Demo Reel Clips Ruled Fair Use in Director's Suit Against Actress

Director Robin Bain in 2016 sued actress Jessica Haid over her the of clips from 'Nowhereland' on her acting reel.

8/11/2020 12:17:00 AM

An actress using clips from an unreleased movie for her acting reel is transformative and doesn't harm the market for that film, a California federal judge has ruled

Director Robin Bain in 2016 sued actress Jessica Haid over her the of clips from 'Nowhereland' on her acting reel.

Director Robin Bain in May 2018from her 2016 filmNowhereland for using clips from the movie on her demo reel without permission. The actress Jessica Taylor Haid hired L.A. MediaWorks to edit her reel and the company removed watermarks from the clips, which prompted claims for copyright infringement and violations of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Hain countersued for breach of contract and failure to pay minimum wage, among other claims, saying she was exposed to unsafe conditions on set and wasn't adequately paid for her work.

Can Circuit Breakers Stop Viral Rumors On Facebook, Twitter? New Data Reveals Music’s Importance to TikTok’s Gen Z Audience September 22 coronavirus news

After a failed arbitration, Haid moved for summary judgment arguing that the use of the clips on her reel qualified as fair use and she lacked the required intent to be liable under the DMCA. Bain also filed a motion for partial summary judgment, arguing that Haid's claims were barred by the statute of limitations. 

U.S. District Judge Percy Anderson on Friday granted summary judgment in Haid's favor. While Anderson found the nature of the copyrighted work favored Bain, the rest of the fair use factors weighed in favor of Haid: it's transformative, uses a limited portion of the film and doesn't substantially harm the market for

Nowhereland, which was also distributed under the titleGirl Lost."Haid’s reel is transformative," finds Anderson. "Unlike the Film, which seeks to tell a story involving the sexual exploitation of women, the reel tells no story. The reel’s purpose is to provide information about Haid’s acting abilities so that casting directors may become interested in casting her in other roles. The reel changes the original work by showing mostly brief portions of selected scenes in a manner that conveys little information about the plot of the film."

Further, Anderson found "no reasonable probability that distribution of an actor’s reel like those prepared for Haid to casting directors — the intended 'market' for such a reel — would interfere with the profitability of or market for a film."

With regard to the watermark issue, Anderson found Bain failed to establish that Haid is liable for LA Media's removal of the mark or that the actress acted with the requisite knowledge to sustain such a claim under the DMCA. (Read the full order below.)

Anderson declined to exercise jurisdiction over the state law claims and dismissed them without prejudice, but discouraged the parties from pursuing them in state court because the amount they've already spent on lawyers "far exceeds" the monetary value of their claims. 

No If's, And's or Butts: Diplo Wants *You* to Register to Vote During This Election Supergirl Is Ending After Season 6 - E! Online Malcolm Nance: Putin finds Trump ‘an absolutely easy mark to manipulate’

"This is, frankly, a dispute that should have been resolved long ago, through arbitration or mutual agreement," says Anderson. "Instead, the parties have unnecessarily taxed both this Court’s, and their own, limited resources. The parties should consider this admonition prior to any party seeking an award of attorneys’ fees or pursuing remedies in another court."

Read more: Hollywood Reporter »

Trump on America surpassing 200,000 coronavirus deaths: 'Well, I think it's a shame'

The coronavirus pandemic has brought countries to a standstill. In many places, as countries reopen, Covid-19 cases are on the rise. Follow here for the latest.

If she has followed all security protocols for online display of her reel with encryption passwords. The director or production can’t do anything about it. If the actress wasn't going to profit from the film, it's fair use. And really this case could be settled out of the court. 'Best true crime book in years!'

How exactly does this director think the actress is suppose to show her ability if the few films etc can’t even be used even a bit. This is going to help those struggling actors/actresses with job hunting big time. Nobody has seen 'nowhere land' so yeah no harm no foul.

‘Lion’ Director Garth Davis To Direct Disney’s New ‘Tron’ Movie With Jared LetoEXCLUSIVE: After taking its time figuring out where its wants the next Tron installment to go, Disney’s sci-fi franchise looks to have new life as we are hearing Garth Davis has been tapped t… OK, but what about the TronLegacy cast ? DaftPunk? JosephKosinski ? Great news , yay!!!!!! Wait till the alt right finds out Lion has nothing to do with Lion king. Actually it’s about...

McDonald’s sues ex-CEO Steve Easterbrook over alleged sexual relationships with staff membersThe fast-food giant has filed suit against former CEO Steve Easterbrook, whom it accuses of concealing sexual relationships with three employees. I'm Lovin' It McNookie wasn't on the menu.... (I am lovin it)

Lebanon Information Minister Resigns In Wake Of Deadly ExplosionThe resignation comes amid protests against the country's ruling elite, blamed for the negligence that is believed to be behind the blast. The failure of the Lebanese Govt is exposed. I wonder when Hezbollah will make a coup and take over. Yozeck1 عقبال الكل. Coming to a neighborhood NEAR YOU SOON. This is what's in store for the USA if WE VOTE DEMOCRATIC. THIS IS ACTULLY WAHT THEY WANT! WE BETTER WAKE the F UP!

Scammers are already selling millions of fake views for Instagram Reels - Business InsiderBusiness Insider is a fast-growing business site with deep financial, media, tech, and other industry verticals. Launched in 2007, the site is now the largest business news site on the web.

Gayle Rankin on the Many Faces of Humanity in 'Perry Mason''The amount you can learn from women then—it took me aback. You look at it on paper, and a young wife in the 1930s is not what I want to be doing in 2020.' GayleRankin talks to mynameiskeely about PerryMason and GLOW season 4.

Melanie Griffith Celebrates Birthday With FaceTimes From Ex-HusbandsThe actress has stayed on good terms with her exes years later. Well God damn I didn't even know they divorced obama is such a playa