Benefits of digital fitness trackers don't trickle down to those with lower incomes. Via InsideScience.
The benefits of digital fitness trackers are often out of reach for those with lower incomes, new research confirms.
Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.Sean Gallup/Getty ImagesInside Sciencestory.Technologies like smartwatches, mobile apps and websites have been touted as an accessible and effective way for people to monitor and increase their physical activity and improve their health. But a new analysis has found that that is really only true for people of high socioeconomic status. As with so many other areas of health care, poorer people appear to see little to no benefit from these digital interventions.
"Even though people might have the same access to these interventions, we're still seeing this pernicious inverse care law -- the people who need this stuff most are least likely to receive it in an effective way," said Mark Kelson, who studies health statistics at the University of Exeter in the U.K.
Kelson and his colleagues analyzed the data from 19 different studies conducted around the world between 1990 and 2020 that looked at digital interventions intended to help increase physical activity and improve health. They then compared how the interventions affected people of higher and lower socioeconomic status, and found what Kelson calls one of the clearest and most robust results he has ever seen in his career. For those of high socioeconomic status there was a moderate positive effect -- those who received the interventions increased their physical activity by around 1,500 to 2,500 steps per day compared with those who didn't receive interventions. But there was virtually no effect among those of lower socioeconomic status. The results were headtopics.com
this month in the International Journal of Behavioural Nutrition and Physical Activity.Sean Gallup/Getty ImagesThe Fitbit Sense health smartwatch lies on display at the Fitbit stand at the IFA 2020 Special Edition consumer electronics and appliances trade fair, Sept. 3, 2020, in Berlin.
This is the kind of result that"strikes fear into the heart of behavioral interventionists," said Kelson, because the health need is much greater in economically deprived groups -- poorer people tend to be less active and to have more health problems than richer ones. So in this case the people who need help the most are the ones deriving the least benefit, while those who need it least get more of a boost."Everyone is keen to increase physical activity to improve public health," he said."But even with the best of intentions we might end up increasing health disparity. We really need to be paying attention to the socioeconomic divide."
The study did not examine why people of lower socioeconomic status with the same access to an intervention like a step counter and associated fitness app would get less benefit. But Kelson speculates there are likely a few overlapping reasons for the disparity. Poorer people tend to have less free time for leisure activity, which is the category of physical activity associated with the most health benefits, so they have less capacity to take advantage of digital interventions focused on exercise. And people with lower socioeconomic status also tend to be less familiar with the use of the digital technologies involved in these interventions, which affects how well they engage with them, the researchers wrote in the paper.
MORE: Breakthrough in electronic display fabrics could help pave the way for smart clothingThe first step to overcoming this digital divide is for researchers to acknowledge it, and then explore it more systematically in their studies, Kelson said. But they should also consider how they design their interventions and look for ways to make the technology more accessible and useful to poorer people. headtopics.com
Lucy Yardley, a health psychologist at the University of Bristol, said a more person-based approach to designing digital health interventions can help reduce the disparities in outcome between socioeconomic classes. That means public health experts must put in the hard work to understand what barriers their subjects are encountering, and constantly revise the intervention until those barriers are gone.
These tweaks can be as simple as changing the language used. Most digital fitness interventions are written for an average reading level of college graduates, for example, which can make them more difficult for people with lower levels of literacy to engage with. Or they may lack clear definitions of terms. In one project aimed at increasing physical activity among people with diabetes who had lower levels of health literacy, Yardley found that many had misunderstood what counted as"moderate intensity" exercise and were inputting much higher levels of activity into the planner, and so getting the wrong advice as a result.
MORE: These are the molecules that help make coffee awesomeOther tweaks can involve dealing with barriers of time, money or location, Yardley said. Instead of suggesting a long walk in a park that might not be accessible, researchers could offer simple exercises that people can do at home in front of the TV, with a couple of cans of food."You need to start with the person in their context, understand their needs and motivations, and base the intervention around that," said Yardley.
Kelson said that addressing socioeconomic barriers will also benefit the researchers designing and studying the interventions. When some study subjects are getting no benefit, averaging the result across all participants ends up reducing the effect you would see under ideal conditions. headtopics.com
"We need to come up with something that is accessible for a large group of people, but a different set from the ones who most of the activity interventions are catering to," said Yardley.is an editorially independent nonprofit print, electronic and video journalism news service owned and operated by the American Institute of Physics.Read more: ABC News »
Audible Creators Talk the Past and Future of Audio Storytelling
As a young working actor in Scotland, Alan Cumming worked extensively in radio, performing in radio plays for Radio 4 and BBC throughout the 80s and 90s. When he came to the U.S. for acting roles, … Read more >>
InsideScience They are over priced, not affordable by low income people - how can they be affordable ? InsideScience More spying devices. InsideScience Well, duh... InsideScience Maybe they can sell a pair of sneakers. InsideScience Great InsideScience You don't have to buy the 300$ ones ya know. I bought a fitness band for $35. Counts steps, sleep, heart rate, oxygen, and it shows my calls and texts. Shop around.
InsideScience Public enemy 1: The Media InsideScience Just bought a replacement Fitbit for $60. Well worth it. It doesn’t require any official ‘exercise’ or smartphone. Most important info is on the watch. During my 3 day wait, kept thinking, “there’s no way I’d be in the shape I’m in now, without my Fitbit”. It keeps you moving.
InsideScience I'm retired and on a fixed income. I can't afford one. InsideScience So what? Not everyone can afford everything. I’d love to have a private plane but guess what… I can’t afford one. That’s life. InsideScience It never does. Smart watches, iPads, hybrid cars, 401Ks... If you can't afford it, it can't possibly help you.
Shopping: Amazon’s Best Cyber Monday Deals on Smart TVs, Soundbars, Fitness Trackers and MoreUpgrade your home theater, workouts, gaming setup or winter wardrobe with these top deals on tech, fashion and more. There is no greater joy than having financial stability and a life free of debts, that’s why I keep tweeting about RussellHodge_ he's for transparency and trust 💯
InsideScience Looting pays off InsideScience Alternate Headline: People with less money can afford less. InsideScience Ha - common sense and a responsible lifestyle will outperform any fitness tracker... InsideScience Benefits of private helicopters don’t trickle down to those with lower incomes. “Journalisming”
InsideScience Once upon a time people exercised without all these devices. Weird! InsideScience You can get a digital fitness tracker for under £20. I've seen a busboy with the latest Apple Watch. I found an apple watch in a skip, bought the charger (£2) - my cheap tracker worked better. The only extra thing the apple could do - count floors - but it got it wrong.
The Best Cyber Monday Deals To Shop At Amazon, Including 50% Off Tablets And Fitness TrackersAmazon's Cyber Monday Sale is bringing big discounts on electronics, toys, home goods, and more. If you don’t think institutions and large corporations are loading their wallets with Bitcoin, you’re mistaken. Follow up with Danielalbino121 and load your wallet and make more profit with his platform With his company platform I have added massively to my holdings
Omicron Variant Highlights Risks of Low Vaccination Rates in Poor CountriesThe wide gap in vaccination rates between wealthy nations and lower-income countries helped open the door to the rise of the Omicron coronavirus variant, public-health officials say the masks are the only thing keeping this fictional virus alive. WSJ knows Covid19 is about world war mainly between capitalist china and the US White, people are still trying make Blackpeople the face of this disease....half of all diseases are zoominc... No mention of the hypothesis that populations with untreated HIV/AIDS can serve as reservoirs in which coronaviruses can reproduce (and mutate) over more generations. Countries with excess vaccine supply might do well to redirect it to areas with untreated HIV/AIDS.
Black Friday Deals You Can Still Shop Today: Nordstrom, BaubleBar, Anthropologie & More - E! OnlineBlack Friday Deals You Can Still Shop Today: Nordstrom, BaubleBar, Anthropologie & More With their worst defeat in Afghanistan, the American century is over already. They have done enough atrocities all over the world. Either it be Vietnam, Lybia, Afghanistan, Irak, or you name it. They have killed millions of people.
What Is Taxable Income And How Does It Work?Most people get money from various sources: wages from a job, investment returns, income from a business, Social Security benefits, and more. Some of that income is taxable, and some isn’t, which makes calculating your taxable income—and estimating how much tax you’ll owe—challenging. However, estimating your taxable income before filing your tax return can help […]
All The Best Black Friday Fitness DealsYou can save a *ton* on fitness gear, workout equipment, and gym apparel this Black Friday weekend.