Controversy reigns as AFL umpires turn blind eye to common sense

  • 📰 GuardianAus
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 60 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 27%
  • Publisher: 98%

Australia Headlines News

Australia Latest News,Australia Headlines

An umpire’s job is to apply the rules. But many of us want our officials (and those who instruct them) to have a better feel for the game’s big moments.

An umpire’s job is to apply the rules. But many of us want our officials to have a better feel for the game’s big moments.When the weather turns, the injuries mount and the big grind sets in, you can set your footballing calendar to three things. There’ll be a call for the return of State of Origin football. There’ll be a discussion about congestion and interchange caps. And there’ll be an industry-wide conversation about umpiring.

For a start, the 50-metre penalty against Laitham Vandermeer on Thursday night was a shocker. It was the full stop and the air sucker on what had been an entertaining, high standard and still-live contest. If he arrived a femtosecond late to the contest, the penalty was grossly disproportionate to the crime.

Besides, if you’re going to enforce a rule that hasn’t been consistently adhered to all year, fans are going to be up in arms. A week earlier, the scientists in the Fox Footy lab ascertained that Izak Rankine had overstepped his quota. Fair play to the umpire for being such a quick and accurate counter. But the frustration relates to the hundreds of times similar incidents weren’t called out, and the sudden crackdown in the final seconds of a crucial game.

In local junior footy, and at the professional level, a massive problem is fans who think they know the rules, but are completely ignorant of them. It’s a problem in commentary boxes, press boxes and grandstands. It’s exacerbated by the likes of coach-turned-pundit Grant Thomas on social media, by passive-aggressive coaches , and by having mic’d-up umpires barking and squawking on the broadcast.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 1. in AU

Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Ch 7 star causes frenzy in AFL controversyWestern Bulldogs great Luke Darcy has caused a frenzy after being moved to a different commentary role on Saturday night while calling his former side’s clash with Fremantle in Perth.
Source: newscomauHQ - 🏆 9. / 77 Read more »

’He’s right’: Roos coach accepts stinging ‘standards’ criticism in candid videoAFL: The AFL will take a public stand against violence against women in each this round.
Source: FOXSportsAUS - 🏆 24. / 51 Read more »

‘Really hard question’: Coaches torn on ex-Roo’s return from ban as Dee praised for DV messageAFL: Tarryn Thomas is starting preparations to return to the AFL in 2025.
Source: FOXSportsAUS - 🏆 24. / 51 Read more »

‘Not able to change’: Leaked email reveals club’s warning to rivals over sacked playerAFL: Tarryn Thomas is starting preparations to return to the AFL in 2025.
Source: FOXSportsAUS - 🏆 24. / 51 Read more »

‘Maximum damage’: The 196cm migraine for AFL coaches... and how these contenders can stop itAFL: On AFL 360, David King analyses how Geelong's Jeremy Cameron has become the most damaging player in the AFL.
Source: FOXSportsAUS - 🏆 24. / 51 Read more »

Inside the Cats litter sparking AFL resurgence... and the unheralded homecoming behind themAFL: On AFL 360, David King analyses how Geelong's Jeremy Cameron has become the most damaging player in the AFL.
Source: FOXSportsAUS - 🏆 24. / 51 Read more »