Palace rebuts Carpio: West Philippine Sea will never run out of fish

  • 📰 inquirerdotnet
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 1 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 4%
  • Publisher: 86%

Philippines Headlines News

Philippines Latest News,Philippines Headlines

Malacañang wants Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio to provide evidence that the West Philippine Sea will run out of fish if the Chinese were allowed to fish in it. WestPHSea Read:

“Paano niyo naman nalaman, kasi ang punto niya, mauubusan ng isda. Paano niya nalaman na mauubusan tayo ng isda doon?” Presidential Spokesperson Salvador Panelo said in a Palace briefing.

Source: Law Daily Report (lawdailyreport.net)

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

This spokesman is an idiot. But he deflects any opinion critical of Duterte.

Mga baboy lang ata pinapasok niu sa bituka niu at di niu naisip na isang malaking kaginhawaan sa mahihirap na Pilipino kung tayo lang na pilipino mangingisda jan..npakaunfair niu nmn mag isip!ipaglaban niu nmn karapatan ng mahihirap mga kapit kau sa saya ng tsekwa!

Nasubukan na natin yan, ung Galunggong at sardinas.. Nsa malalawak clang karagatan bakit nauubosan tayo at pinapatigil ang pangingisda nito.. Dika ba nag iisip Mr. Spokesperson kung hahayaan niung mangisda mga tsekwa jan noon pa nga lang hirap na Pilipino sa pangingisda

oo nga naman, bakit pati laguna de bay ay ginagawang palaisdahan

The number of overfished stocks globally has tripled in half a century and today fully one-third of the world's assessed fisheries are currently pushed beyond their biological limits, according to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

mauubos din talaga yang mga isda na yan bobo naman nito

Mr Butiki, you are missing the whole point of sovereignity and du30 violating the consitution & abusing power of the office. And also depriving us pinoys of our own natural resources.

As president of the Philippines it is your duty and responsibility to protect our sovereignty not Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio.....damn you!!!!

Its not just about the fish. Its about protecting and owning what is truly yours.

Baka walang bumabanggit sa kanya....please...reporter in Malacanang...paki relay nga po sa butiking ito how IDIOT sya🤨🤨🤨

This guy needs to watch BBC’s blue planet for some f*ckin education about our ocean.

Sarap ipakain butiking ito sa mga isda

Bobo talaga mga dutete tao

China's spokesperson to the philippines.

Pinatulan talaga ng mga tangang yellowtards? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Pilosopo ang gobyerno natin!!

Pang high school row 4 at best talaga mga utak nitong mga hinayupak na ito!

Bakit hindi si Sotto ang tanungin. Alam niya ang pasikot-sikot ng karagatan. Kahit nationality ng mga isda. 😂 senatePH pcoogov

Bobo amputa, galing ba to sa drug session nila ng presidente nyang naaagnas na 😂🤣😂

panelo keeps sinking to a new low each day.

Willing ako ishare konti kong knowledge sayo, Panelo. Juskooooooooo!!!

You get wiser as you age, this however doesn't apply to Panelo.

Common sense lang naman po iyon. Kung araw-araw napakaraming mangingisda halos magagawan sa huli. At walang pagkakataon to reproduce, ano sa palagay po ninyo? WPS

Endless game for DilawTae

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Why the Chinese traveled more than a thousand miles, far away from their own shores, to trespass & go fishing on some nation's territorial seas Because they depleted their own. senatePH gmanewsbreaking ABSCBNNews cnnphilippines

grabe, talagang nagtatanga-tangahan para lang mapagtakpan ang kawalanghiyaan!! tangina mo wala kang integridad

Ala bang isda malapit sa China bakit need pa nila dumayo sa WPS aber ala bang galunggong dun na paborito ng mga tsekwa hehehe

As if yung population ng isda ang issue 🤦🏻‍♂️ abogado ba talaga 'to?

Mr.panelo..kay tito sen mo yan itanng hehehe..sigurado alam nya sagot dyan..

The fact that Chinese fishers go as far as the Argentinian waters to fish proves how much they have depleted their own marine environs. Brain donors in Malakanyang are blind to the environmetal degradation that happens whenever the Chinese are involved in research extraction.

Dore and nimo join the group 😁😄

Bakit parang di ka Filipino sir Carpio? Plus, your argument is full of nonsense. If you kept on covering up China's abuse towards us, then you're a remarkable traitor of the country. It's EEZ for Filipinos only, not for others. Malamang mauubusan tayo if u keep your stand again

Whatever 🤨🤨😜😜

ayaw pa kasi diretsohin. ganito - my rich client wants to drill oil in the WPS. go to war with china. we don't care if filipinos will die, we want our oil. ganyan!

But can Malacanang provide concrete evidence that allowing China to fish in the West Philippine Sea will prevent war?

Common sense.

Ang bobo talaga ng Malacañang! Bumalik na kayong Davao.

Ay, slap his facewith studies.. dali.. malamang di naniniwala to sa coral bleaching and climate change etc..

Panelo should watch Sir David Attenborough.

This is so stupid in so many levels.

Nag-salita bago nag-isip.... clown ka talaga..panelo... Magbasa ka muna...about species getting extinct..at Hindi trabaho ng judiciary Yan... executive work Yan...mag isip ka tunggak

Maybe someone can lecture him about fish biology, ichthyology, to increase his knowledge. This is where our taxes go, people, to someone who is incompetent. And, oh, just a reminder, he MUST be there FOR the Filipinos. Pakipaalala na lang din sa kanya.

Mga ganyang paniniwala hindi niya kilala ang Diyos

Medyo bobo.

Fishes come out from the eggs all grown and mature and ready to be eaten!

LAWYER PO BA KAYO MR SAL!? ACT LIKE ONE...... THINK! THINĶ! THINK!

Shunga! Supply and Demand

Based on record they (the chinese) are dredging the south west philippine sea ... they are removing coral reef... coral reef i the breeding ground of the fish... destroyed reef... no breeding... no breeding ... no fish... IS THAT NOT ENOUGH... DAWG?

Just Google it idiot and you will know the massive fishing that they are doing.

Consultant ba nya si Nobel Fish Prize winner Sotto?

Nasa tadyang ba utak neto?

Dahil kinakain lahat ng Chinese from algae to all kinds of sea food and they have one of the biggest fishing fleets in the world at di nila ito zone. Talagang susuyurin lahat nila. At sa laki ng population market ng China, di pa nagreproduce yan kulang pa.

Pwede bang kayo na lang ng Poon mo ang lumipat ng China? Kung hindi nyo kaya eh wag ang Pinas ang ibenta nyo. Lumayas kayo dito. Kabron ka!! 👹👹

Ay anong klaseng pag-iisip yan? The mere fact na kinukuha ng mga chinese yung mga mismong nahuli na ng mga pilipinong mangingisda eh hindi cla payag na maghati. Pinipili pa yung mga malalaking isda. Talagang swapang cla. Teka, kanino ka ba abogado? Di ba taxpayers ng Pilipino

Yung mag aangkat ka na ng galunggong? Hindi ba scarcity ng isda yun? Try mo muna kaya i convince yung gg na mag reproduce para naman di na tayo mag import ng GG na may formaline. Or even ask yung chinese fish na mag reproduce muna sa WPS

Bobo amputa

Sal Panelo does not get the point!! The issue is abt the territory. Kung meron 1 libo or 1 bilyong isda doon ang makikinabang ay mga Pinoy at hndi Intsik!! Kelan b tayo papanigan at papahalagahan ng mga bwiset na to? Atin na nga eh pnapamigay pa? Kayo n lng sna ipamigay sa China!

Malacanang should also provide evidence that fishes in the WPS reproduce everyday and, if they do, that they and their offspring stay in the WPS all the time so Filipinos can catch them.

Carpio has okoy friend ...kaya alam nya ang hinaing ng mga isda

The Chinese are actively jamming comms of PH boats daily. BBC reporter witnessed them stealing giant clams and purposefully wrecking the coral out of spite. Doot may passthe blame to Aquino for losing the islands, but everything they do is death.

legallyzen Hoy Talakitok ..sa tingin mo kung madami pang nakukuhang isda iyang mga Intsik na iyan ay dadayo pa sila sa teritoryong hindi sa kanila? Ang binibigyan nila ng supply ay umabot hanggang America at Europa kaya interest din ang porpuse nila.

legallyzen This is a lunatic idea

Knock-knock! Hello, DDS are you there? Listen to this asswipe, aren’t you going to defend him?😜🤪👉👌👊💩

Hoy Pan-elo (asswipe in Pangasinan), kung ganyan karami ang mangingisdang papasok sa soberenya ntin mauubos talaga ang isda ntin!

Remember the clam harvesting method they use that destroys coral reefs. With no shelter and habitat to support them would fish thrive there?

Oy Panelo research muna bago dada. Ayan on report ng philippines news agency pa.

Naturingang matalino pero bakit ganun ang BOBO UTAK GALONGGONG!

Isip isip muna kc bago mag-comment Mr Spox.

Paniguradong aprubado sa mga bulok na DDS ang kasagutan na yan. Hoy Panelo, sabi ko sa iyo dati, huwag mong lahatin na tanga At bobo ang mga Pilipino!

ewan ko sa yo, Panelo!! Puro kayo pilosopo. Parang sinabi mo na rin na lahat pwedeng kumain sa bahay mo ng libre!! haaay... bakit merong mga ganitong mag isip na mga tao sa pinas? nakakaloka na talaga!!

TANGINA HAHAHAHAHAHA SERYOSO?

Panelo kaya nagingisda na ang mga China sa ibang dagt ay wala na silang mahuli sa Sea of Japan. Hah! Hindi araw-araw nangingitlog ang isda!

This is beyond stupid. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Sally missed the point. The Chinese are fishing in our EEZ. That is the point

Then how come filipino fishermen are not alloyto fish?

Another divertional tactic by these dumbsses in Malacanang. The issue has always been territiorial dispute and not about the supply of fishes. Even kids in elementary are taught that the supply of fish will run out due to overfishing.

Bobo sa row 4 grrrrrrrr💀💀💀talking dead

Napaka Inutil mo Panelo! INUTIL!! Kaya mo kayang mabuhay at ng mga pamilya mo sa pinas kung wala na kayong matitirhan, mapagkukunan ng ikabubuhay. For sure, lilipat at lilipat kayo ng bansa mabuhay lang. Tulad ng mga isda, ang mga corals na sinisira ng China ang home ng mga isda.

Our leaders. Slow clap, please.

👏 👏 👏

Nagsalita na nmn ang matandang bobo Facts are already given by marine scientist from UP wag maging bulag tanda

Really, you are going above and beyond, just to defend China and your vested interest in it?

Ang tanga. Kaya nga sa pilipinas nangingisda Ang mga chekwa Kasi sinira na nila ang dagat nila

Watch and learn Grima Wormtongue Panelo Is China's fishing fleet taking all of West Africa's fish?

Carpio should focus on resolving the electoral protest and stop mouthing his opinions on the WestPHSea

That statement of Carpio was just emotion based and NOT SCIENCE BASED. Maybe that opinion is even DILAWAN BASED

panelo, ang point po eh HINDE dapat mangisda ang friendly neighborhood natin doon! if maubusan man o hinde ng isda, ang PILIPINAS ang dapat makinabang doon. ATIN YUN!

Don’t change the topic, Sal. The Chinese are not supposed to be fishing there, or be there at all, whatever the amount of fish there is. Will you start talking like a Filipino, for goodness sake, rather than a paid fahsion-victim hack.

Look at the way this brainless man conveys his thoughts... Baka di xia nakapag aral ng biology or any branch ng science... Lahat po may hangganan... We have to limit our resources dahil isa lng mundo natin Sa bagay, bansa nga natin d maprotektahan, mundo pa kaya

Haayst Sal, when will you ever learn?

Justice Carpio must have eye-rolled so much he saw the back of his head. 🙄😒 This guy is just too exasperating. 🤮

You missed the point sir!

grabe mehn ubusan na talaga sila ng brain cells sa malacañang

Galing mo talaga panelo ,mr yes today ,no tomorrow

Teach him about over fishing nagbobo bobohan eh

Just ignore Carpio. Gerald Anderson is more relevant than him.

IS PANELO A REAL LAWYER? OR DOES HE EVER HAS BRAINS? MR PANELO, IF YOU ARE STUPID, PLEASE DONT LET ALL FILIPINO ARE STUPID JUST LIKE YOU... PLEASE

Mr. Panelo,para ka din yang amo mo,use your common sense,syang abogadgo kapa naman!!!!!!!!!!

bfarph DENROfficial

He's not a fisherman so he won't know. He's earning way more than the average Filipino so it won't hurt his pocket if seafood price skyrockets due to scarcity of supply. He may be living in another world where overfishing don't exist and coral reefs are not being damaged.

Mga pilisopong Walang kwenta is being used by this admin ks that's what works with their zombies, nkkinsulto lng pra s mga d members ks they colour you same as the brainless kanto peeps n WL tlg pakundangan s ginagawang panloloko

Ito yung sa recitation na hindi nagbasa ng homework so kahit na ano na lang maisagot kahit sobrang di brainy ang dating maitawid lang yung recitation.

DDS Challenge: retweet nyo ang image na yan na may caption na 'Proud Duterte Supporter'

May contest ba sa pabobohang statement sa admin na ito?

Nag aral ba yan ng science? Seasonal ang reproduction ng isda. Mamals lang ang kahit kailan pwede. Hayz!

Isda mauubos doon pero Intsik hindi !!

Mga gago ata ang mga taga malacanang over fishing will definitely deplete fish in the area

Opo hindi n mag rereproduce pag kinuha mo

liampclancy1 Traitors to China!! Walang unli Fish!!! Engot

Wala pa tayo sa 10% ng population ng china! Di mo naisip kung gaano karaming bibig na kumakain yon?

Ibalik nga sa grade school ang matandang yan!

i notice dito yung mga 3% magaling sa komentaryo.. nakakatuwa... cge lang, magkapit kamay lang kayu..eh, baka next year, mg 4% na kayo. lols..

Overfishing you fool.

common sense kuya, 1.4 bilyon na sila, ang daming bibig nun na kailangan kumain.

Ang isda sa west PH sea di basta batas mauubos. Pero ang pasensya namin konting konti na lang😡 Wala ng dumadaloy na logic sa utak nyo.

Utak butiki talaga to🤬

Wag nyo na i-ban ang plastic din tutal di naman nakakasira ng kalikasan yan

Sal Panelo one stupid kind of a lawyer

Alam ba ni panelo na even china has fishing ban sa jurisdiction nila to para makaproduce ulit ng mga isda from may -aug 16 yearly?

Lets ask the fishmaster..tito syotto

Ang laki ng dagat nila dito sa atin ang inuubos nila. Tangago nyo!!!

Bilyones po ang populasyon ng China. Malaking pakainin. Mauubos talaga ang isda sa ating WPS kung lahat doon kukuhain ng China ang isda ARAW ARAW.

Lizardo Panelo your so stupendously stupid, why don't you just molt inside the cabinet mas bagay sayo kasi puro naman kayo amag at lumot dun

mangingisda ba ang mga yan dito kung sandamukal pa ang isda malapit sa kanila, malamang naubos ng mga tsekwa ang mga isda nila. Hihingi ka pa ng evidence punyeta ka!

Over-fishing. Look it up. It is taught in Grade 1 Science and AP.

🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

Tanging ang walang common sense lang ang hindi maniniwala na mauubos ang isda sa WPS kung patuloy na huhulihin ng libo libong Tsinong fishermen ang isda dito.

Haiz ang hirap ng Bobo!!

sinira na kase yung mga corals mo, at logic lang kuya mahigit isang bilyon kailangan nilang pakainin kaya hindi imposible na pag pinayagan mo sila lilimasin nila isda don, hindi lang isda lahat ng marine resources. destructive sila sa environment.

Putsa BUGOK talaga utak ni butiki, ano kailangan para dumami isda? Di ba corals, na continuously sinisira ng mga sinasamba nyo ng poon mo, mga TSEKWA!

Lawyering for China...again.

Wag magpalinlang sa WALANG KATUWIRANG HAMON na ito. They’re asking Carpio to CONJECTURE w/c is no logical basis for a debate. Let’s re-direct the discourse to the real issue: TAMA BA NA NILAGLAG NI DUTERTE ANG RectoBank22 & HINDI IPINAGLABAN ANG ATING EEZ? AtinAngWestPHSea

This is how brainless our officials are - the issue is not about the supply of fish in the WPS but the sovereign rights we have over the area

Spox Panrlo, r u familiar with the word ‘overharvesting’? If we do that too often and too much, that doesnt give enough time for marine life to mature and reproduce. There wont be enough fish for everybody.

Mr Lizardo Iguana Panelo, China's overfishing in the WPS will deplete our marine biodiversity and ecosystem sooner than we think.

Panelo thinks theres infinite supply of marine life in the wps even if the chinese are destroying their breeding grounds and are engaged in illegal mode of fishing.😭

They don't think fish stocks can be depleted?

What a reasoning! Why dont the palace assure filipinos that there will be abundant fish FOR FILIPINO fishermen in wps.

koopal talaga tong taong to, pinapatunog n ayus lng ung gngwa ng mga intsik'

At paano ninyo nalaman na hindi mauubos ang isda, aber?

Nyahahaha.

Hindi ba niya alam that the Chinese Govt is destroying the Marine Habitat in WPS? Panu magrereproduce if wala na yung habitat nila?

Those Chinese have these big commercial fishing vessels, compared to our fishing boats. Remember GG?

Correct ka talaga Mr Panelo. Parang drugs lang din yan. Kahit patayin nyo pa lahat ng Pilipino, ang DRUGS nandyan pa din yan hanggang may nag rereproduce na mga DRUGLORDS. Provide us evidence ka dyan!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

this guy never heard of the concept of overfishing.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 3. in PH

Philippines Latest News, Philippines Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

China not in possession of the West Philippine Sea: CarpioCome on sir, just because you have plans entering politics, nag iba n ang tempo nyo po.
Source: ANCALERTS - 🏆 26. / 50 Read more »

Duterte vows to stop Chinese fishing in West PH Sea ‘in due time’Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio, a fierce defender of the Philippine rights in the West Philippine Sea, rebutted President Rodrigo Duterte's claim that he could grant fishing rights to China. I hope he cites that provision. Disagree. The Tribunal does not preclude States to continue honoring such rights outside of UNCLOS. Basahin mo po ng buo ang decision at hindi lang kung ano ang convenient sa yo. ... in the exclusive economic zone in their legislation, in bilateral fisheries access agreements, or through regional fisheries management organizations” (SCSA, para. 804(b)).
Source: CNN Philippines - 🏆 13. / 63 Read more »

Baste now acting mayor of Davao CityDAVAO CITY – Vice Mayor Sebastian “Baste” Duterte will be the acting mayor of Davao City for two months after his sister, Mayor Sara Duterte-Carpio, took a 60-day special medical leave starting July 19 until September 17. Looks siga. o duwag din to parang kapatid nya at tatay nya?
Source: manilabulletin - 🏆 25. / 51 Read more »

China not in possession of the West Philippine Sea: CarpioCome on sir, just because you have plans entering politics, nag iba n ang tempo nyo po.
Source: ANCALERTS - 🏆 26. / 50 Read more »

Duterte vows to stop Chinese fishing in West PH Sea ‘in due time’Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio, a fierce defender of the Philippine rights in the West Philippine Sea, rebutted President Rodrigo Duterte's claim that he could grant fishing rights to China. I hope he cites that provision. Disagree. The Tribunal does not preclude States to continue honoring such rights outside of UNCLOS. Basahin mo po ng buo ang decision at hindi lang kung ano ang convenient sa yo. ... in the exclusive economic zone in their legislation, in bilateral fisheries access agreements, or through regional fisheries management organizations” (SCSA, para. 804(b)).
Source: CNN Philippines - 🏆 13. / 63 Read more »

Duterte's West Philippine Sea policy simplistic - analystIf we can get to fish in other countries' EEZ's by threatening them with war (like what China did to the Phils., or what the latter 'perceived' the former is doing), then we should modernize our armed forces and 'threaten' coastal states with least-modernized armies.
Source: ABSCBNNews - 🏆 5. / 83 Read more »