When should British schools reopen? Here's what the science tells us | Devi Sridhar and Ines Hassan

  • 📰 The Guardian
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 1 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 4%
  • Publisher: 53%

United Kingdom Headlines News

United Kingdom Latest News,United Kingdom Headlines

We need to get children back into education, but a locally managed approach using testing and tracing is the only way, say public health experts Devi Sridhar and Ines Hassan

The big debate over the past few days has been whether it’s safe to open schools to children other than those those of key workers or classed as vulnerable. However, this isn’t quite the right question to be asking. There will never be no risk. In a world where Covid-19 remains present in the community, it’s about how we reduce that risk, just as we do with other kinds of daily dangers, like driving and cycling. What we should be asking is whether schools are safe enough to open.

Source: Education Headlines (educationheadlines.net)

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

2/2 It would have been useful with regards to transmission by children, to test everybody 10 days after the return to school from the February half term, when a lot of families had gone skiing in Europe. How many parents, children and teachers were infected then? Did it expand?

devisridhar Glad I live in Ontario where the Premier, fordnation, put children first & said not worth the risk for 4 weeks of school. Focus on what’s needed for September re-opening including new framework for e-learning for kids who stay home. onpoli

devisridhar What about using football stadiums for children to return to school? MaryBoustedNEU kennygibsonnhs 🤔

saltiredogs English schools you mean?

devisridhar devisridhar this is excellent and very clearly reasoned. (I am married to a teacher.) I know you're busy but could you please, please help advise SG on their approach to dentistry next. Apparently arbitrary decisions at the moment.

devisridhar Excellent article

devisridhar Another great piece of guidance!

devisridhar It amazes me that people think that there is no God, but want Science to talk 🤪 Science 🧫 can’t tell us anything. It needs subjective human interpretation by scientists who as people are seldom without their own biases, prejudices or political affiliations.

devisridhar

Ya... Ontario Canada shuts schools until September because of COVID-19 pandemic. The province said in a news release that the decision was made after consultation with the chief medical officer of health and an assortment of medical experts.

devisridhar Interesting article in NY Times suggesting you can increase number of tests by swabbing five people and running all of them through one test. Could be useful for classes! Teachers starts day by swabbing all kids, gets results within 24hrs. If one positive, class quarantined.

devisridhar As they open to more pupils they are finding the older ones are less compliant with social distancing than the younger ones.

devisridhar Germany prioritised Year 13 pupils, in a very careful, controlled way not because they found social distancing easier but because they were doing their Abitur (A levels) this term. One of the schools closed after one day when a parent of one of the pupils was found to have CV

devisridhar Max class sizes of 15 for social distancing!? Come on.

devisridhar How do we find ‘safe enough’ ways for care home residents to spend time with their loved ones. Can’t see any signs people are even thinking about this. It’s nearly ten weeks since I have seen my mum.

devisridhar Great article Devi, Please come and join our Marchmont & Morningside YES independence group in Edinburgh. In Scotland we’d prefer to take advice on our societies health and well-being from credible scientific sources rather than be subject to some mad exceptionalism ideology.

Schools aren’t closed, there open for essential care workers. They should give the option for those kids who can’t study at home or are vulnerable. This would be all year groups with max class sizes of 15 for social distancing.

Never.

81.3% of parents will NOT send their children back to school if they reopen in June - according to our survey of 20,805 families. schools school schoolsreopening

When the education minister of Wales decides in Wales. When the education minister of Scotland decides in Scotland. When the education minister of NI decides in NI. When um, Gavin Williamson, the education minister for England decides in England. Good luck.

(They mean England, again)

There’s incredible variety in schools’ architecture & profile both within the UK and internationally; each will need a detailed short & longer term plan with significant additional resources funded by the Government. If a winter epidemic is likely planning for that shd start now!

Scottish schools will reopen sometime after mid August at the earliest.

At this stage, the question ‘when’ schools should open is nowhere near useful. The question should be ‘how’ schools will reopen. On that question, the Govt has showed a gross failure to lead.

You give your conclusion before the argument thus allowing politicians to quote your excellent article out of context & in support of their policy.

Labour councils should not open for the remainder of this year! This will ensure that their future voting public will remain as thick as the present one!

BIZAZARI process of ITHANTHI Teaturi is been failed!! The Planet could not be placed in its original orbit in SAAWRI-SAADHRI SHRIASHASHTA in ITHANTHI Teaturi!!COVID-19 may never be resolved!! Main cause UJAANDANDAAS-SOOTANDDHAAS-SUDDHADDHAIs and DEATH THIEVES!! -Plitisua

The same science the government are gearing up to throw under the bus when even more people die.

Rainbows everywhere, subversive

No children are dying from this virus.

When it's safe!

Some people, including children, will continue to get sick and die

Science can’t seem to make up their minds.

Because Tony Blair said so.

Not this year.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 84. in UK

United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

'US has no science-based reopening policy', Bernie Sanders warns‘But you know Trump will blame everybody and everything instead of dealing with the crisis’ Does anyone? Reopening isn't a science. I don't like Trump, but Bernie is an extreme too. He wants revolution so bad, he wants the economy to worsen until people are absolutely desperate. The virus will be there today, it'll be there 5 years from today. Might as well open now. we had only 1 thing in common though we re born and we died. today we have planned for it
Source: The Independent - 🏆 80. / 59 Read more »

'It's time to get our children back into the classroom' -Teachers and parents on schools reopeningParents and teachers share whether they think schools should reopen in June
Source: The Telegraph - 🏆 41. / 63 Read more »

Union tells headteachers to open schools after Govt assures it is safeA TEACHING union has told heads to open their school gates next month after being reassured by government scientists it will be safe. After a week of wrangling, the Association of School and Colleg… Let's see the House's of Parliament full first, so they can lead by example giving us the confidence. Since when did the Unions decide? That’s will be in England...not Wales.
Source: TheSun - 🏆 64. / 61 Read more »

Coronavirus: Government doesn't rule out penalising regions that refuse to reopen schoolsThe culture secretary says ministers are working with unions and teachers, adding: 'I really hope that it doesn't come to that.' Abhorrent These regions, mainly labour strongholds, should show their evidence to the government that opening schools is dangerous for children. Once Parliament is open and they all sit in there I'll have my class back in. Its safety for me. My family. My kids family. And the kids in my class. All the government care about is money. They said 20k deaths would be rough the rest is on their hands.
Source: SkyNews - 🏆 35. / 67 Read more »

Reopening schools in 22 EU countries has 'not been harmful to kids and teachers'Blaženka Divjak, the minister for education in Croatia, has warned any apparent lack of negative impact should be seen in context, with schools having only been open for two weeks in most cases Not you also. I thought you woulld defend teaching staff.
Source: The Mirror - 🏆 136. / 51 Read more »

Only 5% of teachers think it safe to reopen English schools, poll showsSurvey by NASUWT union shows more work needed to win trust and allay fears That many 😬 What makes those 5 percent teachers believe that it's safe to reopen schools? Shame most of them are my SLT 😭
Source: The Guardian - 🏆 84. / 53 Read more »