Concussion: there's no knock-out answer

Around the time the sun was setting on Hall of Famer Graham "Polly" Farmer's career in the west, a young medical student was just starting out with Uni Blues in the amateurs. Early one match he was knocked out, not coming to until quarter-time.

"If there was a simple scan that confirmed the presence of concussion, of course we'd do it," Brukner said. "The problem is that there isn't." This, says Jess, explains former Collingwood and Brisbane defender Jack Frost, who retired two years ago after 56 games and 14 concussions, and St Kilda's 2014 No.1 draft pick Paddy McCartin, whose career is forever stalled.

This century, Byron Pickett – a footballer good enough to have won a Norm Smith Medal – was more famous than infamous for a series of brutal shirt-fronts, catching unaware and defenceless victims who sometimes were blamed while Pickett was held in awe. To be clear, it wasn't just Pickett, it was footy. Some blanched, but few protested.

This is an occupational hazard in American football, with all its headlong rushes, where a lineman might cop 18,000 hits to the head in a 10-year career. It is plainly a health hazard in boxing; it was recently estimated that Muhammad Ali absorbed 200,000 punches in his time. "Punch drunk" is a sub-type of CTE with its own name, dementia pugilistica.

"We've had this crackdown for two or three years now on protecting the head," he said. "It's not working. If you're going to change behaviour, it has to be four to five weeks."Ex-Bulldog Liam Picken plumped for a concussion sub. "This would take the pressure off players, clubs and medical staff, and it would reduce the disadvantage to clubs if they lost a player through concussion," he said.

As for the minimum break, the once-statutory seven days was only ever a matter of convenience rather than science anyway, the typical time between games in most sports. It is bound to be increased.Jess' answers are twofold. One is better record keeping, to counter what he suspects is official fudging. The other is new-old.

Here’s an idea. Before footballers are made to play in bubble wrap, ban the game. No more injuries. And instead people can watch bunnies play with toys.

Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Concussion: there's no knock-out answerThe shock of Polly Farmer's posthumous CTE diagnosis is shining a torch again on how the AFL deals with concussion | GregBaum smhsport
Source: smh - 🏆 6. / 80 Read more »

Predictions and promises: gambling on a surplus is for mugsEvery year we are subjected to the deception that political leaders can predict where the economy will find itself in a year’s time - or, for that matter, in the next several years. It’s called the Budget | OPINION by tonyowright tonyowright And when the ALP is in charge what are the headlines? tonyowright I had to stop reading and leave a brief appreciation tweet for the use of “skew-whiff” I’d have personally struggled to establish the correct spelling and probably avoided it. Now, I must read the rest..... must tonyowright You write as if the stock exchange is involved..they've been there,done that,its now a foresight of financial planning..budgeting in other words!
Source: theage - 🏆 8. / 77 Read more »

There's a massive scarlet flag flying over women at riskI don’t know a single expert who thinks it’s a good idea to have another inquiry into family law, particularly one whose deputy chair, Pauline Hanson, said after Clarke’s death: “These things happen.” | OPINION Omg, we don’t need more investigations. 1woman is being killed every week by her partner, isn’t that enough evidence to make the Gov. take action. More refuges, better protection & safety for a women & kids. A starting point could be AVOs that R acted upon. You've taken PaulineHansonOz's words out of context. You are FakeNews I also don’t know a single legal or domesticviolence expert who thinks it’s a good idea to merge the Family Court with the Federal Circuit Court. cporterwa is determined to make the family law system even more dangerous for women victims & their kids. auspol
Source: theage - 🏆 8. / 77 Read more »

Fan out cold in ugly police videoShocking footage of a football fan knocked out cold after a dispute in the street with riot police has emerged on social media. Dont we have one punch laws
Source: newscomauHQ - 🏆 9. / 77 Read more »

'Why?': Outcry after 16-year-old girl with cerebral palsy tasered by Queensland policePolice have tasered a Queensland schoolgirl who has cerebral palsy, angering her mother who says the teen has significant physical limitations. Answer: She was swinging a cricket bat, damaging property, and lunged at police. Was that really so hard? tough guys, strip searching young girls, tasering them WTF Until we stop employing boofheads and thugs nothing will change.
Source: SBSNews - 🏆 3. / 89 Read more »

Truth in Tyson’s threats to duped starThere’s been a staggering twist to Mike Tyson’s chivalrous attempt to defend his daughter’s honour after rumours of a $10 million dowry.
Source: newscomauHQ - 🏆 9. / 77 Read more »