Abortion clinic safe-zone laws 'discriminate against political speech'

  • 📰 smh
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 1 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 4%
  • Publisher: 80%

Australia Headlines News

Australia Latest News,Australia Headlines

'It discriminates against a particular point of view and privileges the position of the other side': Lawyer argues abortion clinic safe-zone laws 'discriminate against political speech'

Source: Law Daily Report (lawdailyreport.net)

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

There is more notice of people killing animals than that of those of murdering innocent babies.

A woman attending a medical practice to undergo a medical procedure should not have political beliefs forced onto them. It is not the right situation for political campaigning and speech.

This isn’t about freedom of speech. This is about women’s legal rights to access medical treatment. It is about women being harassed & intimidated by groups of religious fundamentalists whose ideas about female bodily autonomy are rooted in misogyny.

LyleShelton Assaulting women outside abortion clinics is not freedom of expression...

Come on Oz, lets give those lethal abortionists, who use terminal violence upon helpless unborn children in the safe zone of wombs., a safe zone so no violence is enacted upon them.

It is sad that people are comfortable with killing babies in the womb. It is understandable that some people find this utterly incomprehensible.

LyleShelton Is it political speech or is it side walk counselling? They can't seem to make up their mind, they just call it whatever they need to, to suit their agenda at the time. Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom to harass people accessing a legal medical procedure.

Oh, so they're calling it 'political' speech, now? I would suggest that that is sophism. If they want to make political points, they are free to do so - outside the buffer zone. If they wish to hand out pamphlets, they can do that also - outside the buffer zone. It's the law.

Your right to a political opinion does not outweigh a woman's right to enter a clinic free of harassment.

LyleShelton No it doesn't. People can still have their free speech. They just have to move a certain distance away from the women they seek to harass with it. You people make me sick. You care more about the unborn than living children like those on Nauru. Selfish, egotistical, freaks.

I want to yell “fire” in the cinema. Damn laws curtail my point of view.

LyleShelton 1 - It is not a political issue. Therefore his argument is ridiculous. 2 - The 2nd half of his argument is that the law takes away an 'advantage' & that advantage should be restored? 3 - If these are the best arguments her lawyers can come up with then I am VERY happy & confident

you can have your point of view, just don't physically menace, abuse, manhandle, bully or traumatise vulnerable women while you have it. it's not difficult.

Only someone truly sick would want to abuse a person on their way into an intensely personal medical procedure. These people should seek help and not be enabled by dogmatic law and the media. Keep them away FFS!

LyleShelton This is of course nonsense. The right to protest is still there. Try protesting at parliament house, state or federal. That's where these laws were made.

LyleShelton If their motion is upheld whats to stop people exercising their right to political speech & disrupting churches every Sunday (Apart from the fact that non-christians are happy to let others go about their lives without interference)

Anyone who thinks they have the right to verbally abuse and harrass women who need medical assistance & who may be already traumatised is a garbage human

Lets make a deal, no protests stopping free speech in university's. Then they will stop protesting against abortions.

LyleShelton the foetus looks like it's having its morning nap. LOL.

LyleShelton Freedom of speech should be virtually unlimited, which includes the right to offend and to say unpalatable and unpleasant things. However. should it be limited?

What utter nonsense

I would hope that the antiabortion protesters would be right up there in the front row of protests involving children in detention on Nauru

LyleShelton Your 'right' shouldn't impinge on the rights of others.

No it safeguards staff and patients being hurt.

LyleShelton Are there people really so self centred as to think the women do this just to make a point? Have your idiotic debate in an appropriate place if you must but find a consenting opponent.

Rubbish. There are plenty of places where free speech is curtailed like the public gallery in Parliament House for example. Doesn't mean I don't have free speech. Just not there.

You can have your political speech but please do not harass women going to an abortion clinic. They are often sad enough as it is.

That isn’t what a 12 week old foetus looks like. The real thing is so much sadder. If you are going to put this type of imagery in your paper at least make it accurate.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 6. in AU

Australia Latest News, Australia Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Abortion clinic ‘safe access zones’ subject of High Court challenge | Sky News AustraliaTwo anti-abortion campaigners are fighting laws that prevent them protesting as people enter or leave an abortion clinic.\n\nThe laws to set up ‘safe access zones’ outside clinics are in effect in Victoria and Tasmania, and have made it illegal to protest ‘in a way that is reasonably likely to cause distress or anxiety’ to patients.\n\nThe challenge is being heard by the High Court, with the campaigners claiming the laws are an imposition on their freedom of speech.\n\nHuman rights lawyer Adrianne Walters says the laws strike the right balance between freedom of expression and the right of every person to access healthcare without being caused harm.\n\nImage: Eugene Hyland \u002F News Corp Australia\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n LibertyWorksAu Harassing women going into the clinic isn't what I'd call a peaceful protest. LibertyWorksAu No it doesn't. It just means you can't harass women. You can protest, you just can't harass. LibertyWorksAu MKe it 5 years that would be fair
Source: SkyNewsAust - 🏆 7. / 78 Read more »

Abortion clinic safe zones stop harassment and intimidation, court toldTwo anti-abortion campaigners say the laws in Victoria and Tasmania infringe their right to political communication. Nah... These anti abortion people really shouldn't be doing what they are doing. If you don't like abortion clinics then perhaps focus on giving information on how to avoid accidental pregnancies. Don't harrass people who are already stressed If YOUR imaginary sky daddy says YOU shouldn't have an abortion, then YOU dont have to get one. Pushing YOUR religious dogma on OTHERS, is not cool. We should arrest and fine such religiotards into oblivion.
Source: theage - 🏆 8. / 77 Read more »

Abortion clinic safe zones under spotlight - 9NewsState laws keeping protesters 150 metres away from abortion clinics stop them harassing and intimidating patients and staff and are not designed to protect patients from hurt feelings, the High Court has been told. 9News Assure them that abortions happen before christenings. Get their names and sue them for obliging birth upon others, the cost of care for any child to do well in their world.
Source: 9NewsAUS - 🏆 10. / 72 Read more »

Abortion clinic safe zones under spotlightProtesters are asking the High Court to overturn state laws which set up safe access zones outside abortion clinics, which they say breach freedom of speech. Once again we are subjected to the inane obfuscation of the distorted wailing of the Freedom Speech brigade that haven't a clue what the definition of Freedom of Speech is or what it avails citizens, wouldn't make decent speed bumps any of these troglodytes. What about the constitution preventing religion being forced upon an individual Auspol Auspoll Abortion leave 'safe access zones' alone ! This just in: Anti-abortion protestors like to bully women!
Source: SBSNews - 🏆 3. / 89 Read more »

Clinic safe zones 'halted intimidation' - 9NewsLaws could not halt the intimidation of abortion clinic patients and staff until 'safe access zones' were imposed around Victorian providers in 2015, the High Court has been told. 9News Don't stop WomensRights of choice Women hating anti choice zealots assaulting women outside abortion clinics should be a crime... Religion especially created the havoc yet ecclesiastical laws state that religion had no say before baptisms.
Source: 9NewsAUS - 🏆 10. / 72 Read more »

Religious schools could still discriminate against gay students under PM’s draft lawsSBS News has obtained the Morrison government’s draft amendments to protect gay students from discrimination at religious schools auspol The Grand Mufti of Australia will be happy with this result. Evil is as evil does. SBS If kids in schools want to declare their gayness then they want to declare their stance on politics. They therefore should get offence or defence. I wish them luck.
Source: SBSNews - 🏆 3. / 89 Read more »

Protesters banned from Queensland abortion clinics from todayAs of this week, abortion in Queensland is no longer a crime and protesters cannot come within 150 metres of clinics Fantastic. About time
Source: smh - 🏆 6. / 80 Read more »

Darwin bar staff 'told to discriminate against Indigenous customers'The former Rorkes Beer, Wine and Food employees said they were told by owner Mitchell McNamee to find 'any excuse' not to serve Indigenous patrons. 9News Disgusting. But the instruction to charge for water doesn’t fit with the “they have no money” argument. Mitchell McNamee is a moron on so many levels How is that any different from average white males being refused entry to nightclub and bars. While black people lathered in expensive clothes and jewellery get let in? Shirts with collars, and no thongs allowed in some clubs near me
Source: 9NewsAUS - 🏆 10. / 72 Read more »

When can a religious school discriminate against gay students?This might come as a surprise, but in Victoria, religious schools already have legal rights to discriminate against gay students and teachers. We know. the hope was that the clause would be and possibly still can be removed. Why would this be a surprise to anyone i do not agree with the gay lifestyle but they have the right to live in peace just like the rest of us
Source: theage - 🏆 8. / 77 Read more »

'Forced to walk the gauntlet': High Court threat to safe access zonesAbortion clinic staff fear going back to the “dark ages” as anti-abortionists challenge the Victorian laws that banished religious protesters. Kathleen Club says “abortion was inherently political” and believes she has the right to accost women and clinic staff within the safe access zone. Who is watching Kathleen’s 13 children while she is harassing other women? Maybe she should focus on her own reproductive choices.
Source: theage - 🏆 8. / 77 Read more »