You may refuse to be vaccinated, but mind the consequences

2021-07-11 02:23:00 PM

Employees refusing to be inoculated could face dismissal and will probably struggle to find the same job elsewhere

Gideon du PlessisPicture: SUNDAY TIMES/ALAISTER RUSSELLThe department of employment & labour’s amended occupational health and safety directive on mandatory Covid-19 vaccination in the workplace has provoked renewed unhealthy debate between pro- and anti-vaccination groups.

Covid vaccine linked to improved mental health 40% of wastewater treatment plants don't work, putting pressure on already stretched supply | News24 Merkel makes final push for successor in Germany's knife-edge polls

Key details that have been largely overlooked in this debate pertain to mandatory vaccination applying only to elderly high-risk employees, employees suffering from comorbidities, and employees engaged in risky work where the virus can spread rapidly. 

The risk of dismissalThe draft directive contains guidelines on which vulnerable employees could be dismissed should they resist vaccination. During the debate on this concept in the National Economic Development & Labour Council (Nedlac) the department and Business for SA (B4SA) were in favour of a “dismissal clause”. However, the trade union federations won the day, and the clause was scrapped.

Unlike Filipino employees, whose choice is limited given President Rodrigo Duterte’s message — “You choose: the vaccine or I will send you to jail” — the directive provides for freedom of choice in that designated employees may refuse vaccination on medical or specific constitutional grounds.

In the event of refusal employers must, among other things, consult further, provide guidance and, if reasonably possible, accommodate the employee in another position. While most employers should be sensitive to an employee’s freedom of choice and as it is would be wary of legal action against them, dismissal — whether unlawful or not — remains a risk for a designated employee. Thus, B4SA informed its members that the directive does not prevent employers from dismissing employees who cannot be reasonably accommodated.

Sibanye-Stillwater, which has accreditation to vaccinate its employees, has recently started dispensing doses and has told designated employees it is an opportunity to get preferential vaccination to counteract their vulnerability. While this process is voluntary, the mining house has indicated it may change its stance.

A designated employee who loses his or her job by refusing vaccination can rest assured that there would be a trade union or lawyer who would contest the dismissal. What must be kept in mind is that test cases must still ensue to provide legal certainty, and legal proceedings can be protracted.

Namibia's Chanique Rabe on being Africa's first Miss Supranational titleholder: 'I feel the love' | Channel India to export 8 million Covid-19 jabs in October Rights groups slam Tunisia president's power 'seizure'

Moreover, when you lose your job you do not just step into a new one. If your current employer categorises your job as high risk, the new employer may well take the same stance and your chances of being employed in the same position as your case is playing out in the courts are remote.

If an employee’s reason for dismissal is related to refusal to be vaccinated, it is unlikely that another employer would hire them. Freedom of choiceRegarding consultation with employees who are hesitant to be vaccinated, it is important to note a recent study in the UK published by Lancet Public Health. A key finding was that the message to those strongly hesitant should focus on the personal benefit rather than the collective benefit.

This was the approach followed by SA’s department of basic education in its communication with hesitant educators. It emphasised that while they will not be forced to be vaccinated, teachers should bear in mind that vaccination prevents severe illness or death from Covid-19.

The five SA teacher unions have also urged their members who have not yet been vaccinated to do so, and have used the same argument as Sibanye by encouraging teachers to take advantage of the special dispensation for educators to be vaccinated ahead of the general population’s age-based rollout.

Employees who resist vaccination should also bear in mind that employers are likely to identify them — with good intentions — to protect employees against serious Covid-19 consequences. However, there may well be employers who abuse this directive by identifying all employees who are at risk to limit long-term absenteeism due to Covid-19. That said, employers will find it difficult to circumvent the risk analysis guidelines.      

Ultimately, employees will have to accept responsibility for their choice. It is important to base the decision on the right reasons, not prejudice against the government or fake news on social media but rather the advice of a medical practitioner, and by taking note of other countries’ vaccination successes. In this regard, it is worth noting that nearly all Covid-19 hospitalisations and deaths in the US are now among unvaccinated people, according to US government data analysed by the Associated Press. It is now common in the US to refer to a “pandemic of the unvaccinated”.

Didiza unveils plan to reverse Ingonyama Trust leases - The Mail & Guardian Gospel queen Winnie Mashaba axes husband after 16 years | Citypress #RepYourHeritage Challenge: South Africans take to TikTok to celebrate cultural food favourites

Paramount in this debate is that legal arguments about employees’ rights and freedom should never trump the medical and scientific facts concerning Covid-19 and its threat to human life. In addition to the medical benefits, there are positive workplace consequences. Once vaccinated your job is 100% safe as far as vaccination is concerned.

Employees need to think carefully about their vaccination choice. Should they later realise that they have made the wrong choice, it might be too late, and they can then blame only themselves for the consequences.     Read more: Business Day »

eNCA Entrepreneurship Friday | 17 September 2021

From doing fresh fades on his stoep to opening his 50th store. Legends Barbershop was started in 2011 but its growth in the market took off in 2014.\u003Cbr /\u003E\r\nSheldon Tatchell took a stab in starting the country’s most talked-about barbershop. And what\u0026#039;s great is that he has not kept his talent to himself.\u003Cbr /\u003E\r\nLegends has a training platform for budding barbers looking to enter the industry.

I owe you an apology to ever doubt your sincerity and professionalism. It’s was just like a dream to me when I received my first payment. After my second payment it became a reality now after several payments it has become a way of life. tyron_robert7 But mind my rights you too What consequences 😕 😳 f◇k julle CyrilRamaphosa nobody will be forced Listen to video until u understand business day 🙄


You may refuse to be vaccinated, but mind the consequencesEmployees refusing to be inoculated could face dismissal and will probably struggle to find the same job elsewhere Your choice not to be vaccinated but then you must self isolate until the pandemic is over.

Tanker and car carrier among 23 vehicles torched in N3 Zuma protestThe consequences of the violent protests that plagued KwaZulu-Natal on Friday spilt over into Saturday. This so called spokesperson of JZ foundation must be arrested for insighting violence.The man is too much emotional The Bullshit Story or Narrative that Zuma is In Prison without a Trial RET Corrupt Cabal Zuma Must Die in Prison He is a Convicted Criminal He is in Prison for a Crime as Contemot of Court Contempt of Court is NOT a Trial its s Criminal Offence with a Stipulated Sentence

Tanker and car carrier among 23 vehicles torched in N3 Zuma protestThe consequences of the violent protests that plagued KwaZulu-Natal on Friday spilt over into Saturday. Just imagine being a young entrepreneur with 1 truck and it gets torched like this.😟😧 Day 2 of 15 months! And you still paying for it, lets hope insurances will play ball.

Vaccination rate ramps up and registration for people aged 35 to 49 to open - The Mail & GuardianMore than 191 000 people were vaccinated on Thursday the daily target for next week is 250 00, says the health department Reasons Why Not To Invest/Visit in South Africa: 1. Racist BBBEE laws 2. Corruption 3. Crime 4. Unfriendly labour legislation 5. Land Expropriation without compensation 6. Failing infrastructure 7. No electricity 8. Farm Killings 9. City Name Changes (Port Elizabeth)

Heathrow airport to fast-track vaccinated passengers - The Mail & GuardianThe programme is slated begin on 19 July, the date on which most Covid-19 restrictions in the UK are set to be lifted

Houston, we have a fynbos problem: Nasa flies to rescue of Cape's natural treasuresThink of Nasa and the images that spring to mind are probably rocket launches or the International Space Station. Certainly not fynbos.