SANDF probe clears soldiers of killing Collins Khosa, saying he was only ‘pushed and clapped’
The police investigation into Khosa's death continues, and the soldiers implicated 'have been ordered not to report for duty' until the criminal probe has been concluded.
A man gestures while being stopped in the street by South African Police Service (SAPS) officers in Hillbrow, Johannesburg, on April 18, 2020, during a joint operation between the South African Police Service (SAPS) and the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) to enforce a national lockdown to help curb the spread of the COVID-19 coronavirus outbreak. Picture: WIKUS DE WET / AFP
The police investigation into Khosa’s death continues, and the soldiers implicated ‘have been ordered not to report for duty’ until the criminal probe has been concluded.An SA National Defence Force (SANDF) inquiry has found soldiers, who are accused of killing Alexandra resident Collins Khosa, cannot be held liable for this death as there is no link between the injuries he sustained due to their actions and him dying.
The findings of the inquiry are attached to an explanatory affidavit filed with the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria by the SANDF’s legal adviser, Elvis Hobyana, on Tuesday.The affidavit was filed to update the court on what steps had been taken to adhere to Judge Hans Fabricius’ orders after he ruled in favour of the Khosa family earlier this month.
Khosa and Thabiso Muvhango, his brother-in-law, got into an altercation with SANDF and Johannesburg metro police officers at his Alexandra house on Good Friday.The inquiry, which did not interview Khosa’s relatives, relying only on their statements to the police, noted one of the soldiers entered the yard after seeing a glass of alcohol. This is when an argument ensued.
The probe claimed the pair was “undermining the two female soldiers”.Provocative“The attitude of these two men was provocative,” the report noted.The investigation noted the force used to get the men to comply with the officers’ instructions was “pushing and clapping”.
The board, led by Brigadier Viscount Ngcobo, further found Khosa was “conscious and healthy when the security forces left”.It said none of the witnesses “mentioned the vomiting of Mr Khosa” contrary to other accounts of what transpired.The board added it had consulted a neurologist, one Professor M Baker, who raised concerns “about the level of pathologist assigned to deal with such a sensitive case” and “pointed out some short-comings and contradictions in the report”. It did not say what these “shortcomings and contradictions” were.
A detailed list of all the witnesses approached or testimony was not attached to Hobyana’s affidavit.Death cannot be linked to injuriesWhile the board noted Khosa had a “small cut above [the] left eye, a scratch on the left leg under the knee” and his cause of death was “blunt force head injury”, the injuries on his body “cannot be linked with the cause of death”.
It therefore concluded “the death of Mr Khosa was not caused by the SANDF members or the JMPD”.The inquiry also took exception with the police’s action after Khosa died; noting the move to open a murder docket “was unacceptable”.The police investigation into Khosa’s death continues, and the soldiers implicated “have been ordered not to report for duty” until the criminal probe has been concluded.
In court papers filed last month, Khosa’s family claims officers and soldiers held his hands behind his back while he was choked and beaten.They also claimed he was pushed up against a wall and hit with the butt of a machine gun.In his judgment, Fabricius was scathing of the SANDF and police’s use of excessive force during the lockdown, ordering the security bosses to instruct soldiers and officers to act in accordance with the Constitution.Read more: The Citizen News »
Here we go again....DO NOT HOLD YOUR BREATH ON THIS ONE EITHER. I support the findings that cleared the soldiers,they were there with the mandate from the president not just roaming around,they also came to my area and there was compliance they didn't have to force people to comply And these are the people that needs to protect us against real enemies? OR ARE THEY ENEMY NR 1 NOW Army Curfew = NoPeace & NoFreedom
What absolute rubbish!! We are a caring government?....meaningless words from the this corrupt government...you get killed by one of them it means nothing to them...kill one of them, all hell breaks loose. Apartheid style of reporting is back under myANC we are in trouble They will deceive us but not the all mighty God.
sounds like assault for a start. needs an inquest. That should never of happens in the first place!!!! Died of natural causes then ? A push can kill a person it all depends on how one is being pushed same applies to a clap can lead someone to being deaf or death therefore the army agrees that they clapped and pushed him then they killed him hence their duty was to monitor the lockdown not to attack people
So if he was pushed and died, what charge is that kante? Welcome to RSA SANDF probe was unlikely to yield anything of value. How can an investigator, investigate members of an organisation that the investigator is a member of? 🤔 Confused? Clearly so is whomever commissioned the probe to begin with.wtfbazalwane LockdownSA Day62ofLockdown
Murders! EndthelockdownSA That was most likely to be predetermined report since the whole of SANDF & the minister already shown support & sympathy towards the perpetrators. The kind of leadership we deserve. 🙄🙄🙄😥😥😥 Yes “pushed and clapped” him dead. He had a wife and children. Why not when Cele's gang kills people and gets away with it? This was expected.
Those soldiers need to be put to book , no one is above law in SA! 💔💔💔
MRC board agrees to launch investigation into Glenda GrayThe scientific community has condemned the probe, saying it infringes on academic freedom Fire that board. Now. Bloody waste of tax payers money. And a waste of space. NDZ fingerprints all over it. ANC Oligarchy. she should emigrate and take her skills elsewhere. this country is a dictatorship dog show.
Khanyi Mbau claps back hard over 'albino comments'No troll formed against Khanyi Mbau shall prosper. Is she an albino or bleached herself? No news here. Moving right along....... How was that hard? 😒
SAMRC clears Glenda Gray of wrongdoing after she called lockdown rules ‘nonsense’All parties in the spat were advised to settle their differences for the good of the country.
COVID-19: Medical research council clears Glenda GrayProfessor Gray says she will remain at the disposal of the minister of health and the Ministerial Advisory Committee. Shame she's been cleared of her views... Nothing to clear, the truth always prevails, although for some issues it takes longer
KZN ANCYL member gunned down outside homeThe ANC Youth League in eThekwini is mourning the killing of its leader, Kingdom Gcabashe, 29, Why why why!!! Noone deserves to die at the account of politics Oh my God! We don’t want this anymore This killings must 🛑
KZN ANCYL member gunned down outside homeKingdom Gcabashe, 29, ANCYL branch secretary in ward 91 eThekwini, was gunned down on Monday outside a friend's house in Hammarsdale, near Pietermaritzburg. This has started again 2 people like this 😭 Kgomo389 in your region