Judge Questions Trump Decision to Revoke U.S.-Born Woman’s Citizenship

  • 📰 WSJ
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 1 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 4%
  • Publisher: 63%

United States Headlines News

United States Latest News,United States Headlines

A federal judge questioned the State Department’s decision to revoke the citizenship of a U.S.-born woman who traveled to Syria to marry an Islamic State fighter and now wants to return home

Hoda Muthana, 24, traveled to Syria in 2014 and married a succession of Islamic State fighters before turning herself into Kurdish forces earlier this year. Her father, Ahmed Ali Muthana, is suing the Trump administration in Washington.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

She would have killed the judge over in the caliphate, she would have killed any American that wasn’t a believer, she not a victim!

She was never a citizen you tools. Her father was a diplomat in the US when she was born so it doesn’t matter.

Just another liberal. Not a Judge.

Time to remove this judge from the bench.

Yes...gave it up..

Wasn’t Obama’s State Department who ruled that she IS NOT a US citizen?

How, how in the world can anyone expect this woman to prevail in her quest to return to the USA? She obviously is a terrorist. Does our judicial system protect terrorists or law abiding citizens?

What was never given cannot be revoked. She was never a U.S. Citizen to begin with. 14A SubjectToTheJurisdictionThereof DiplomaticImmunity

During Obama Administration “Court records show that the State Department sent a letter revoking Ms. Muthana’s passport in January 2016, after determining the document was issued “illegally, fraudulently or erroneously.”

Excelent decition

Dude.... SHES A LEGITIMATE TERRORIST?!?!?!?!?

She won't live long if she makes it back. American prob would be willing for the boy. She can die there or ruin her sons life her and then still die

Is not the Islamic state a terrorist group

CChristineFair Shameless

Throw the judge out of the country. or bring her home and execute her.

This woman is a terrorist a traitor, if she comes home we must prosecute

Hey judge, bring her to your house and assume full responsibility for her

Even if her citizenship is not revoked she will be facing prison , Trump is a crazy man

She wants to return to spread more terrorism here? BIG FAT NO

This isn't her home anymore.

And, participated in terrorist acts of violence.

Let's bring back a woman who called for attacks on Americans on veterans day etc. Of course she shouldn't be a citizen. She is a terrorist who wants Americans dead

Should definitely be revoked - who knows her real motivation to return to US - better safe than sorry!

She want to come back so her ISIS baby can find out how he is when he gets older he will be the buggiest terrorist in the US.

WSJ, you mean the dems aren't even welcoming her home ?

Again, the media siding against the majoririty which is why ur known as the enemy of the people!

Tell her to stay wherever the hell she is

Outtttt please !!!!

The judge need to be removed too.

Why can’t she go to Guantanamo Bay

B/C ...she can face justice as American citizen....the state department play a warm supremacists scary game,plus the unconstitutional decision will be revoke...There are other priorities...I wonder who is the head of the justice department..

charge her with treason

Bye Felicia

IslamicStateSupporter islamicterrorism NeverForget911 3rdjihad

“An Islamic State Fighter!?” You mean 3 ISIS TERRORISTS!

The woman clearly is a traitor.

She is a terrorist and an enemy combatant.

Enemy combatant

Unconstitutional ! , Bring her here and press charge ,let her face trial to lock her in prison .

Hola como están tiene todo su derecho muchas gracias

Brief is misleading. Judge rejects fast track as there is no demonstrated threat against her.

She is a ProdigalDaughter ! And her citizenship deserves a DueProcess hearing !

As much as I hope she doesn’t come back, her father was no longer a diplomat when she was born on US soil, which is what defines a natural citizen, and she deserves due process like anyone else born here.

She keeps saying she has NO citizenship. She is from Libya so she should have Libyan citizenship. Her father was a diplomat. So don't fall for the BS on TV.

She gave up her rights when she became a terrorist.

Wow, now she doesn’t have to file a Form 1040? You rock lady!

She stay here with me ! HAWAII

I think revoking citizenships without due process is scary. So 2 options, revoke with due process, and/or, let me come back and try hr for treason.

Revoking citizenship to born citizens who served in Army, or diplomacy, for foreign countries is an accepted standard worldwide. It comes from Roman Law under the name of 'ostracism'.

Bring her to Guantanamo Bay

Gov stated she wasn't a citizen. Has that changed? Not possible to revoke citizenship of a non citizen.

CChristineFair She is where she belongs in a sharia compliant eutopian land. No need to come back

betrayer

Ra'd

She should be begging to stay there. How many years in prison is she facing if she returns here?

Let me guess. The Ninth Circuit of Hell at it again?

If she comes back, can we execute her?

If you propose taking up arms against America- you are a traitor-see Benedict Arnold

She wants to kill american. What will happen after she comes back? She will hire a vehicle and drive down to kill american. And tell story to her children that her 3 husbands been killed by american so they have to take revenge.

I don't think her citizenship can be revoked unilaterally; rather, the question is whether she ever had US citizenship. Children of diplomats aren't automatically given citizenship. He had surrendered his diplomatic status, but was that enough to get her citizenship? Dunno.

When you defect your country Your country's dead to you You've lost any trust you had Gave up your citizenship too … … … … … … … … … …

Didn’t she revoke herself first? And wasn’t this started (precedent) during Obama admin?

This federal judge must be a Muslim terrorist sympathizer...!!!!

Ninth district?

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 98. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Trump wrongly says Islamic State holds no land in SyriaWASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump asserted on Thursday that the Islamic State group has lost 100 percent of the territory it once controlled in Syria, but U.S. officials in Washington and accounts from people in Syria said a sliver of land remains contested. Fake accounts fake accounts! realDonaldTrump No kidding? MEANING - Trump is LYING AGAIN!
Source: YahooNews - 🏆 380. / 59 Read more »

Yazidis freed from Islamic State captivity in Syria, returned to IraqA group of Yazidi women and children returned to Iraq from Syria on Friday after... 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Let’s praise all our gods!! bigs liars. Freed at last.
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

Timeline: The rise and fall of Islamic State in Iraq and SyriaIslamic State faces territorial defeat as U.S.-backed Syrian forces attack its f... Was it intentional?. The rise of the Islamic State the US invasion of Iraq the fall of the Islamic State Russia steps in Thanks President Trump 😀👍🇺🇸 maga
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

Islamic State faces final territorial defeat in eastern Syria battleIslamic State faced final territorial defeat on Saturday as the U.S.-backed Syri... *Territorial* defeat. The Nazis were 'defeated' once too. Wars don't solve problems. Toyota, biggest sponsor of Terrorism since the state of Iran.
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

On brink of Syria defeat, Islamic State unleashes car bombsIslamic State launched suicide car bombs against the Syrian Democratic Forces (S... Bye felicia ISLAMIC STATE IS FATE AND LET IT DETONATE::::::BECAUSE THEY KISS THE STONE::::::LIKE APOPHIS ONE::::::BUT IN HEAVEN GODDES MOTHER NATURE::::::BURNS ALSO THESE CREATURES:::::::BECAUSE THEY PRAY TO WHICH GOD? FORGOT:::::::THE GOD WHOSE SPOKE FROM PARADISE IF THEY WILL KILL::: :::::SO MUCH HOW CAN::::::CHRISTIANS::::::THESE HOLY VETERANS FROM WHO:::::::ALLLLLAAAAAHHHHHH ALLLLLLAAAAAAAHHHHHH::::::MACHINE GUN FIRE::::::ANGEL A THIS WAS YOUR DESIRE::::::NOW WHAT WE ALL WILL DESIRE::::::HIRE THE WIRE:::::OR BURN IN FIRE
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

Attack slows on Islamic State Syria pocket to save civilians: officialU.S.-backed forces are slowing down their offensive against the last Islamic Sta... Aaaaand that’s how we lose.
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

150 Islamic State fighters surrender in Syria battle: monitorScores of Islamic State fighters surrendered to U.S.-backed forces on Monday, a ... So those DAESH didn't actually believe their SEX after life in their heaven lol
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

'This isn't over': Islamic State loyalties linger despite defeatHaving joined Islamic State in Syria four years ago, the Algerian woman only aba... I don’t imagine it is. But I would not want to be an ISIS member and stick my bearded head above any sandbag! as if there would be any detractors . Bunch of mercenaries
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

Islamic State supporters and victims flee the ruins of its 'caliphate'Hundreds more people of many nationalities streamed out of Islamic State's ... they should stay in that beautiful mess they made
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »

The Islamic State is dying ... but believers in its radical ideology live onShe was covered from head to toe in black. Identifying herself only as Um Bassam, the mother of Bassam, she told me she was 25 years old, the mother of four children, a widow, and from the city of Aleppo. Isis are NOTHING but a Bunch of Wimpy, Little Sissies. President Trump and Our GREAT American Military, (along with our allies), have COMPLETELY & TOTALLY DOMINATED Isis. Isis has COMPLETELY & TOTALLY SUBMITTED to President Trump, Our GREAT American Military and our allies. Yep you can't eradicated a bad idea. We also have Greenpeace and The New Green Deal. Ideology can be acted against by providing the better example, the leading example for healthy and more happy living! Also the more ethical and moral, not by providing excuses for cannibals!We too have the word of Almighty dear: The 10 Commandments! Religious Stupid is w/Atheism
Source: CNN - 🏆 4. / 95 Read more »

Family devastated by Belgian ruling not to bring back Islamic State childrenA Belgian court's decision to overturn a ruling forcing it to repatriate tw... Yet, a nation rejoices They should eff off to the caliphate Family devastated by relatives' decision to leave Belgium to join and fight for a terrorist organization in a war in which they were defeated and captured.
Source: Reuters - 🏆 2. / 97 Read more »