Explainer: When does a mental health condition count in court and are more people using it as a defence?

  • 📰 TODAYonline
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 99 sec. here
  • 5 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 50%
  • Publisher: 99%

Mental Health News

IMH,Court

SINGAPORE — In recent years, more people in Singapore have asked for their mental health to be assessed for court proceedings, say some legal and mental health practitioners.

Explainer: When does a mental health condition count in court and are more people using it as a defence?

The following month, the cyclist in the same case had her sentencing adjourned as she recently was diagnosed with aIn January, a man took intimate photographs of two women asleep at his home, claiming that he had done so as he suffered from"While legislative changes — such as mandatory treatment orders in lieu of punishments — and a rising awareness of such issues in the public sphere have led to more psychiatric assessments, it is still unclear if more people are using them as a way to...

Dr Jacob Rajesh, senior consultant psychiatrist at Promises Healthcare, said that a psychiatric assessment can also be made to determine aggravating factors instead of mitigating ones — like whether a person was abusing substances or alcohol and if that contributed to the offence.Those accused of capital offences automatically require one upon arrest, said Mr Chooi, who is a partner at Eugene Thuraisingam law firm.

However, those accused of serious and violent offences such as murder and sexual assault will be remanded for psychiatric assessment in prison, said Dr Cheok. Dr Jacob said that in producing a forensic report, a psychiatrist would focus on a few key questions, namely whether a person has a mental disorder, and “more crucially”, whether it was present at the time of the offence.

“For example, a person has obsessive compulsive disorder and has fear of dirt and washes his hands. However, he chose to shoplift which has nothing to do with his OCD symptoms,” said Dr Cheok.A judge is entitled to question the basis of a psychiatrist’s opinion and conclusion and accept one side or the other, said Mr Chooi.

Criminal lawyer Che Wei Chin said that if it deems suitable, the court may also order an accused to undergo an MTO in lieu of other punishments. Mr Low of Drew and Napier and Dr Tan of The Therapy Room, for example, found the number for such requests have largely remained the same throughout their years of practice.

IMH Court

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 1. in SG

Singapore Latest News, Singapore Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Singapore Airlines flight bound for Singapore turns back to Sydney due to technical issueA Singapore Airlines flight bound for Singapore had to turn back to Sydney after a technical issue was discovered. The flight eventually took off again and landed in Singapore later in the day.
Source: The Straits Times - 🏆 8. / 63 Read more »

‘Make merry while we still can’: Ex-crew members of SIA and its predecessor get togetherSINGAPORE - Some 130 former crew members who used to work for Singapore Airlines (SIA) or its predecessor, Malaysia-Singapore Airlines (MSA), attended a soiree at the Singapore Cricket Club on April 28.
Source: STForeignDesk - 🏆 4. / 71 Read more »

Longer SIA flights to Europe as airline avoids Iranian airspaceAll Scoot flights between Singapore and Athens will also take longer, says a Singapore Airlines spokesperson.
Source: ChannelNewsAsia - 🏆 6. / 66 Read more »

Explainer: Trials to fight treatment-resistant depression in Singapore — why these could be a game-changerSINGAPORE — Two clinical trials are currently underway to fight treatment-resistant depression — where patients do not respond well to medication — which, if successful, could significantly improve remission rates for people who suffer from severe depression.
Source: TODAYonline - 🏆 1. / 99 Read more »

Pope Francis to visit Singapore in SeptemberSINGAPORE: Pope Francis will visit Singapore from Sep 11 to 13, the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Singapore said on Friday (Apr 12). "Details of the visit are still being discussed between the Singapore Government, the Holy See and local Church officials.
Source: ChannelNewsAsia - 🏆 6. / 66 Read more »

High Court Orders Block on Illegal Streaming Sites in SingaporeThe High Court in Singapore has ordered the blocking of 26 illegal streaming sites and over a hundred associated domains. This decision comes after a similar order was obtained by the Premier League last year. A recent study by Cyberstronomy reveals a high risk of encountering cyber threats on pirate sports streaming sites in Singapore.
Source: SBRMagazine - 🏆 13. / 51 Read more »