Piecemeal tax changes won’t do. To get out of Canada’s productivity rut, we need radical reform

  • 📰 globeandmail
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 94 sec. here
  • 17 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 90%
  • Publisher: 92%

Column News

Opinion,Andrew Coyne,Coyne

A broader restructuring of the tax system would avoid some of the traps we are seeing with the capital-gains changes

Once again the Trudeau government has stepped on the hornet’s nest called tax reform, and once again it is getting stung. We have seen this happen before: for example, with the changes to the taxation of small private corporations in 2017, and with the “proposal” of the same year to tax employee health and dental benefits as income. Both encountered a storm of opposition, and were either amended or killed.

Probably the government’s advisers thought a single-bullet reform was more manageable politically than one aimed at closing a number of tax breaks at one go. But it hasn’t tended to work out that way. With a broader reform, it is true, you antagonize many more taxpayers. But that in itself arguably makes it less toxic politically: if everyone’s ox is being gored at the same time, it’s harder for any one group to complain of ill treatment.

But perhaps the most urgent imperative is sweeping reform to Canada’s tax system: the single largest barrier to investment and the biggest impediment to its efficient allocation. A good place to start is with the Finance Department’son the cost of federal “tax expenditures.” As the term implies, these are tax preferences that, by taxing certain taxpayers, activities and things at less than the statutory rate, cost the government money, the same as a spending program.

There are lots more of these on the corporate income tax side. While many are inefficient and wasteful, most are fairly small beer, in terms of revenue forgone. The biggest exception: the preferential rate for small business. This would still leave Canada with relatively high marginal tax rates at the top end: at about 50 per cent, federal and provincial combined, Canada’s tax system would remain among the most steeply progressive in the developed world. But for most people below the top bracket it would mark a major improvement in tax competitiveness.

of the Accelerated Investment Incentive – then it is more systemic pro-investment reforms, the kind that would really catch the attention of international investors.moving to a distributed profits tax: Profits would only be taxed on distribution to investors, exempting those reinvested in the company.replacing the corporate income tax with a tax on corporate “rents.

Opinion Andrew Coyne Coyne Tax Income Reform Gains Rate Canada Savings Business Bank Of Canada Canada Robin Boadway

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.
We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 5. in CA

Canada Latest News, Canada Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

A bestselling collaboration between two historical novelistsWriters Janie Chang and Kate Quinn stress the importance of in-person meetings when they were plotting The Phoenix Crown
Source: globeandmail - 🏆 5. / 92 Read more »

The bestselling Canadian books of the weekThe Phoenix Crown is a novel by American writer Kate Quinn, right, and Canadian writer Janie Chang.
Source: CBC - 🏆 32. / 63 Read more »

GM’s Mary Barra Remains Undeterred About an Electric FutureIn this week’s episode of The Circuit, Emily Chang visits the automaker’s factory floor to discuss the CEO’s ambitions for an all-EV fleet by 2035.
Source: BNNBloomberg - 🏆 83. / 50 Read more »

Bank of Korea’s Rhee Signals Rate Cut Delay as Fed Stays TightBank of Korea Governor Rhee Chang-yong said the central bank will reconsider the timing of interest-rate cuts, amid expectations that any easing is likely to get delayed by a weak currency and a strong economy.
Source: BNNBloomberg - 🏆 83. / 50 Read more »

China blasts off on mission that could provide 1st samples of far side of the moonA Long March 5 rocket, carrying the Chang'e-6 mission lunar probe, lifts off as it rains at the Wenchang Space Launch Centre in southern China's Hainan Province on May 3, 2024.
Source: CBCNews - 🏆 2. / 99 Read more »

COVID’s unlearned lessons, plus other letters May 8: ‘There has been a near-total absence of both accountability and interest in averting the next such disaster.’In today’s letters to the editor: COVID-19 pandemic; Canada Pension Plan; capital gains tax changes; wealth backlash; sex education; Toronto Maple Leafs
Source: globebusiness - 🏆 31. / 66 Read more »