‘So vague, it invites abuse’: how Twitter’s new privacy policy helps the far right

‘So vague, it invites abuse’: how Twitter’s new privacy policy helps the far right

Twitter, Internet

12/8/2021 5:33:00 PM

‘So vague, it invites abuse’: how Twitter ’s new privacy policy helps the far right

The policy meant to tackle doxxing on the platform has left many anti-fascist activists locked out of their accounts

The platform would allow users to report other users sharing their images. If a review concluded the complaint had merit and the image wasn’t used for a journalistic or public interest purpose, those accounts would be deactivated.Activists swiftly warned that the policy as it was published would backfire. The policy was vague and had been put together without much input from the communities most vulnerable to harassment and doxxing, the activists argued. They had little faith in Twitter’s reporting and appeals process, which they described as unreliable, automated and allowing for little discussion about the enforcement of policies.

Such Unluckly Moment Has Never Been Seen! The Scariest Sports Accidents

And indeed, hours after the policy became public, users affiliated with far-right movements like the Proud Boys and others espousing QAnon conspiracies put out calls to their followers, urging them to weaponize the new rules to target activists who had posted about them.

On 1 December, for example, a member of the far-right group National Justice Party posted a list of about 40 Twitter accounts of anti-racist and anti-fascist activists who research far-right groups. The member called on his more than 4,000 followers to report their posts: “Due to the new privacy policy at Twitter, things now unexpectedly work more in our favor as we can take down Antifa, [gay slur] doxxing pages more easily,” the post read. headtopics.com

When we expose white nationalists, neo-Nazis and other racists who wish to hide behind the internet, we present sources that are publicly availableAnonymous Comrades CollectiveThe effect was near immediate. Twitter locked the account Miami Against Fascism, which is managed by a group of activists who work to expose far-right extremists, after someone reported a 14 July retweet of an image of Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio. The original image of Tarrio, who

Pioneering US military pilot Charles McGee dies at 102

is servinga five-month sentence for two crimes including setting fire to a Black Lives Matter banner stolen from a historically Black church, was tweeted by a local journalist covering a school board meeting Tarrio was demonstrating outside of.“Supposedly, the policy is that [reports] can only come from self-reporting individuals,” said Diego, one of the members of Miami Against Fascism who the Guardian is only identifying by his first name for fears of reprisal. “But I think that people are doing it on other people’s behalf. And I don’t think that Twitter is verifying it. For instance, Enrique Tarrio is in jail right now. He’s not able to report these tweets personally.”

Gwen Snyder, a Pittsburgh-based activist, was locked out of her account over a Twitter thread that identified a mayoral candidate and Capitol riot attendees who had participated in a local Proud Boys rally. Screenshots Snyder shared with the Guardian show Twitter gave her the option to delete the tweets and have her account reinstated. But deleting the tweets would mean she acknowledged they had “violated the Twitter rules”. Snyder, who had dealt with Twitter’s support and appeal process in the past, didn’t have any faith in the process and chose to delete the tweets to gain access to her account.

“They did give the option to appeal,” Snyder said. “I didn’t, because I felt it was important to post about [the policy] in a timely way. I’ve also had bad experiences with the Twitter appeals and reporting process.”“Twitter is really hard to reach out to in any way if you’re not press,” she said. headtopics.com

Covid news live: New Zealand begins vaccinating children aged 5-11; French parliament approves vaccine pass

Twitter admitted it had been wrong to lock Snyder’s account after reporters brought attention to her case. In an email to Snyder, the company wrote that it had reconsidered its judgment and the tweets in question weren’t in violation of its new policy. The company did not indicate whether it was reinstating the tweets or changing the policy.

Twitter did not respond to the Guardian’s repeated questions about the policy, its enforcement and its execution.Context matters. Our existing private information policy includes many exceptions in order to enable robust reporting on newsworthy events and conversations that are in the public interest.

— Twitter Safety (@TwitterSafety)November 30, 2021Another group of activists working to expose far-right extremists, the Anonymous Comrades Collective, reported its account was locked over a tweet that linked to a blog post exposing the legal name of “Vic Mackey,” the host of the podcast Bowlcast, who led an internet troll group called “Bowl Patrol” and had threatened journalists. “Bowl”, the group said in an email to the Guardian, refers to the haircut neo-Nazi shooter Dylann Roof sported.

“When we expose white nationalists, neo-Nazis and other racists who wish to hide behind the internet, we present sources that are publicly available – like public social media posts that are intended by the poster for public consumption,” the group wrote in an email. “The way Twitter’s policy is written … makes openly sourced media subject to an arbitrary criteria. It requires us to get the permission of a neo-Nazi to use a photo that is otherwise available for anyone to see, which is absurd.” headtopics.com

“Twitter’s policy is written so vaguely that it invites abuse,” the Collective said in an email.It’s really important to acknowledge that the people who are hit by mass harassment ... are disproportionately women, people of color, trans folks and other marginalized groups

Read more: The Guardian »

Boris Johnson: Senior Tories urge PM to quit after party apology

Cabinet members are rallying round Boris Johnson - but other top Tories say he has to stand down.

'How could a policy intended to protect against doxxing and harassment go so wrong, so quickly?' It didn't go wrong. It's working exactly as intended, to protect the far-right. Had my original acct suspended for saying stories about tRump’s wealth needed to be killed. Not him. The lies about his money. They did this in 2012, I was able to go thru their 3rd party customer svc contractor to get it restored. No longer using that company.

another bullshit take ignoring the exact same behaviour from the left Probably intentional.

‘Vague and weak’ policies mean Scotland could miss emission targetsClimate Change Committee says Holyrood administration cannot show how it will cut CO2 by 75% Very few Govts will meet targets. Waste of breath. Anything else happening? berdo'a aja....berdo'a.... The ego is the environments problem not co2.

How Biden’s symbolic Winter Olympics snub was designed to avoid China’s wrathDiplomatic boycott reflects Washington’s desire to send a message over human rights abuses without critically harming relations with Beijing, reports Ahmed Aboudouh

New Zealand police charge one staff member over child abuse at Lake Alice psychiatric hospitalAbout 200 people alleged in evidence before New Zealand’s royal commission this year they were tortured and abused at the institution thanks

Booster vaccine side effects: New symptom reported after third dose - it's a 'feeling'THE BOOSTER shot campaign is proving a triumph, offering higher protection than that needed to prevent hospitalisation and death. But rapid vaccination rates means awareness of side effects can often be delayed. According to one doctor, reports of new side effects are becoming prevalent.

TikTok ‘couch guy’ speaks out about being falsely accused of cheatingResponse to viral video was an invasion of privacy and ‘menacing’ says Robert McCoy Till date Shelia_A_Gooch has been great to me and am happy with her work. For a start I deposited $1000 and after a week got $9,900 return. Her accuracy and reliability can’t be compromised

Northamptonshire reviews show parents were drunk when babies diedSeparate reports into the deaths of two babies show poverty and alcohol abuse were factors. Years ago i was at a mother and baby/under 5 support group. I was shocked when parents were organising who was drinking who's babysitting several children overnight. The social workers and support staff turned blind eye as long as they were sober when at group