This Was the First Western To Win the Best Picture Oscar — and It’s Got Problems

United States News News

This Was the First Western To Win the Best Picture Oscar — and It’s Got Problems
United States Latest News,United States Headlines
  • 📰 Collider
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 61 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 28%
  • Publisher: 98%

The First Western To Win the Best Picture Oscar Has Problems

The Big Picture At the 4th Academy Awards in 1931, Cimarron became the first movie of the Western genre to take home the prize for Outstanding Production, the award now better known as Best Picture.

What ‘Cimarron’ Gets Wrong About the Female Experience In terms of representation, Cimarron contains glaring flaws in its portraiture of the movie's female characters, upholding the unfavorable stereotypes of women too commonly explored in the early traditions of the Western genre.

Estelle Taylor plays the role of Dixie Lee, one of Cimarron's most thinly-written and enigmatic female characters. Dixie Lee first encounters Yancey at the film's start when she slyly beats him to claim a plot of land in the Oklahoma Territory that he had been eyeing. With dark hair and eyes, always clad in black gowns, Dixie Lee is treated by the film as a take on the femme fatale, but for reasons never made clear in the movie's screenplay.

Isaiah, portrayed by Eugene Jackson, is a young Black domestic worker for the Cravat family who sneaks in to join them on their journey to a new life in Osage. Depicted as a pure yet simple-minded figure, Isaiah's character is a victim of racist stereotypes forced upon Black actors during the Golden Age of Hollywood. Included mainly in the narrative to provide comedic impact, Isaiah is problematically treated as the punch line to many jokes.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

Collider /  🏆 1. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Western Companies in Russia Fear Further Asset Grabs by the KremlinWestern Companies in Russia Fear Further Asset Grabs by the KremlinAfter Moscow’s seizure of Danone and Carlsberg operations, exiting foreign businesses may have difficulty finding buyers.
Read more »

One of Chris Farley’s Final Films Was This Forgotten Western ComedyOne of Chris Farley’s Final Films Was This Forgotten Western ComedyMatthew Perry and Eugene Levy also star in this Christopher Guest movie.
Read more »

Dozens of whales die in mass stranding in Western Australia | CNNDozens of whales die in mass stranding in Western Australia | CNNMore than 50 whales have died in a mass stranding event in Western Australia as officials and volunteers race to save dozens of others stuck in shallow waters, authorities said Wednesday.
Read more »

Head Count Teaser Trailer Sets Release Date for Neo-Western ThrillerHead Count Teaser Trailer Sets Release Date for Neo-Western ThrillerShout! Studios has dropped the official Head Count teaser trailer for its neo-western thriller, starring Aaron Jakubenko.
Read more »

As frustration grows, Quintillion extends timeline for restoring Western Alaska internet serviceAs frustration grows, Quintillion extends timeline for restoring Western Alaska internet serviceRepairs to the broken fiberoptic cable can’t happen until sea ice opens up enough for a repair vessel to get through.
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-03-05 01:12:10