, and after all four costumed characters delivered their memorable performances, fans had to bid farewell to yet another one of them.
Before unmasking, the show's panel of celebrity"detectives" -- including Robin Thicke, Nicole Scherzinger, Ken Jeong and Jenny McCarthy, as well as guest panelist Nicole Byer -- made their final guesses. ET spoke with Penn about his time with Teller on the show, and the celebrated magician and TV personality reflected on how the costume itself was a bit of magical misdirection to keep their identity hidden.
"We knew that my voice is so damaged from being carney trash that I don't have a choice. I can sound like this and no other way," Penn said."So our real star was Teller. Because they didn't know Teller's voice and he did two voices... and I thought he was the absolute star of the whole show."
Beautiful