A lapse in our editorial rigour

  • 📰 mailandguardian
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 33 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 16%
  • Publisher: 92%

South Africa Headlines News

South Africa Latest News,South Africa Headlines

A lapse in our editorial rigour - The M&G erred in publishing an opinion piece that uncritically lauded Zweli Mkhize

published an opinion piece by repeat contributor Rebone Tau titledThis piece spoke about how Mkhize should be lauded and be mentioned among those who are ethical for resigning as a minister when his name was compromised.

However, the opinion piece fails to address the long list of allegations against Mkhize including how his family and friends benefitted from money meant to educate and save people’s lives during the pandemic.We have since taken the piece down. We pride ourselves on contributing to building a better South Africa. This opinion piece does not do that. We apologise for the lapse in editorial rigour in publishing this article. We have already started an internal process to ensure this kind of error does not occur again.

We accept that we have a responsibility to our readers and community, and thank you for keeping us on our toes.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

Well done on admitting the error. Thank you for your rare honesty.

RediTlhabi 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. Thumaminamediagroup was not impressed with your antics. How about you being Mampara of the year?

Realeboga,gare batle nonsense

Your editor read it and signed it off. There was NO 'lapse' in judgement. The mainstream media is a joke. 🤡🤣

WMC wielded the finger to silence what was an honest opinion. We are being dictated by the rich white people in Stellenbosch. Cyril has been accused left right and centre but he remain incharge, thanks to WMC agenda.

What kind of a newspaper are you?

A lapse? You are joking right? What a shameful rag you have all created out of a once venerated publication.

CoruscaKhaya 😂🤣😅🤭👀

EXPLAIN ….!!!

there's sure been a lot of those recently!!

You don’t say asswipes

When you going to apologise for not defending a free world? Why did u support a one sided covid vaccine...lockdown protocol. Why did u ridicule, censor and muzzle world Renowned scientist who had another opinion. Which we know today they were correct?

Remember when this bogus story was published? That was also blamed on a “lapse of editorial judgment”.

🤣🤣🤣

samkelemaseko Mxcim

You regularly publish opinion pieces on that uncritically laude the vaccine, it just that in this case it ran counter to your propaganda aims

TshepoTsoane

Well done on apologising

Nansi I media LukhonaMnguni

Allow differing opinions to flourish. That is balanced reporting

That was a huge mistake and politicking...

Thanks. It was an opinion piece intended to mislead and was offensive given the proximity of events to the deaths of thousands of South Africans

tshidi_lee No no no… you purposefully published it, many times, because you were paid to do so.

Eusebius It's an opinion! Since when an opinion piece has to conform and align with publisher's perspective? Could this be a subtle form of media censorship?

It was shocking to be precise, I thought it was New Age 😳

It was tasteless and low for the newspaper 😳

Which idiot stil believes in the independence of the media?

it takes forever to build a reputation - only 5 secs to destroy it you are welcome to your opinions and we'll disagree if we want to - but at least maintain some level of objectivity and rational discourse - we've had enough of 'we are shocked'

PLMyburgh Maybe your rigour is getting off the rails.

👀👀

🫣

Pathetic - was paid/corrupt journalism. The reason I no longer buy this pathetic newspaper

How many clicks did it get you though?

Eusebius Bitcoin is something worth talking about, I decided to give it a try when i witnessed how it lifted my friend to his financial hierarchy. I invest $1500 worth of bitcoin and now with the current increase in bitcoin price I got $17,200 just in a week with the help IreneRamire33

Eusebius Has the writer, as well as all responsible and the editor, offered their resignation or asked to go? My guess not. Damage already done! Besides, too many similar mistakes.

TyaliSiya Thank you for allowing yourselves to influenced and or corrected. That article left a bitter taste. Thank you again for your contribution in flushing out t rot.

CoruscaKhaya We know it was a paid advertorial. What else can it be!! There was not even a paywall in that nonsense. But you are quick to put a paywall in other stuff Mxm

thutozadc1 Mail and garbage lesiba_keetse

Yeah no that was bad. You really Surve-d us something strange.

Hope u fired ReboneTau.or you?

RediTlhabi I got worried reading that article

Some people are going to need more time to recover from the shock. Thoughts and prayers.

Yep...u made your intentions very clear.....heads must roll.....

Good call . Shocking Op-Ed. Nobody should be lauding those who stole funds meant to save lives.

Damage is done already

ow wow... running parallel with the ANChor movements explanation of the looting and dire state of the RSA by the ANChor Movement... and r the ppl of SA supposed to be gullible and naive to the fact of lies, lies and more lies sugar-coated by a lame ass excuse.. LMFAO again&again

Did the journalist/paper receive money for said article?

PLMyburgh but the 'goal' has been achieved. Same staregy as the Russian propaganda machines! You should hang you heads in shame!

Too late. You revealed yourself for who you are

Was wondering why such a controversial piece was published by M&G. Was about to stop reading anything from you... but hey... everyone makes mistakes. 🤔

Is the editor asleep?

We can and must do better 👇🏽

How humiliating.

Ya think?

Glad to see some corrective action. Can’t afford trusted newspapers go the route of the “Independent media group” and undo the legacy of robust journalism at the price of politicking on behalf of a faction. Otherwise might as well become the next “New Age”

More than just a lapse. A bad error of judgment.

Where is the editorial i wanna read it 🤔📖

Not acceptable…… your reputation and integrity are now worthless

PLMyburgh Not acceptable

Bit more than a lapse guys. Disgraceful piece.

That was an extremely bad piece of journalism. I mean, it is ok to loot if you resign. Really

Dunno what you were thinking

I'd say

M&G is going to have to work extra long and hard to rebuild their reputation after this disgusting episode. Heads must roll.

Not a lapse, you just showed your gutter journalism for all to see, and that M&G support criminals as leaders in this country. Next you will be telling us what a great president Zuma was and he's great moral and ethical values by leaving office.

Maybe this!!!

Not gonna lie, should have stuck to your guns. You’ve officially contributed another coffin nail to this 1984 hellscape we’re trapped in. It clearly wasn’t an error and now you’re spineless as well. 🙌

Will you then be publishing the facts or is this it?

You never err about Ramaphosa tsek

PLMyburgh We susspected that long time ago. Pls also investigate this Tau guy. I am willing to bet my last cent, they guy/girl has been one way or the other PAID!!

🤣😂😅

To err is human. It was a aberration. Uncharacteristic. Tighten your controls.

Too late. Damage is done.

I have always hated Bitcoin and thought it was a scam until a friend referred me to _ambreymarcus1, I made my first withdrawal of R100,000 in 2 weeks thanks to _ambreymarcus1.

No wonder people lose trust in journalism around the world 😫

What a shame 😔

This clowntry is getting funnier and funnier

🚮

No, you pretty much nailed your colours to the mast.

Was someone drunk at work to publish this?

How could it be?🤔😊

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 2. in ZA

South Africa Latest News, South Africa Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Editorial | An ode to Masebe, a great communicator | CitypressGovernment spokespeople are generally not the most likeable characters. Often standing between the media aggressively demanding answers and their political principals concerned with protecting their reputations, they can never quite win. Born in 1964?
Source: City_Press - 🏆 7. / 72 Read more »

EDITORIAL | Let’s remember what we share as humans as we celebrate Freedom DayScience is showing us we share more than we think, debunking the basis for prejudice. The more we understand what makes us human, the more human we can become. We were Created by The Higher Power!
Source: SundayTimesZA - 🏆 47. / 51 Read more »

EDITORIAL: Trust Imtiaz, not our thieving officialsOnce bitten, twice shy — well-wishers would rather send their KZN disaster relief to Gift of the Givers. Being the head of the home isn't easy, you are expected to provide for the home, I lost my job during the pandemic and relied on the little money I had,things were hard until I met Williamchurch07 and started Bitcoin trading, I earned R500,000 in 3 weeks thanks Williamchurch07 I have always hated Bitcoin and thought it was a scam until a friend referred me to _ambreymarcus1, I made my first withdrawal of R100,000 in 2 weeks thanks to _ambreymarcus1.
Source: FinancialMail - 🏆 20. / 63 Read more »

EDITORIAL | SA knows it has hit rock bottom and it showsIt remains to be seen if politicians understand why the finance minister refused to let government handle relief funds No why would these cliptomaniacs understand... LOOTING, THEFT AND MURDER OF OPPONENTS ARE NOW OFFICIAL ANC POLICY. CRIMINALS ARE RUNNING THE COUNTRY AND THE ANC. SOUTH AFRICA HAS BECOME A FAILED STATE UNDER THE ANC GOVERNMENT. Fraud and corruption....
Source: SundayTimesZA - 🏆 47. / 51 Read more »

EDITORIAL | Lack of action against fraudsters breeds even more corruptionThat government employees caught defrauding the state of social grants are still employed says a lot about our leadership They are paying back at the rate of R5 pm interest free MYANC Being the head of the home isn't easy, you are expected to provide for the home, I lost my job during the pandemic and relied on the little money I had,things were hard until I met Williamchurch07 and started Bitcoin trading, I earned R500,000 in 3 weeks thanks Williamchurch07 really, how the does that work; the ultimate collapse of mr anc is going to be as to the lack of no due accountability urgh
Source: SundayTimesZA - 🏆 47. / 51 Read more »

EDITORIAL: Mantashe under fire as mining investment divesThe fact that SA is now among the 10 least attractive countries for mining investment underscores the story of squandered potential. Being the head of the home isn't easy, you are expected to provide for the home, I lost my job during the pandemic and relied on the little money I had,things were hard until I met Williamchurch07 and started Bitcoin trading, I earned R500,000 in 3 weeks thanks Williamchurch07
Source: FinancialMail - 🏆 20. / 63 Read more »