'Antebellum,' starring Janelle Monáe, is a slavery revenge fantasy gone sideways. K. Austin Collins' review
Janelle Monáe stars in a brash debut from filmmakers Gerard Bush and Christopher Renz that tackles America’s original sin
How the movie gets there is not fair to spoil. What can be said, however, is that the beginning of the movie is hardly the beginning of the ordeal it depicts. And, bolstered by the strength of its admirable and talented cast — which includes Kiersey Clemons, Gabourey Sidibe, Jena Malone, Tongayi Chirisa, and Jack Huston — the movie is good at getting a good number of ideas going at once.
This is in part a credit toAntebellum’s amalgam of influences, which are perhaps the most intriguing thing about it. With its insistence on courting the gaze of a specifically black audience, with its sinuous mix of horror and racial commentary, Bush and Renz’s project of course earns comparison to Jordan Peele’s
Get Out, a phenomenon whose global success can safely be credited with making the green-lighting of projects likeAntebellummuch more viable to begin with. More interesting, though, are the connections to a broader cultural lineage. Fans of the late, great Octavia Butler’s pioneering speculative fiction will no doubt notice the premise’s similarity to that author’s 1979 novel
Kindred, in which a 20th-century black woman finds herself transplanted to the Antebellum south and forced to reckon not only with the thorns of her own racial ancestry, but with the real violence of enslavement — violence that surpasses analogy or allegory and which implicitly indicts the risks of modern ignorance. Case in point: the novel opens with its heroine missing an arm.
There’s also something to be said for the ways thatAntebellum’s broad, ironic arc — not from slavery to freedom, but rather the nightmarish reverse — owes a great deal to the specific form of enslavement documented by Solomon Northup, whoseTwelve Years a Slave: Narrative of Solomon Northup
(1853) inspired Steve McQueen’s Oscar-winning12 Years of a Slaveand provides a psychological road map to the terrorsAntebellumis dredging up. Being born into enslavement is hard enough to wrap one’s mind around. But the idea of being snatched from freedom and progress is, for any beneficiary of these privileges, somehow even more unimaginable — maybe even more terrifying, because it literalizes the fear at the heart of anyone who knows that all freedom is malleable: that it always comes with a price, with one such price being the terror of losing it.
At its heart, and at its best,Antebellumis a grand play on what we know people really mean when they shout to “Make America Great Again.” If, for you, a return to America’s past is an especially dangerous prospect, there’s no way to hear this slogan but as an explicit call for social progress to be reversed, for freedom to be re-denied, for racism and other forms of bigotry — none of which have left us — to again enjoy the impunity of a suppressive social order. It is, for many, a terrifying thought.
What also cannot be denied, because it has by now been made imminently clear, is that some people would all too happily enjoy the privilege. Which is whyAntebellumalso can’t help but bring to mind franchises likeWestworld, and everything that its premise, in which rich people get to cosplay America’s lawless frontier West for kicks, seems to invoke.
One thingAntebellum’s panoply of influences have in common, explicitly or not, is a distinct interest in class privilege — an interestAntebellumshares, but not without some cringe-inducing complication. The movie is rife with class signifiers: from the size and abundance of Veronica’s family home, to her professional status as an academic and public intellectual, to the yoga and veganism, the Ubers and champagne populating her everyday life. The movie doesn’t forget to draw a line between the role this plays in making her a target for what is going to happen to her over the course of the movie.
But it wears this connection a little uneasily. Rather, it seems to take a few things about capital — the beating heart of slavery — a little too easily for granted. In recent years, it’s begun to feel too easy for the empowerment-forward professional class to wield historical disenfranchisement, and slavery most especially, as a metaphor for contemporary social ills. It is very much the case that slavery by another name, as the journalist and author Douglas A. Blackmon has put it, exists in the present; much of modern freedom is still made possible by forced labor.
Slavery is what ought to come to mind when we hear of incarcerated men being conscripted to fight our nation’s wildfires, protecting the homes of the free when they are not free. That’s to say nothing of the slavery that still exists worldwide. As recently as this week, Kanye West
has likenedthe music industry to a form of enslavement and the NBA to a slave ship, images that are only as rhetorically powerful as our ability to overlook the immediate, incomparable reality of wrought-iron chains.Maybe these questions, which are questions of ideology, would find finer resolution in a movie that kept a closer eye on the rich nuances of its characters. But this is where
Antebellumnot only fails but, at times, flails — in part because the details it provides, the interactions in which the film grounds itself, keep getting bulldozed by the locomotion of its plot. There’s a sense that Veronica’s time on the plantation needn’t be overly elaborated, because we all know how life in a plantation is meant to play out. But the view of plantation life we get is — it’s difficult not to notice — primarily concerned with the humiliations faced by black women, specifically, while in the same moment not especially rigorous or careful in the ways it details that humiliation. All that these women have to show for the pain, in the end, is a high body count.
A somewhat-exception, and probably the most electric stretch of the movie, is a dinner between Veronica and a pair of colleagues (including Dawn, played by Sidibe), in which a man sending a drink to the table results in an eyebrow-raising show of flirtatious entitlement. Sidibe’s character overall risks colliding a bit unfortunately with the stereotype of the louder, sassier sidekick to a skinny lead, and this movie isn’t absolved from that. But there’s real abrasion in what Sidibe offers the scene, which starts with her berating a white waitress and calling her Becky. On the other hand, we’re encouraged to sit, for a moment, with a chilling idea: that Veronica and Dawn risk being punished, not only for being black women, but for daring to be demanding and confident black women — and daring to make demands, even rude ones, of white people.
Of all the movies one could recall at that moment, I thought back toGreen Book, and to the truth it wears on its face, apparently unbeknownst even to the movie: that few things can seem more vexing or infuriating to latent white racism than the merest idea of black “privilege,” the slightest hint of a black way of being that refuses to accept secondary status or know its place.
Antebellum, to its credit, makes this tension somewhat explicit. But in its barreling toward what begins to feel like a foregone conclusion, it cuts its exploration of that idea painfully short.The movie isn’t without its climactic satisfaction: It offers black audiences the escape hatch of reciprocal violence that revenge narratives deploy as a rule. But even this gets marred a little when the complex pleasure of vengeance is doled out in a conclusory overdose of beauteous empowerment imagery. For all its fiery comeuppance, the end of the movie is wanting. It’s a neat bow on the story it tells. But the tragedies at its center tumble on, unaffected.Read more: Rolling Stone »
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg honored in historic ceremony at US Capitol
The late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was the first woman to lie in state at the U.S. Capitol.
Janelle Monáe's radical rebellionWelcome to JanelleMonae's rebellion. For our new digital cover, the Antebellum star details rising to meet the challenge of her first starring film role, from honoring Black women's work to self-advocacy. Story by marcus_jones antebellumfilm JanelleMonae marcus_jones Yes!!!!!!!🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥so proud of this queen! JanelleMonae marcus_jones JanelleMonae marcus_jones
Singer Lady A Is Not Backing Down in Legal Fight With Lady AntebellumSeattle blues singer Lady A, who has been in a legal battle with the country band formerly known as Lady Antebellum after they edited their name without consulting her, is not backing down. She is now suing the Lady A band for “lost sales, diminished brand identity, and diminution in the value of and goodwill associated with the mark” as well as trademark infringement and unfair competition. Allies We know. TheRealLadyA ladya I mean ladyantiblm Drop the suit. Pick a new name. Your poorly researched PR stunt turned intense legal battle is not a good look.
Seattle singer Lady A files countersuit against band formerly known as Lady AntebellumThe battle between the singer known as Lady A and the band Lady A (formerly called Lady Antebellum) appears bound for a courtroom. I hope she wins Good. Hope she wins. Those fools knew what “antebellum” meant when they chose it. When it's time too sue it's time too do that.
How Ho Che Anderson's Neo-Noir 'Stone' Crosses GenresThe latest release from indie digital publisher NeoText sees comics creator Ho Che Anderson turn his hand to a noir revenge fantasy
Horrors of slavery at center of Janelle Monae's 'Antebellum'NEW YORK (AP) — Janelle Monae says she “felt so much rage and anger” when she stepped onto a former slave plantation for the first time to film the psychological thriller “Antebellum.” In... jacarucci When you get indoctrinated by an ideology that makes you believe this shit, the social construct you're living in brings up that anger in you instead of showing understanding for the history of your country. jacarucci She should read into some Stoicism, after she has her emotions not under control. 😇 jacarucci gaslighting
‘Lady A’ Files Trademark Countersuit Against Nashville TrioAnita White, the artist who goes by “Lady A,” filed a countersuit for trademark infringement on Tuesday against the Nashville trio formerly known as Lady Antebellum. Lady Antebellum cha… You go girl! So unfair the way they stole your name! Hope that she gets ALL of her coins. Good! Fuck ladya