseptic will prevent COVID-19. Y’all must be bored. Never heard anyone say this until y’all wrote THIS article. Stop lying Natural Immunity is 20 times better than any vaccine.