The fallacious case for abolishing the rich

  • 📰 TheEconomist
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 60 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 27%
  • Publisher: 92%

United Kingdom Headlines News

United Kingdom Latest News,United Kingdom Headlines

Arguments for caps on income and wealth are simple, rousing and wrong

Astra House; 336 pages; $28. Allen Lane; £25Pluto Press; 160 pages; $19.95 and £14.99books argue for doing away with the rich. Not in the Pol Pot sense of murdering them all, for the writers—a Dutch professor of ethics and the director of a left-wing British think-tank—are impeccably nice. Rather, they favour policies that would make it impossible to have “too much” money.

The authors offer many reasons for loathing the loaded. They are bad for the environment, with their private jets and occasional holidays in space. They aggravate housing shortages by owning multiple homes. Some of them buy political influence. Some acquired their wealth corruptly. A pragmatist might tackle these problems directly, by taxing carbon emissions, allowing more homes to be built, tightening campaign-finance laws or cracking down on corruption.

When it comes to practicalities, however, both books lose their grip. How, exactly, can one abolish the rich? Mr Hildyard favours a maximum wage and a hefty wealth tax, among other measures. Professor Robeyns says it will require a patchwork of policies and is irritated by those who try to oversimplify her idea by describing it as a marginal tax rate of 100%.

Consider, too, the incentives such a system would create for entrepreneurs. You have an idea for a better mousetrap. Under the old system, you might mortgage your house to raise cash to build a mousetrap factory, in the hope of making a fortune. Under the new system, you must shoulder the same risks , for a small fraction of the rewards.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 6. in UK

United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

– breaking down 41 pages of written arguments behind record penaltyEverton have been deducted 10 Premier League points. We have gone through the commission's lengthy written reasons to explain why...
Source: TheAthletic - 🏆 54. / 63 Read more »

Should ketchup be stored in the fridge or cupboard? We answer the questionIt's not a simple question to answer but we weigh up the arguments
Source: nottslive - 🏆 96. / 52 Read more »

Inside Abbey Clancy and Peter Crouch's 'fiery rows' that make them 'stronger'EXCLUSIVE: Abbey Clancy and husband Peter Crouch are more than happy to share their heated arguments with fans but, according to a source, it's the key to their 13-year marriage
Source: new_magazine - 🏆 72. / 59 Read more »

Inside Nottingham Forest's case and what it may mean for EvertonThe ECHO takes a look at the arguments between Nottingham Forest and the Premier League and how they may relate to the cases against Everton
Source: EchoWhatsOn - 🏆 74. / 59 Read more »

David Raya proves doubters wrong with impressive performance for ArsenalDavid Raya settles all arguments about his status as Arsenal's first-choice goalkeeper with an impressive performance, proving doubters wrong.
Source: BBCLondonNews - 🏆 115. / 51 Read more »

MAFS couple announce surprise split - 'we are no longer together'Married at First Sight's Jordan Gayle and Erica Roberts have split after months of reported fallouts and arguments have caused their relationship to turn toxic
Source: new_magazine - 🏆 72. / 59 Read more »