Column: To anti-vax firefighters, bye-bye. Now let's build back better at the LAFD
L.A. City officials haven’t spelled out consequences for firefighters and other city employees who don’t comply with the vaccination mandate by Dec. 18.
PrintSo let’s say that in two weeks, hundreds of Los Angeles city employees still defy the COVID-19 vaccination mandate.What then?Well, we don’t know exactly. Wimpy city officials, who already moved back the compliance deadline in the face of resistance, still haven’t spelled out consequences for those who don’t comply by Dec. 18. Already, some city employees — including firefighters — are off-duty without pay for failing to sign notices informing them of the deadline.
For the sake of argument, let’s say that in the Fire Department, where more than 500 membersprotesting the mandate, a few hundred stick to their guns and refuse the jab.AdvertisementI say bye-bye, and good luck finding a firefighting job that pays as handsomely. And let’s hope the Cro-Magnon who allegedly took his mandate notice,
with it and dropped it on the floor of a station house in Pacific Palisades is the first to go. He’s on administrative leave while the department investigates.Firefighterunion presidentFreddy Escobar warned of a “devastating” public-safety risk if hundreds of firefighters are lost. headtopics.com
But that’s unlikely. Chief Ralph Terrazas told me that with some juggling here and some maneuvering there, he can cover the field while the department fills the vacancies.But if, say, 100, 200 or 300 firefighters stick to their guns and quit, this could be a tremendous opportunity for the department to realign and better serve the public.
Firefighters who leave could be replaced by paramedics.Why would that make sense?L.A. firefighter accused of vulgar act in protest over vaccine mandateThe department is investigating a firefighter who is accused of a vulgar act after being given a letter to comply with the city’s vaccination mandate.
Because it’s easier, quicker and cheaper to hire paramedics than firefighters. And more important, because 85% of the calls are for medical issues rather than for fires, per the LAFD. That’s part of a national trend, and metro agencies across the nation have been shifting resources and strategies to serve changing needs.
That’s why Andrew Glazier, a former member of the Board of Fire Commissioners, sees a potential mass departure as an opportunity rather than a problem.“If you lose several hundred people, and you refuse to change your operating model, then, yeah, you’ll have a big problem,” said Glazier. “But … if they were willing to add single-function paramedics to the department, you can hire them up and have them in the field in six weeks or less, and you can continuously hire them as needed.” headtopics.com
Glazier, who was appointed by Mayor Eric Garcetti, asked a lot of tough questions about department policy and advocated unsuccessfully for greater emphasis on medical services, but he was rebuffed. He paid a price for not being a City Hall stooge and rolling over to the wishes of the administration and firefighter union: Garcetti replaced him.
But let me get back to why Glazier uses the term “single-function” paramedics. It used to be that the LAFD had two main job classifications: You were a firefighter or a paramedic, not both. That changed in the mid-1990s, when paramedics were given firefighter training.
Today, all LAFD firefighters have basic medical training, and many have also become paramedics, which involves more advanced training and comes with a big boost in pay. The dual training can be a great benefit, because there’s a ready response for either fires or medical emergencies.
But it’s an expensive model, and Glazier is not alone in thinking that some changes might be in order. Steve Knight, vice president of the fire consulting company Fitch & Associates, said the New York City Fire Department is exploring options to better align resources to meet changing needs. headtopics.com
Knight said that over the last few decades, the number of fire calls have decreased dramatically, while emergency medical calls have soared, and among the alternatives in play is a public-private partnership, in which emergency medical services are contracted.
A former high-ranking LAFD official told me that not only are more than 8 in 10 calls medical in nature, but the vast majority do not involve life-threatening issues.“Probably 70% of them don’t even require paramedic skills,” said the former official. He added that there is long-standing opposition to hiring single-function medics by the firefighters union, which would rather maintain higher-paying positions and avoid losing members to a medic unit not represented by the union.
Escobar confirmed his opposition to hiring more single-function medics. He told me by email that they wouldn’t necessarily be easy to come by and would still need training in department operations, and he argued that the greater need is for firefighters and firefighter/paramedics.
Terrazas told me he would oppose replacing firefighters with single-function medics, in part because he thinks it would be difficult to maintain personnel diversity goals. But that was disputed by the former fire official and Glazier; both said that hiring female paramedics, in particular, would help address a department shortfall.
A greater emphasis on medical services might also help trim overtime costs, which are both outlandish and legendary at the LAFD, whichtops all departmentsin annual OT costs, according to a recent audit by the city controller. It’s expensive to have multiple firefighter/paramedics — who are often on the overtime clock — roll out to a medical call that turns out to be little more than a stubbed toe.
Kenneth Mejia, an accountant who’s running for city controller, dug into records recently andtweeted a list of top earnerson the L.A. city payroll between Jan. 1 and the end of September.Eighteen of them are in the Fire Department. And each of them hauled in more than $500,000 in nine months.
That is not a typo.The amount represents more than just salary and overtime. It includes healthcare benefits, retirement benefits and other sweeteners. But the overtime amounts are staggering.Firefighters are critical of LAFD leadership and discipline process, survey finds
Many Los Angeles Fire Department employees lack trust in the agency’s leadership and more than half of the LAFD’s female sworn personnel cite bullying and harassment as a source of conflict, according to a new survey.One LAFD captain made $385,000 in overtime alone in those nine months. In all, six firefighters made more than $300,000 in overtime alone, seven made more than $200,000, and four pulled in more than $100,000.
With those kinds of numbers; squadrons of LAFD members; a recent audit of overtime issues at COVID testing sites; and claims of harassment, discrimination and a frat-house culture, I think it’s safe to say this is not a particularly well-managed department.
When I asked LAFD spokeswoman Cheryl Getuiza about the half-million-dollar leader board, she emailed me a response.“The LAFD members on this list have worked multiple overtime shifts, either filling a field vacancy or working in our COVID Division,” she said.
Yeah, it’s quite a gravy train.And although the work of firefighters can be grueling and dangerous, it’s astounding that hundreds of public safety employees might opt out rather than take a safe and effective vaccine in the middle of a pandemic.But like I said, that’s not a problem.Read more: Los Angeles Times »
Explosion kills 13, flattens village in Ghana mining region
At least 13 people were killed and scores injured when a truck carrying explosives to a gold mine in western Ghana detonated, flattening a rural community, the police said on Friday. Read more >>
Inmates that are already fighting fires in California need a good paying job when they get out. Here’s to the 2 LA fire fighters that stood up and fought for their constitutional rights! The LA Times columnist is nothing but a Lemming! Discrimination is fun when society lets you get away with it, huh? 100% agree. Time to clean house. LAFD are totally overpaid. They rip us off on overtime, get excessive base pay, get a big pension. Thousands of qualified applicants live up around the block for a single opening there. Dump them. lafd LAFDtalk MayorOfLA
Thank you for this description of the paramedic factor. Their rebellious nature has cost them all their careers! The best choice I've made this year was investing in cryptocurrency and forex trading. I now make $5k weekly I've never regretted this decision. 🙏🏻🙏🏻 Thank you very much cammilacampton Send her a dm(cammilacampton ) to get started. You'll forever be greatful
I love the idea of focusing on the service we need from firefighters -- paramedic support. Thank you LATstevelopez. I hope the MayorOfLA CD6Nury cd4losangeles PaulKoretzCD5 etc gives this idea serious consideration. We don't need emergency workers who don't trust science. 🔑🔑🔥🔥🔥🔥⌛⌛⌛🔑🔑 SI SEÑÓRES.
a year ago they were heros, what happened?
Column: Baseball can't afford another extended labor disputeBaseball’s last labor dispute was devastating, but the comeback had two big things working in its favor. Yesterday game And it’s their own damn fault. These outrageous contracts. Man babies on the field. It’s never too late to start making beneficial mark, so glad taking risk and it turned out positively…thank God for encountering with lisamiabtc…it’s has been a great news ever since I came across her on twitter.
Wow, look at the psychos at Los Angeles times that are more interested in politics than the people that help them every day. This headline is absolutely sickening. Byeeee 'And let’s hope the Cro-Magnon who allegedly took his mandate notice, wiped himself with it and dropped it on the floor of a station house in Pacific Palisades is the first to go.' Public health means nothing to the firefighters refusing vaccines.
💯 Do the cops next. JoshMankiewicz Good riddance. Don’t let the door hit you in the ass on the way out. Might cause brain damage. More precisely, b-bye to the LA Times, bye Spot on here. Hiring paramedics makes much more sense. And the chance to hire people who truly want to help people as opposed to wanting a “cool” job that pays well.
Way to act like a 5 year old L.A Times! Your shithole of a state has dozens of forest fires yearly and now with more firefighters lost, it's only going to get worse. 'Hey, this whole neighborhood burned down but at least the firefighters were all double vaxxed with 16 boosters!'
Kristen Stewart Is Breathtaking in This Strapless Pink Column GownThe actress's Gotham Awards look was striking, from the bow bun to the dress's vivid pink hue.
They are doing the work for us thinking they are hurting us by quitting and I love it! Amen Great column, LATstevelopez ! An opportunity indeed. LAT, not a good way to act; these are public servants & your immaturity shows nothing more than the behavior of a teenager in a street fight, taunting other kids over the color of a gang’s jackets. Your politics and racism cards should be calming, not calcifying. Bye bye from me.
Column: Congress has become a cesspool of threats and extremism, thanks to Kevin McCarthy's leadershipAt a time of political violence, McCarthy bears responsibility for tolerating hate from the likes of Lauren Boebert and Marjorie Taylor Greene. opinion HELP BRAZIL! BOLSONARO IS KILLING INDIANS AND BURNING THE FORESTS OF BRAZIL. NO NATURE LIFELESS CAN YOU UNDERSTAND ME? THE AMAZON AND THE FORESTS OF PANTANAL (BRAZIL) ARE DESTROYED! THIS WILL CAUSE CLIMATE CRISES, HURRICANES, FLOODS, WATER LACK, POLLUTION AND DEATHS IN THE WORLD. opinion And lemme guess. Only one side is to blame according to you. opinion
Column: For many alive during Pearl Harbor, the war years were the most momentous of our livesColumnist George Skelton writes that his generation is the last that will have any recollection of the attack on Pearl Harbor and World War II, which made America a superpower and California a nation-state.
Column: Sorry, Pete Buttigieg. It's Fred Karger who belongs in the history books“I think it’s important that our history be recorded accurately,” Fred Karger said, “and that I certainly be a part of that.” LondonBreed SFPDChief SFPDCommission KTVU kron4news KPIXtv ANOTHER DAY BEING HARASSED INCESSANTLY BY SFPD VIA SYNTHETIC TELEPATHY. THE MAYOR REFUSES TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT
Column: 'Why does Mater Dei protect bullies?' A school and Orange County diocese have lots to answer forA high school student gets assaulted. Their innocence is shattered; their lives, forever changed. Most football coaches who double as the social studies teacher are like that. protecting abusers is a tradition in the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church is a hierarchical structure and there is virtually no recourse for an underling going against someone over them, regardless of abuse/cruelty/crimes. “Jesus wept.”