Pfizer has backed down over its controversial demand that the South African government put up sovereign assets guaranteeing an indemnity against the cost of any future legal cases, the Bureau of Investigative Journalism can reveal.
Government, according to Mkhize, is “relieved” as Pfizer eventually conceded and removed the “problematic term”
Duringnegotiations, the company sought indemnity against civil claims from citizens who had experienced adverse vaccine effects — meaning that the government would have to cover the costs instead.On Wednesday, South African Health MinisterZweli Mkhize
, voiced frustrations about “difficult and sometimes unreasonable” terms his country’s government had been presented with during contract negotiations with vaccine manufacturers, including Pfizer.In a briefing letter sent ahead of his appearance at the parliamentary health committee, Mkhize said one condition in particular demanded by Pfizer was “too risky” — that the country put up sovereign assets as potential collateral.
Internationally Pfizer wanted indemnityIn its negotiations to provide vaccines to countries worldwide, Pfizer has asked governments for wide-ranging indemnity protection against any civil claims a citizen might file. This means that if Pfizer were to be sued by someone who had suffered a rare adverse effect from the vaccine, then the government, not the company, would have to pay for legal costs and compensation. This would apply even if the case were brought due to the company’s own acts of negligence, fraud or malice. headtopics.com
In other negotiations, Pfizer went further. The company required some Latin American governments to put up sovereign assets, including federal bank reserves, embassy buildings or military bases — as a guarantee against indemnifying the cost of future legal cases. This was
reported by the Bureau in Februaryand picked up by more than 25 media organisations worldwide.Pfizer told the Bureau: “Pfizer and BioNTech have no intention of interfering with any country’s diplomatic, military, or culturally significant assets.”
Unredacted draft contracts between Pfizer and the Dominican Republic, Albania and Peru show that the company sought to be indemnified against problems at any step of the supply chain — including packaging, manufacturing and storage. Experts told the Bureau it was “unreasonable” to require governments to pick up the bill for any negligence by Pfizer.
In South Africa’s case, Mkhize said the clauses “posed a potential risk to our assets and fiscus [public purse]”. He described how Pfizer’s late demand caused delays in the discussions, which in turn put back the anticipated vaccine-delivery dates. headtopics.com
Mkhize wrote that the government was “relieved” when Pfizer eventually conceded and removed the “problematic term”. He added: “As the government, we found ourselves in a precarious position of having to choose between saving our citizens’ lives and risking putting the country’s assets into private companies’ hands.”
A level playing field Experts have raised concerns that Pfizer and some other big pharma companies have demanded complete confidentiality during the recent vaccine negotiations, which would prevent the public from knowing about issues including indemnity protection and price. In South Africa, there are fears that any such secrecy clauses could undo public trust built up by years of anti-corruption work.
“I think it is important that this [sovereign assets] clause has been taken out,” said Georg Neumann of the not-for-profit organisation Open Contracting Partnership. “When contracts are negotiated in secret, companies have the power to dictate the terms. And I think what we’re seeing here is that transparency — when contracts with other countries have been made public — has improved that balance and created a bit more of a level playing field.”
A contract for 30-million doses of Pfizer vaccine has now been signed at $10 a dose. Nearly two million doses are scheduled to arrive in South Africa in May and 2.5-million in June. The government has made down payments in its deals with Pfizer andJohnson & Johnson headtopics.com
, which are not refundable under any circumstance.“This is another onerous term that we had to concede as manufacturers were not prepared for it to be removed,” Mkhize wrote.Yousuf Vawda, a professor at the University of KwaZulu-Natal’s law school, said: “While Pfizer appears to have dropped its demand on sovereign assets, it has still insisted on the indemnity and no-fault compensation commitments … Such conduct must be condemned in the strongest terms, as they are holding governments to ransom and delaying the rollout of vaccination.”
More talk as Covid-19 tally risesPfizer told the Bureau: “Pfizer and BioNTech seek the same kind of indemnity and liability protections they have in the US in all of the countries that have asked to purchase our vaccine, consistent with the applicable local laws.
“In markets that do not have the legal or legislative protections that are available in the US, we work with governments to find mutually agreeable solutions, including contractual indemnity clauses.”The delayed Pfizer deal arrives as South Africa is facing a third wave of Covid-19. In total, the country has recorded nearly 1.6-million cases and more than 53 000 deaths.
Its response has been complicated because current vaccines appear to be less effective against the dominant variant circulating in the country. Less than a quarter of the country’s 1.2-million frontline health workers have been vaccinated, using doses donated by Johnson & Johnson. However, its roll-out has been suspended to investigate a potential link to blood clots. South Africa decided to sell or donate 1.5-million doses of the
/Oxford vaccine when a small study suggested the jab might not adequately prevent mild or moderate illnesses in patients with the country’s dominant variant.Subscribe to the M>hese are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.
TheMail & Guardian Read more: Mail & Guardian »
IOL Sports Show: Temba Bavuma ready to build bridges as Proteas captain
Speaking candidly on The IOL Sport Show, Temba Bavuma tackles the hard issues that the Proteas face in trying to be a high-performing international sports team on the global stage.
GlassPearl Fuck them and buy Sputnik V, help SAns to ID their pharmaceuticals blacklist them. Can't be held hostage by big pharma RDIF & China's top influenza vaccine manufacturer HualanBio team up to produce 100 million doses of SputnikV jab per year in China ✌️
First batch of Pfizer vaccines has landed in South Africa - The Mail & GuardianIn a statement issued on Sunday, health minister Zweli Mkhize said South Africa was expecting to receive shipments of more than 320 000 Pfizer vaccine doses weekly until the end of May, totalling 1.3-million doses. Why couldn't we have our observers at the source overseeing the manufacturer's quality control processes? Surely we should be doing everything to reduce the waiting time. I never believe in online trading after my awful experience with scammer until I meet an account manager Mr Andrew who convinced me to trade with him, I gave it a trial behold I received my profit after 7days you can connect him on Twitter MALYAROVALARA_ Andrew Pertersonfxt
First batch of Pfizer vaccines arrive in South AfricaOver 325,000 doses of the jab landed at OR Tambo International Airport on Sunday night. . We don't want that we need jobs that what maybe get us sick not coronavirus please give us jobs you will see the difference trust me🤞🏽
South Korea signs with Pfizer for additional 40 million Covid-19 vaccine dosesSouth Korea said on Saturday it signed a contract with Pfizer Inc to purchase an additional 40 million doses of its Covid-19 vaccine amid fears of spiking infections at home. Thank God for bringing bitcoin to man,it has being a great source of blessing to all of man kind who have passion for bitcoin trading. Now the poor are getting rich over night and the rich getting richer. William_claw_ thank you for your proper management .
First batch of Pfizer vaccines expected in SA by midnight on SundayThe first batch of Pfizer vaccines - 325,260 doses - is expected to arrive in SA shortly before midnight on Sunday amid strict security measures, health minister Zweli Mkhize said in a statement. The best choice I've made this year was investing in cryptocurrency and forex trading and earning from home. With the help of KevinKatch2 I've been earning ZAR70,353.00k weekly I've never regretted this decision fellow RSA, 🙏🏻 This image is disturbing, from the first look, you will assume they are injecting a person's forehead...atleast from my point of view Why have other countries stopped using it causing inflamation of the heart
First batch of Pfizer vaccines expected in SA by midnight on SundayThe first batch of Pfizer vaccines — 325,260 doses — is expected to arrive in SA shortly before midnight on Sunday amid strict security measures, health minister Zweli Mkhize said in a statement. good news, but more badly needed. This things are confusing, we have lost track, tool much activities, “take this one and the next minute leave it because of W & Z” and the next moment there is a new vaccine coming, the next thing it has been put on hold until further notice because it’s has side effects🤣🤣🙈