Might trauma affect gender identity? | Opinion

A history of sexual abuse is associated with an increased risk of a lifetime diagnosis of multiple psychiatric disorders." The fact that abuse so often entailspatients with such a history, transgender or otherwise. Given today's transition-first absolutism, a more nuanced approach would be a step forward in itself.

Second, the question of childhood trauma suggests that medical professionals take caution over protocols that put hormones and scalpels first. Their current status as cure-alls surely incentivizes quick-buck diagnosis. It also disincentivizes extended therapy and non-hormonal medications that might deliver authentic, long-term relief.

Trauma deniers insist that transition-forward medical professionals know best. But as history has lately shown, well-meaning doctors buffeted between suffering patients and aggressive medical marketing can make catastrophic mistakes—especially when substantial industry profits are on the line. Last time around, just such a toxic triad produced the greatest self-inflicted public-health catastrophe in American history: the opioid crisis.

No one is suggesting a unified field theory about anything as complicated as transgenderism. But at a minimum, the troubling autobiographical details offered up by some transgender and non-binary individuals themselves suggest new grounds for questioning the current consensus. Mary Eberstadt holds the Panula Chair in Christian Culture at the Catholic Information Center, and is a senior research fellow with the Faith and Reason Institute.

Opinion Isn't the argument that people were born that way?

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

A Friend Started Secretly Dating a Much-Younger Friend. Now We’re All Stuck in the Drama.Can our friend group recover after discovering that two members have been having an ongoing toxic relationship?
Source: Slate - 🏆 716. / 51 Read more »

'PPSD' could develop after a year of 'mass trauma' – 7 signs of post-pandemic stress disorder'A lot of people have experienced some degree of trauma this past year'
Source: RedMagDaily - 🏆 312. / 61 Read more »

Argentina creates an ID for nonbinary peopleArgentina's President Alberto Fernandez announced a new National Identity Document for nonbinary people on Wednesday. The DNI's goal is to guarantee the right to gender identity for people who don't recognize themselves as either female or male, he said. And for those who don't consider themselves as human? Look at common sense…
Source: CNN - 🏆 4. / 95 Read more »

Judge Blocks Arkansas Trans Youth Treatment BanA federal judge temporarily blocked enforcement of Arkansas’s ban on gender-confirming treatments for transgender youth while a lawsuit challenging the prohibition proceeds
Source: WSJ - 🏆 98. / 63 Read more »

There Are No Reparations Equal to the Trauma of Forced SterilizationCalifornia's budget proposal factors in compensation for victims, but it's hard to imagine it ever being enough
Source: Jezebel - 🏆 153. / 63 Read more »

Banijay’s New TV Format ‘Drag Me Out’ to “Transform Celebrities Into Gender Revolutionaries”TV production giant Banijay has unveiled Drag Me Out, a new entertainment format from its Mastiff Denmark banner, which sees drag artists “transform celebrities into gender revolutionaries.” In the… Their fathers must be so proud.
Source: THR - 🏆 411. / 53 Read more »