Leonardo da Vinci’s rule for how trees branch was close, but wrong

  • 📰 ScienceNews
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 41 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 20%
  • Publisher: 63%

United States Headlines News

United States Latest News,United States Headlines

Leonardo da Vinci was wrong about trees. But he was pretty close.

Leonardo’s rule says that the thickness of a limb before it branches into smaller ones is the same asUsing surface area as a guide, the new rule incorporates limb widthslengths, and predicts that long branches end up being thinner than short ones. Unlike Leonardo’s guess, the updated rule works for slender birches as well as it does for sturdy oaks, the team reports.

This sketch from one of Leonardo da Vinci’s notebooks illustrates his original “rule of trees,” which posited that the thickness of a limb before it branches is the same as the combined thicknesses of all the limbs after it branches.The new Leonardo-like rule is an improvement, says Katherine McCulloh, a botanist at the University of Wisconsin–Madison who was not involved with this study. But she has her doubts about the Russian group’s rationale for it.

Still, the fact that the Leonardo-like rule appears to hold for many trees intrigues McCulloh. “To me, it drives home the question of why are [trees] conserving this geometry for their external tissue, and how is that related to the microscopic level differences that we observe in wood,” she says. “It’s a really interesting question.”

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

I think it’s not that important that da Vinci was close but wrong on tree branching. What matters is that, in his lifetime, he was closer to right than everyone else.

👍👍

Here's a rule. Human beings cling to distractions like crutches to get through their bleak, uninteresting lives. Sick reality, 10/10 would suffer again.

🆕 NEW BIG PROJECT 🔥 METAXA 🔥 🆕 ✅ Website Launch ✅ Social Media ✅ Marketplace Demo ✅ Burn 25% ✅ Audit ✅ KYC ✅ FairLaunch METAXA METAVERSE NEWTOKEN BSC BNB

The thickness and length determines surface area so he was right.

What kind of trees are these? I like em...

if it was 'close', it couldn't have been 'wrong', just a little bit of wrong, give him a break,

FUTURE ❓ METAVERSE ❗ This is the way of life of the future. Are you ready to witness the change? Take your place now and invest in the future now. Shall we begin ❓

I find it heartening to note that a Russian team of physicists has been looking deeply and reverently at the nature of trees and the vision of artists despite a government that is murderously dismantling natural and civic life. May their humanist science prevail.

Surface area connections is determining factor for gravitational strength.

I’ve been close lots of times. It’s really a human condition that many don’t believe applies to them. But thanks for pointing him out.

Not interested. Tell me something about someone who was right.

Vinci’s rule was from 500 years ago. Everything has evolved, including trees. Great new rule though.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 286. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Arbor Day 2022: Here's how climate change can impact treesDavey Tree Expert Company Research and Development Vice President Dr. Daniel Herms joined ABC7 to discuss how climate change can impact trees ahead of Arbor Day.
Source: ABC7Chicago - 🏆 284. / 63 Read more »

One killed, two injured in I-5 crash near Camp PendletonOne killed, two injured in I-5 crash near Camp Pendleton [Breaking]
Source: sdut - 🏆 5. / 95 Read more »

California legislature is endangering over 193 historic trees in controversial plan, tree expert says -SAN DIEGO (KUSI) – The City of San Diego chopped down age-old palm trees in Ocean Beach Monday morning despite a lawsuit from residents in the area. RELATED STORY: Residents outraged the City of San Diego cut down iconic Ocean Beach palm trees Sacramento’s Historic State Capitol Park is home to almost 1,000 unique trees but the California legislature is... So much for keeping it green. bUT mUh ClImaTE ChaNgE! Hypocrites wherethetreesat vivaparkinglots
Source: KUSINews - 🏆 241. / 63 Read more »

Why You Should Never, Ever Use Tap Water In Your Neti PotRinsing your sinuses has its perks—but can be dangerous if you do it wrong.
Source: PreventionMag - 🏆 141. / 63 Read more »

Yes, Some Pollinators Need Saving — But Honeybees Are Actually Doing Just FineIf you’ve been concerned that the honeybee is facing extinction, you're worrying about the wrong bee. Find out more on which pollinators need help by clicking the link below. Ontario beekeepers stung by devastating parasite that may impact honey, fruit growers in other provinces Writing this “by clicking the link below” at the end of your posts infuses what you say with a stigma of profiteering and click-baitness. All depends on what you want to convey.
Source: DiscoverMag - 🏆 459. / 53 Read more »

Perspective | Banning books to save kids? Please. Bullets are more dangerous.Our nation looks totally insane when parents focus on the wrong thing here. Book banning never ends well.
Source: postlocal - 🏆 327. / 59 Read more »