How More Teachers are Being Trained in the Science of Reading - KQED

2/17/2020 9:01:00 AM

Will the gains in teacher training outlined in a new report translate into more American kids learning to read?

In 2019, more than half of teacher training programs were teaching science-based reading methods — compared to 35% in 2013, a new report finds. MindShiftKQED

Will the gains in teacher training outlined in a new report translate into more American kids learning to read?

chunking,“Teacher Prep Review: Program Performance in Early Reading Instruction,”NCTQ considered fifteen programs as exceptional, ones that ranged from Arkansas Tech University, the University of Florida, to two programs in Utah and Mississippi, respectively. They found that undergraduate university education programs were more likely to offer scientific-based courses, with 57% earning an “A” or “B” rating. Graduate programs lagged behind with 33% earning a top mark.

doing this,” she said. “We hope that by the next time we release new findings, we will make much more significant progress.” Reading and the Brainto learn the relationship between spoken language sounds and written letters and words. , 72 percent said their schools use balanced literacy. While phonics is a part of balanced literacy programs, the report found that balanced literacy “has been criticized for paying insufficient attention to explicit, systematic instruction” of phonics. 

Read more:
NPR »

USMNT: Pass gun reform, now

The U.S. Men’s National Soccer Team used its platform to demand that Congress do something about gun violence in America Hear from: Chris Murphy (U.S. Senator from Connecticut) Alejandro Bedoya (USMNT) Gregg Berhalter (USMNT) Mark McKenzie (USMNT) Chris Richards (USMNT) DeAndre Yedlin (USMNT) Walker Zimmerman (USMNT) Dr. Amy Bass (Manhattanville College) Check out the video feed. Escucha en español. Read more >>

MindShiftKQED I'm a retired SLP, and a former elementary school literacy tutor. Prior to those experiences, I was first a child of the 70's, pre-Whole Language. This is precisely how I was taught to read. MindShiftKQED How about paying teachers MORE!? MindShiftKQED Many blame public schools for the ills of society when, in actuality, educators are like scientists who specialize in helping students to adapt and survive in our ever changing world. Btw, you don’t learn everything in school. Thus the disparity between socio-economic districts.

MindShiftKQED What is wrong with phonics MindShiftKQED How I taught my own kids. BIG resistance in school to teach a more natural way because “ that’s not how it’s done, and I’m the teacher”. Lots of frustration and it happens teaching math, too. MindShiftKQED NO MindShiftKQED Phonics vs Sight Words?

MindShiftKQED My 5yr nephew was pointing out ‘sight words’. I was never taught that kind of vocabulary

BTS Reveals the 'Map of the Soul: 7' TracklistThe album features a track with Sia. Y.E.S. Is it Friday yet? 7TRACKLIST ARE YOU THOUGH?

Why Miley Cyrus, Billie Eilish, and Barbie Ferreira Are Making Me Reevaluate The MulletWhen 'Achy Breaky Heart' unexpectedly becomes a work of art. no

How a Program Can Help Students Re-enter School After a Mental Health Crisis - KQEDA Massachusetts program has become a model for helping kids return to school after mental health-related absences. It's run in a dedicated classroom, where students receive emotional and psychological support and assistance catching up on schoolwork. How about designing a program that kids don't have to 'catch up with' in the first place? There are all kinds of reasons that kids miss school, and some of them have to do with the fact that the 'program' is like a treadmill that they have to keep pace with or else fall off. $$ First it was the short yellow bus and now, it is the Snowflake classroom?

Caroline Flack's Boyfriend Shares Emotional Tribute After Her Death: 'My Heart Is Broken''I am in so much pain,' Lewis Burton wrote as he broke his silence following the former Love Island host's death on Saturday ❤️ Sorry for your loss. We may get to live about 80 years, but there is no guarantee that this happens. Death can come at any time and for the most take them by surprise. Awareness of death gives us enormous power to not waste life and to use it as effectively as a way we can. awareness

Shay Mitchell Is The Face of Cacharel's Newest FragranceShay Mitchell is the ambassador for Cacharel’s latest Yes I Am fragrance, plus, all the other beauty news you missed this week.

Copy Link  (Sneksy/iStock) Hannah Hughes is playing a game with a group of second graders at Johnson Elementary School in Kingsport, Tennessee, who are still working on their reading skills..Every item on this page was chosen by an ELLE editor.Copy Link  (iStock/Ponomariova_Maria) CAMBRIDGE, Mass.

Hughes shows the group the word “bright,” but then takes a card and covers up the letter “b.”  “What does the word say now?” she asks. You must face it and move on forward. “Right!” Students shout. By Jan 14, 2020 Getty Images A new year brings with it the requisite bargaining over what I'm reforming in the hair department. For students still sounding out words letter by letter, learning this skill, called chunking, helps kids practice combining letters and sounds together to make reading words more efficient. Halsey) Make It Right.  Hughes, a first-year teacher, said she learned how to teach this important decoding skill to help struggling readers in her pre-service training. Faced with large, noisy classrooms, Ava froze with fear.

In her undergraduate studies at Eastern Tennessee State University, early elementary reading courses focused on science-based reading methods like chunking. Perhaps you've absorbed the news that are making moves and want to follow suit? Luckily, the"business in the front, party in the back" aesthetic previously reserved for country stars and metalheads is now sported by the likes of Miley Cyrus, Billie Eilish, and Euphoria. And a new report suggests that her students’ future reading success might rely, in part, to that training.  According to the “Teacher Prep Review: Program Performance in Early Reading Instruction,” released by the National Council on Teacher Quality (NCTQ), teacher preparation programs are catching up to the scientific evidence on how the brain learns to read. The teacher preparation research group reports that in 2019, more than half of teacher training programs now teach the “Science of Reading,” compared to 35% just a few years ago, in 2013.  In order to earn an “A” grade from NCTQ, programs had to show that they thoroughly and explicitly covered what’s commonly called the “five pillars” of learning to read—phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension. “Some days I couldn’t even get out of bed,” said Ava, who is 17 with light auburn hair.

Textbooks had to be aligned with the science of reading; discussion and lecture had to include “explicit and repeated” instruction in the five components. And teachers needed to be able to display their mastery of the concepts, not just through assignments and tests, but also through practice teaching them in classrooms.  Sponsored NCTQ considered fifteen programs as exceptional, ones that ranged from Arkansas Tech University, the University of Florida, to two programs in Utah and Mississippi, respectively. They found that undergraduate university education programs were more likely to offer scientific-based courses, with 57% earning an “A” or “B” rating. Graduate programs lagged behind with 33% earning a top mark. But eventually she agreed to transition back to school while spending one period a day in the program’s dedicated classroom, where she received emotional and psychological support and assistance catching up on the schoolwork she’d missed.

While NCTQ is encouraged by the uptick in evidence-backed reading programs, president Kate Walsh said she hopes that news of the report puts pressure on even more to join them.  “Getting programs to the halfway mark means that half of all programs aren’t doing this,” she said. “We hope that by the next time we release new findings, we will make much more significant progress.”  How the brain learns to read The report outlines the importance of providing teachers who teach reading with the understanding of how the brain learns to read. Learning to read is a function of spoken language, in which the brain connects the speech sounds of spoken language to the visual written “code” of letters and words. One study found that nearly   of students failed to receive the mental health care they needed, and more than 50 percent of students ages 14 and older with emotional and behavioral disabilities drop out of school.

When a child learns to read, according to , author of Reading and the Brain , the brain essentially creates an “interface between your vision system in your brain and your spoken language system.”  Creating this “interface” involves making the connections between the speech sounds (that she already knows from spoken language) and the sounds that letters and letter combinations make. Though some children make those connections without much help, most kids need explicit instruction in phonics to learn the relationship between spoken language sounds and written letters and words.  But for decades, most classrooms haven’t focused on phonemic awareness (the ability to hear, recognize and apply the individual units of sound in speech) and phonics (connecting sounds to letters) as the first crucial step in learning to read. Instead, teachers were teaching reading based on philosophies they learned in their training programs, most commonly called “whole language” and “balanced literacy. The BRYT program, which was founded and pioneered in a Boston-area school in 2004 by the nonprofit Brookline Center for Community Mental Health, has emerged as a successful model for helping kids re-enter school after a mental health crisis.

”  And it turns out most teachers are teaching reading this way. Of the 674 K-2 and special education elementary teachers surveyed by the EdWeek Research Center , 72 percent said their schools use balanced literacy. While phonics is a part of balanced literacy programs, the report found that balanced literacy “has been criticized for paying insufficient attention to explicit, systematic instruction” of phonics.  These philosophies, unsupported by scientific evidence on how the brain learns to read, emphasized that kids didn’t really need much phonics if they had plenty of good books to read. They argued that there are several strategies that kids can rely on if they come to a word they don’t know--like looking at the pictures or re-reading the sentence and guess what word made sense. BRYT’s director, Paul Hyry-Dermith, said 137 schools in Massachusetts now employ the program and pilots are starting to roll out in Rhode Island, New York and New Hampshire.

If children had lots of exposure to printed words, they asserted, the rest would take care of itself.   But for many children those methods don't work, because the brain needs explicit instruction to learn the sound/letter connections to read words correctly. National reading scores reflect this disconnect. The most recent national reading scores from 2019 show that overall reading proficiency dropped, and essentially two-thirds of American kids cannot read at a proficient level. “Surrounding kids with good books is a great idea,” reports journalist Emily Hanford in her documentary “ ,” “but it's not the same as teaching children to read. In another corner, a noise machine beckons for attention before it’s soon forgotten.

” Training teachers before they head into classrooms Though how the brain learns to read has been well-established in the scientific community for years and is backed by thousands of studies, many teacher preparation programs don’t include the mountain of research on reading instruction in their programs. Sometimes they have actively resisted it. But recent attention from frustrated parent groups and the media has put the spotlight on asking why so many young American readers struggle, and has put pressure on teacher prep programs to re-evaluate how they prepare teachers heading into classrooms.  Both NCTQ and universities recognize the role that teacher training plays in ensuring teachers are equipped with knowledge of the science.   Eastern Tennessee State University, in Johnson City, Tennessee, where Hughes graduated in 2019, earned NCTQ’s highest grade—an A+.” At Rindge & Latin, Sitkin and her colleague, academic coordinator Nkrumah Jones, disrupt that cycle with a three-to-four-month reintegration plan that includes emotional support and mental care coordination.

But that’s due to completely revamping their reading courses in 2015. Karen Keith, who became the elementary education department’s chair that same year, said she and her team quickly realized that their reading courses needed a reboot. They replaced existing courses they felt weren’t serving students with evidence-based reading courses. For example, Keith said a course that taught undergrads how to write about general issues in education was replaced with a “foundations of literacy” course. The foundations course provided students with a deep dive into the brain science and the five pillars of reading. Eli, a trans student at Rindge & Latin, began to battle with depression in eighth grade, a condition that worsened the following year when he entered high school.

Then they created a second course that built on the foundations course, on how to use assessment data and differentiated instruction to target students who were struggling.  Teachers-in-training then have a chance to practice what they’ve learned at the on-campus lab school, as well as out in the field through student teaching. Hughes was placed in a fourth grade class for her student teaching, helping struggling readers. “We can learn definitions all day, but putting it into practice is the hard part,” Hughes said. “There are so many needs, which is challenging. Unable to walk into the building, he met Sitkin and Jones at the school door before being escorted to the safe space.

But then it’s so rewarding when students are using the strategies you’ve taught them.”  Education school leaders recognize how aligning teacher practice with methods backed by scientific research might start to crack the fortress of American illiteracy that many view as a crisis. “It’s a very clear cycle,” said Merideth Van Namen, the Chair of Teacher Education, Leadership, and Research at Delta State University in Cleveland, Mississippi, which also earned an A+ rating in the NCTQ report. “If we are better preparing teacher candidates when they enter the field, it’s assumed that then they would better prepare those students to be fluent readers.”  Could teacher training change how many American kids are able to read well?   For many years, Mississippi ranked at the bottom of national rankings for state education, but the most recent test scores showed that Mississippi was the only state to make big reading gains. “I was behind on school work before I left, so the academic coordination, having someone else deal with my teachers, was really, really helpful.

  Some have speculated that Mississippi’s big gains in reading are connected to a reboot of their teacher training programs. The NCTQ report rewards two Mississippi schools, Delta State University and the University of Mississippi, with an “A+” rating, and two more get an “A.”  Van Namen said the university has had a long legacy of teaching the science of reading, even when it wasn’t popular to do so. But they recently strengthened the program that was already working, and have helped lead a statewide effort to get every Mississippi teacher trained.  “For the past several years, Mississippi institutions have collaborated through many efforts to enhance teacher preparation in the area of early literacy,” as well, Van Namen said. That’s part of a national trend.

“No one is working in isolation, and that’s a likely factor [for the statewide gains]. We are all going in the same direction.”  While NCTQ’s rising numbers show promise, some teacher educators are skeptical about measuring something as broad and unruly as how teacher training translates into student achievement. Researchers have been trying to untie that knot for years, said Nathan Stevenson, assistant professor of special education at Kent State University. Though research points to which instructional practices and strategies raise achievement, there are still many questions on how to scale them effectively.

  “So then when you step back another level and say, how are we going to rank institutions that are producing these teachers that are trying to affect change for students?” Stevenson said, “You add a layer of complexity. We already didn’t have a clean way to investigate these problems, not to mention doing it on a national scale. It's hard to capture what’s really going on.” Teachers themselves seem to recognize that, even with good training, reaching individual students who struggle to read isn’t easy. Hannah Hughes feels confident in her understanding of reading, but her students come to school with their own challenges.

She has noticed, she said, that her struggling readers often don’t read outside of school or are dealing with issues related to poverty—something over which she has little control.  Yet Hughes’s training provided her with enough background knowledge to address some of those reading challenges, and she said her students have seen growth so far this year. Some of her “bubble kids”—students reading well who still need help with specific deficits— started the year at 40 words per minute and are now reading about 70 words per minute.  Karen Keith feels hopeful that the work that the university has put into giving teachers science-backed reading instruction methods will transform students’ lives.  Sponsored “I convey this to faculty all the time,” Keith said.

“What you are doing is changing the lives of the people of this region and beyond.” See Comments Mindshift Want to stay in touch? Subscribe to receive weekly updates of MindShift stories every Sunday. You’ll also receive a carefully curated list of content from teacher-trusted sources. Enter Email Address .