COMMENT | Agong vs PM: Who is right?

  • 📰 malaysiakini
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 50 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 23%
  • Publisher: 51%

Malaysia Headlines News

Malaysia Latest News,Malaysia Headlines

Before we unzip this conundrum, we must first recognise a fundamental principle of the Constitution.

COMMENT | A confrontation of sorts has occurred between the Agong and the prime minister over the issue of the annulment of the emergency ordinances.

On July 29 at noon, the Agong issued a statement rebuking de facto law minister Takiyuddin Hassan and attorney-general Idrus Harun for failing to honour their promise to allow Parliament to debate on the annulment of the emergency ordinances. The Agong also expressed his deep disappointment that Takiyuddin had misled Parliament claiming that the emergency ordinances were revoked on July 21 when the Agong had not even assented to it.

Retorting the Agong, Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin issued a statement in the same evening, pointing out that the cabinet did advise the Agong on July 23 to annul the emergency ordinances and that under Article 40 of the Federal Constitution, the Agong was bound to act in accordance with such advice.

With that, Muhyiddin asserted that Takiyuddin did no wrong when he informed Parliament that the emergency ordinances were revoked on July 21 and that there was no need for Parliament to debate the matter.Let me unzip this conundrum...

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

Agong scared of PM bcoz PM more power

Omg, now you'll dare to question the King? Confirm you'll are the traitor of backdoor government. Whoever using backdoor very sure won't be a genuine person because they meant to use all the hanky pinky stuff to be in position only. MGBA

agong need to listen to pm advice that was a democracy monark is.

Gopal Sri Ram, says it is not essential for the King to sign off on a Cabinet decision to revoke the emergency ordinances. Sri Ram said no effect on the validity of the Cabinet’s decision in the event that the Agong still refused to sign off on it.

PM HAS MORE POWER!! We r not monarchy country

No comment.

depend who is standing with RAKYAT.

Current PM thinks he is as smart as Dr M?

We don't believe PM. He is from backdoor, everything he did also from backside.

Agong

Rakyat support YDPA

netraKL PM. Can rakyat comment about Agong statement?

King should dissolve Parliment and save Msia from the clutches of PN the evil avengers..The rogue beings who hijacked from PH Govt and now guilty of treason..anwaribrahim guanenglim KhalidSamad PartiAmanah dapmalaysia KEADILAN SyedSaddiq partimuda pejuanitamuda netraKL

MK loves to do this 'batu api' role. Let the PM n YDPA resolve this internally. This cud be miscommunication, as always. Even if it involves legal or constitutional matters, sort it out. It's all man made. We want MPs to hv productive discussions, not bashing each other like kids

Anybody can make comments. But comments must be civil. We may be right or wrong but you are never wrong being civil. Like it or not, you never say, do or imply anything insinuating against the Agong. That's fundamental.

Normally a PM. This is not a pure monarchy so he can't block. But the PM bypassed proper procedure so likely this case he's in the wrong?

As a birthday gift to Malaysians pls sack MuhyiddinYassin and his cabinet ministers. They have been setting a very bad example to our future generation.

it’s not about right or wrong - it’s clear that current frameworks that characterise our democracy has failed and/or is failing in the face of egotistical power grabs done in the name of religion and race rather than the respecting the people’s vote to have allowed PH their 5 yrs

During Emergency or 'Darurat', Agong is the main man! So whatever did by the PN government about the revocation of Darurat is usurping the jurisdiction of Agong. It is a treason! But do those 'biadab' Melayu isle care? 🤔 Check the Rukun Negara again.

Haha bring it ON

Today you all chanting ' Daulat Tuanku', but what if things are not to your expectations? Popcorn!

While AG is responsible to provide legal advices to PM, who is the legal advisor for YDPA?

May be the King can attend Monday Parliment session and disolve the Parliment to save Malaysian! ?

I just know one thing, Agong have right to disolve Parliment !

Daulat Tuanku KEPERCAYAAN KEPADA TUHAN; KESETIAAN KEPADA RAJA DAN NEGARA; KELUHURAN PERLEMBAGAAN; KEDAULATAN UNDANG-UNDANG; KESOPANAN DAN KESUSILAAN

They just need cordial consultation to overcome this issue 😀😇

Sorry to say that the Agong is wrong for appointing the PM. 🙇🏻‍♀️

Agong

PM lied, of course he's wrong!

The situation looks fluid. The people will be the one who will choose the next government but with so many party hopping, this issue is not going away with reforms.

You are the one who always right. Others all wrong.

Stop this nonsense of furthering the rift.

YDPA is not a politician. He does not need to twist facts. He has said it. He hasn't signed the ordinance. You do not signed when you see something is not right even been advise to do so. YDPA is not a puppet. Do not be a dictator MuhyiddinYassin Daulat Tunku

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 20. in MY

Malaysia Latest News, Malaysia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Agong dukacita: Ketua pembangkang tuntut PM letak jawatan - Utusan DigitalTerdahulu, Yang di-Pertuan Agong menzahirkan rasa dukacita dengan pengumuman pembatalan darurat di Parlimen. kerajaanderhaka Nuor jelah jadi PM Nuar jadi PM abislah..sendiri mau ingt.
Source: UMonline - 🏆 27. / 51 Read more »

PMO defends bypassing Parliament, says PM already advised AgongIt says the Yang di-Pertuan Agong is required by the Federal Constitution to act according to the advice of the PM. Another after though, shariah compliant lie Then kenapa lari dari parliament masa bersidang… Dia nak agong sound direct mcm Sultan Kelantan masa jadi Agong dulu, 'Sila duduk dan jangan lari'
Source: malaysiakini - 🏆 20. / 51 Read more »

PM, Takiyuddin perlu mohon ampun Yang di-Pertuan Agong - Utusan DigitalJuga perlu mengambil tanggungjawab di atas segala kekhilafan yang berlaku kerana mengingkari titah Yang di-Pertuan Agong yang mahu semua Ordinan Darurat dibahaskan di Parlimen.
Source: UMonline - 🏆 27. / 51 Read more »

Ordinan Darurat perlu dibahas selagi Agong belum perkenan batal, kata pakar | The Malaysian InsightPerbahasan akan mendatangkan kemakmuran kepada demokrasi dan menunjukkan kerajaan telus. Prof kayu
Source: msianinsight - 🏆 8. / 63 Read more »

Parti politik Melayu Islam sendiri derhaka kepada Agong - DAPSY - Utusan DigitalBerhubung pembatalan Ordinan Darurat oleh Kerajaan Perikatan Nasional (PN) yang dilaporkan tidak mendapat perkenan dari Seri Paduka. Huih howardlee_my bersuara. Dalam masa 22 bulan pentadbiran Pakatan Harapan, tak pernah Agong zahirkan amat dukacita terhadap tindakan kerajaan macam ini. Dapat rejim Melayu-Islam pintu belakang, macam ini pula jadinya. Mereka semakin berani ! scrome78 Ni hauwward ni dgn punni puak termasuk gelam heng bapak 30 hinngit.tu.semua. Buang dari malaysia ..bawak sekali.keluarga dan penyokongnye sekali
Source: UMonline - 🏆 27. / 51 Read more »

UMNO juga derhaka kepada Agong, terlibat dalam pembatalan Ordinan Darurat - Pejuang Muda - Utusan Digital'Keputusan pembatalan Ordinan Darurat dibuat oleh Kabinet menteri yang turut dianggotai UMNO.' YES, ON THE POINT! THANKS UTUSAN!
Source: UMonline - 🏆 27. / 51 Read more »