Danske’s top ESG banker spots risks in loan market

Danske’s top ESG banker spots risks in loan market

2021-11-30 03:29:00 AM

Danske’s top ESG banker spots risks in loan market

Among the concerns is the quality of criteria that determine the interest rate and how far key performance areas are pushed

Charles DalyThe explosive growth in sustainability-linked loans has exposed a number of shortcomings that need to be resolved in order to avoid greenwashing, according to the global head of sustainable finance at Danske Bank A/S. Picture: BLOOMBERGThe explosive growth in sustainability-linked loans has exposed a number of shortcomings that need to be resolved to avoid greenwashing, according to the global head of sustainable finance at Danske Bank. 

As things stand now, there are “clear risks”, Samu Slotte, who’s based in Danske’s Helsinki office, said in an interview. “There is room for improvement.”Among those risks is the “quality of criteria” that determine the interest rate on the loans. As with their cousins in the bond world, sustainability-linked loans carry a rate that’s linked to key performance indicators, rather than the strict use-of-proceeds model associated with green bonds or loans. The somewhat laxer requirements have lured a broader range of borrowers, including corporate behemoths such as Ford Motor Company. In 2021, global issuance of such products has soared 212% to $318bn. 

Slotte says it’s “becoming the norm” to discuss sustainability with clients applying for loans. Within two to three years, he expects 75% of large corporate loans at Danske to have sustainability-linked features. It’s a pattern that fits the overall proliferation of environmental, social and governance (ESG) assets, which mushroomed to an estimated $35-trillion in 2020. headtopics.com

ANC and its alliance partners come out strongly in support of SA's Constitution and the judiciary

The Danske banker says a number of issues need to be addressed if sustainability-linked loans are to live up to their label. These include key performance indicators (KPIs), which still require fine tuning. “KPIs have to be material and relevant for the company,” Slotte said. “And they need to be ambitious, so they go beyond business as usual.”

A Bloomberg News survey with 50 borrowers and lenders signalled that almost half of respondents think two KPIs are sufficient for a deal, while 17 think there should at least be three targets. Participants also said they preferred specific performance targets over more general ESG ratings.

There’s also no independent verification of performance objectives, according to Slotte. That potentially puts sustainability-linked loans at greater risk of greenwashing than sustainability-linked bonds, which are subject to an external verification process.

On This Day: What happened on 24 January?

The issue is partly one of incentives. For bonds, “arranging banks can say it is not them that require it, it is the investors”, Slotte said. But he can’t recall any examples of this happening with loans, because “there isn’t anyone the banks can point to, they are the investors themselves”. headtopics.com

Meanwhile, Danske’s efforts to persuade clients to subject themselves to an external verification process often fall flat. The process “easily starts to back-pedal and the client says maybe we don’t need this at all”, Slotte said. Ultimately, “it is typically a cost issue”.

Finally, there’s the question of how to structure the pricing for sustainability-linked loans. Typically, a loan margin will drop 2.5 basis points if three KPIs are met on an annual basis. Borrowing costs rise by the same measure if the metrics aren’t achieved. 

Beggar suffered traumatic injuries as truck ran over her

Slotte says he hasn’t “seen an example where the loan margin has gone up but I have seen cases where borrowers have not hit all their KPIs so they don’t get the discount”. He says it’s a phenomenon that’s more typical of the services industry, in which indicators tend to be harder to quantify.

The market for sustainability-linked debt products has in general faced criticism that borrowers don’t face meaningful penalties for failing to meet the targets they set. But Slotte said that may change once the market matures. “First we need to make sure that the KPIs are correct before we look at moving the margin, which in itself does not solve the problem,” he said. headtopics.com

Read more: Business Day »

South African Depression and Anxiety Group

SADAG - South African Depression and Anxiety Group Read more >>

ESG compliance: Investors need clarity, consistency and reliable data | CitypressAnalysts say investors – including long-term ones – are increasingly recognising the need for urgent climate action and even though they may remain invested in portfolios that do not yet completely recognise specific environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors.

ESG compliance: Investors need clarity, consistency and reliable data | CitypressAnalysts say investors – including long-term ones – are increasingly recognising the need for urgent climate action and even though they may remain invested in portfolios that do not yet completely recognise specific environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors.

Transactional and lending activity is recovering, Standard Bank saysIn the broader Africa region personal loan volumes were also higher, driven by a strong recovery in branch-originated loans

Transactional and lending activity is recovering, Standard Bank saysIn the broader Africa region personal loan volumes were also higher, driven by a strong recovery in branch-originated loans

Market data — November 28 2021Market data including bonds and fuel prices

STUART THEOBALD: Omicron’s timing couldn’t be worse for leisure and travel industriesThe damage in SA will be severe, regardless of market reactions