Supreme Court Rejects 'Independent State Legislature Theory,' Putting Limits on Lawmakers' Powers - Ms. Magazine

In June, the Court

to take up the case, with oral argument scheduled for Thursday, Dec. 7. The Court will likely issue its decision before July 2023.In urging the Supreme Court to reinstate the gerrymandered congressional map, the North Carolina legislators are relying on an untenable misreading of the Constitution’s Elections Clause known as the The Elections Clause delegates to states the power to regulate federal elections while giving Congress the overriding authority to make or alter such laws.

Proponents of the independent state legislature theory—like the gerrymanderers—read the Elections Clause to give state legislators near-exclusive authority to regulate federal elections, prohibiting any other state entity—like state courts or governors—from placing checks and balances on that power. In this case, the gerrymanderers are arguing that the theory licenses them to violate the state constitution when drawing congressional maps, and that the state courts do not have the power to stop them.The independent state legislature theory runs contrary to the constitutional text, history, practice and precedent. state lawmakers, so much so that when they drafted the Elections Clause, they insisted that Congress retain the ultimate power to set the rules for federal elections.

The independent state legislature theory would give state legislatures wide authority to gerrymander electoral maps and pass voter suppression laws.: It would be absurd for a state legislature to be allowed to violate the very state constitution that created it. demonstrates. For these reasons, the Supreme Court has repeatedly rejected the theory for over a century, including as recently as 2015 and 2019.

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Supreme Court says state courts can review election law, rejects independent state legislator theoryThe Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that state legislators are not the ultimate authority on how elections are conducted, reasoning that state courts can review election rules enacted by lawmakers.
Source: WashTimes - 🏆 235. / 63 Read more »

Supreme Court rejects independent state legislature theory in major election law caseBREAKING: The Supreme Court declined to limit the authority of state courts to nullify federal election rules set by state legislatures.
Source: CBSNews - 🏆 87. / 68 Read more »

Supreme Court rejects ‘independent state legislature’ theoryThe Supreme Court rejected a fringe legal theory that would have let states run elections with little judicial oversight. The 6-3 decision turns away a conservative push to empower state legislatures.
Source: politico - 🏆 381. / 59 Read more »

Supreme Court rejects independent state legislature theory: What it means for redistrictingIn a 6-3 decision authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, the Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled against North Carolina’s Republicans, saying state lawmakers do not have sole authority to set rules for federal elections without interference from state judges.
Source: aldotcom - 🏆 82. / 68 Read more »

Supreme Court Shoots Down Right-Wing ‘Independent State Legislature’ TheoryDonald Trump’s team tried to use independent state legislature theory to discard the 2020 election results. Now the Supreme Court has declined to endorse it.
Source: thedailybeast - 🏆 307. / 63 Read more »

Supreme Court rejects 'independent state legislature' theoryThe U.S. Supreme Court ruled against North Carolina Republicans who claimed the legislature has the final say over administering elections.
Source: 10News - 🏆 732. / 50 Read more »