Astros Players Cheated. Baseball Wanted Answers. So They Made a Deal.

  • 📰 WSJ
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 13 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 8%
  • Publisher: 63%

United States Headlines News

United States Latest News,United States Headlines

Why were no players penalized in the baseball sign-stealing scandal? MLB and the MLB Players Association struck an agreement that granted immunity in exchange for honest testimony.

In a scathing investigatory report released last week, Major League Baseball commissioner Rob Manfred repeatedly refers to the Houston Astros’ sign-stealing scheme in 2017 and 2018 as “player-driven.” Yet Manfred also declared: “I will not assess discipline against individual Astros players.”

So while Manfred suspended Houston general manager Jeff Luhnow and field manager A.J. Hinch for the 2020 season—they were later fired—no active players were even named for their involvement. Manfred justified that decision by saying...

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

yankees Articles like these didn't provide notice to cheating Astros that electronic sign stealing was prohibited? That's why the players hide monitors, other equipment? That's why Manfred gave immunity? Because the players thought they were innocent?

jareddiamond Every team in the MLB should refuse to play them. Don't even allow them in visiting stadiums and damn sure don't travel to Houston. Will the players union file a grievance against other players?

MLB didn’t want to take on the Union.

So then why was Beltran named? I understand that he’s not protected by the union anymore but naming him was unfair to his current team.

Manfred is a coward.

Astros 30 pieces of silver

This is bs mann total bs..i hope it continues and the leage gets ruined.

I want to know what will happen to the players that lied during the investigation. We already know Carlos Beltran did. I understand they r trying to get the truth, but are there repercussions to players that lied?

jareddiamond This is utter Bullshit. They are not 5 year old children that need to be taught right from wrong. Manfred issued immunity because they weren’t instructed not to cheat by the GM These guys are getting paid millions. SMH Cheats HOUSTONASTROS MLB

Cheating will be met with “severe punishment” according to MLB! Then do it - vacate Astros pennant and world series! Send the strongest possible message to teams, and more importantly, one that will set an example for our kids - the future players.

Baseball is a historically crooked game. Sign stealing, steroids, corked bats, prospects lying about age, hi grass, cold clubhouses, speed, Adderall, spitballs on and o.

jareddiamond I wonder what would happen if a Tech driven cheating scandal erupted .WSOP ? (World series of Poker) What would the wsop do? My guess is lifetime banishment from all events and casino's. I'm sure titles would be striped money repaid plus criminal charges. No immunity mlb

Even when MLB comes off looking tough against cheating, they still bow to the feel of the players union, lol.

If a sprinter wins the gold medal but is caught cheating, the gold medal is stripped. Major League Basball MUST strip the Astros of their title to save the integrity of the game.

Sources of this deal? Not even anonymous? How do you know?

So reinstate the “black” Sox.

They should be passed over for Hall of Fame consideration.

It's math. They know the problem is wide spread. If they set the precedent of suspending players and 5-10 teams get implicated in the next 2 years, they end up suspending 1/3rd of the major league. That hurts the product more than the crime.

I can appreciate the MLB wanting a relatively quick investigation and player honesty. However, surely, players knew this was wrong in the moment. I believe this is a sad time for children who unfortunately continuously see adults making unethical decisions.

Players, coaches and owners should all be in deep shit. But, it’s all about the money. Protect the brand that has been flailing.

jareddiamond Cheaters

Not right

'Honest testimony'? What a joke!! You really think these guys are going to admit they cheated to win a WS? Of course not. MLB is so scared of the player's union it's ridiculous. The players should be suspended just like management was.

Vacate their World Series win. That should be enough of a punishment. Don't reward them for being scumbags.

They need to give back those rings! Earned in shame. Memo To: Grand Children This is my World Series ring. We earned by cheating.

If someone could prove they used Buzzers, wouldn't that negate the immunity?

abrosh21, it's too bad if this is true.

They will be punished by their opponent pitchers this year ,they will be porked more than ever before

Taking notes from the White House , if the president can lie with impunity and never be held account why would anyone else be truthful .

Weak position by MLB. Should have brought in the lawyers to investigate.

Individual teams can punish players, though. Cut those who cheated and don’t sign them.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 98. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Astros players will apologize publicly for sign-stealing schemeHouston Astros owner Jim Crane said the team will apologize publicly for stealing opposing teams' pitching signs: 'We'll apologize for what happened, ask for forgiveness and move forward.' Cheating paid off for the Astros...💰 Astros won their World Series and reaped all the financial gains from their fans already. Now the Astros just ask for forgiveness which costs them nothing. ✅ Not that simple.
Source: CNN - 🏆 4. / 95 Read more »

Column: Astros' appalling lack of remorse for sign-stealing is another affront to the DodgersFrom columnist BillPlaschke: The Houston Astros are still cheating the Dodgers by not recognizing the pain their sign-stealing brought. There's been zero accountability from players. BillPlaschke spikes high in 2020 BillPlaschke BillPlaschke What about the Rays?
Source: latimes - 🏆 11. / 82 Read more »

Mendoza cowardly blames A's Fiers for the Astros scandalJessica Mendoza Blames A's Mike Fiers For Making Astros Scandal Public (via NBCSAuthentic) NBCSAuthentic Who's Jessica mendoza? NBCSAuthentic A Very Trumpian Move to Blame the Whistleblower NBCSAuthentic Aren’t you like days late on this?
Source: TMZ - 🏆 379. / 59 Read more »

Los Angeles councilmen to request MLB award World Series titles to Dodgers following Astros sign-stealing scandalOfficials in Los Angeles believe they have found a way to rectify the World Series titles they feel they were cheated out of during the sign-stealing scandal surrounding the Houston Astros. I know it’s unfair they lost to the Astros who cheated, but it would also be unfair to all the teams that actually won the World Series fairly if you awarded the championship to the Dodgers. I’m sure MLB will do that right after getting Mike Greenwell an MVP award. I live in Houston. They should replay the game in LA and give the Dodgers the cameras.......then award the the trophy to the Dodgers no matter the outcome. (I had to return a stolen chewed up piece of gum when I was little. It works. Never took anything ever again.)
Source: ABC - 🏆 471. / 51 Read more »

Mendoza cowardly blames A's Fiers for the Astros scandalJessica Mendoza Blames A's Mike Fiers For Making Astros Scandal Public (via NBCSAuthentic) NBCSAuthentic Who's Jessica mendoza? NBCSAuthentic A Very Trumpian Move to Blame the Whistleblower NBCSAuthentic Aren’t you like days late on this?
Source: TMZ - 🏆 379. / 59 Read more »

Column: Astros' appalling lack of remorse for sign-stealing is another affront to the DodgersFrom columnist BillPlaschke: The Houston Astros are still cheating the Dodgers by not recognizing the pain their sign-stealing brought. There's been zero accountability from players. BillPlaschke spikes high in 2020 BillPlaschke BillPlaschke What about the Rays?
Source: latimes - 🏆 11. / 82 Read more »