Upham is often considered to be a coward.
Summary World War II historian John McManus praises the accuracy of the infamous Timothy Upham scene in Saving Private Ryan. The scene in question features Upham frozen with fear and shock when his comrade, Stanley Mellish , is stabbed and killed by a German soldier. Upham does not try to save Mellish's life, and when the German soldier sees the cowardly Upham in the stairwell, he walks past Upham, as if he is not worth killing.
McManus expresses how glad he is that the scene was included in Saving Private Ryan, given that many individuals in war cannot handle the extreme trauma and stress of it, along with addressing the PTSD that comes with living through such horrific events. Read the rest of McManus' breakdown of the scene below:
This was true for many, many other Americans, or people on all sides of World War II, actually. Sometimes, they just weren't up for it, and so you see this face-to-face encounter, and you see that sometimes in modern war. And what I've always thought when watching this clip, especially, is the PTSD element of it. He's going to have to live with that the rest of his life, thinking about whether he could have saved Mellish.
Upham did not have combat experience, and it was because of his skills as a French and German interpreter that he was part of the mission to save Private James Francis Ryan . Given Upham's background, he understandably struggled to navigate the horrors of war. He was an interpreter, and not a trained soldier, with McManus emphasizing that while it is easy to dismiss him as a coward, he acted how many understandably did during World War II and in countless other wars as well.
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Upham's Divisive Moment In Saving Private Ryan Ending Is Accurate, Says WWII HistoriansUpham is often considered to be a coward.
Read more »
North Texas colleges want to make transferring between schools easier, saving saving students time and moneyThousands of Texas transfer students each year don’t get credit for some community college courses. The partnership seeks to address that.
Read more »
North Texas colleges want to make transferring between schools easier, saving saving students time and moneyThousands of Texas transfer students each year don’t get credit for some community college courses. The partnership seeks to address that.
Read more »
The Colony police officer recalls life-saving moment he pulled man from burning carBody camera video shows Officer Edwardo Hernandez breaking open a window and dragging a driver out of the burning vehicle.
Read more »
South Jersey officer turns life threatening crash into life saving momentWhen life was on the line, a Franklin Township police officer on his way to work put the brakes on tragedy with a timely tourniquet.
Read more »
Georgia superintendent says Black studies course breaks law against divisive racial teachingsGeorgia’s state superintendent of schools says he believes a new Advanced Placement course in African American Studies violates the state’s law against teaching divisive racial concepts.
Read more »