Climate Change, Environment

SA’s climate policy is amplifying, not solving the crisis

SA’s climate policy is amplifying, not solving the crisis

2021-10-24 09:38:00 AM

SA’s climate policy is amplifying, not solving the crisis

OPINION: Our leaders have failed us dismally, again, lowering the target for our greenhouse gas emissions from 440 megatons in 2030 to just 420, as if this promised 5% reduction – voluntary with no binding provisions – is somehow laudable, writes Desmond D’Sa.

– petrochemical firms addicted to plastics and toxic products,– automakers reliant on petrol and diesel engines,– agri-corporations intent on high-carbon fertilisers, meat and dairy,– high-energy manufacturers especially in the extractive industries dependent on power for smelting and processing,

SAMA: Get tested for COVID-19, even if you think it's flu COVID-19 Vaccine | Nedlac supports mandatory jabs COVID-19 in SA: Death toll surpasses 90,000 mark

– high-methane waste disposal, and– financiers using cyber-currency data-mining techniques which today chew up as much electricity as a country the size of the Philippines.This pattern continued, even at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change annual gatherings. Policy changes were made only at the margins, for example, in Kyoto in 1997, to introduce speculative fraud-filled gambling called emissions trading.

In Copenhagen in 2009, the idea of binding commitments was removed by Barack Obama, working with South Africa’s leader Jacob Zuma and the leaders of Brazil, China and India.These annual gatherings did not serve the interests of the planet and people, but rather, of ripping more profits from the earth and society.

South Africa hosted the UNFCCC conference – the Cop 17 Conference of Polluters – in 2011, in Durban, my home city. We claimed to have the most progressive Constitution and environmental laws in the world, yet, when it was time to put these into action, we failed dismally.

Instead, throughout, our leaders cowered to our own – and the North’s and BRICS countries’ – major polluting corporations and big government bullies. They signed off on the execution of small island countries, as well as of our African sisters and brothers on the continent, who did least to cause the climate catastrophe, but will face the harshest consequences.

Worse, the South African delegation was often a big part of the problem in the UNFCCC, for example, by obstructing the call by the African and G77 bloc of countries to address the climate crisis seriously.Since then, South Africa has recently submitted a ‘nationally determined contribution’ (NDC) to the UNFCCC. Our leaders have failed us dismally, again, lowering the target for our greenhouse gas emissions from 440 megatons in 2030 to just 420, as if this promised 5% reduction – voluntary with no binding provisions – is somehow laudable.

While UN climate negotiators are failing us, the UN’s scientific body – the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change – just warned of new climate feedback loops such as the loss of reflective white albedo from melting ice, large-scale venting of carbon dioxide and methane from melting permafrost peat bogs in the Arctic and Siberia, and the proliferation of wildfires.

EFF blames ANC for failure to pass expropriation without compensation bill | Citypress LIVESTREAM: Parliament decides on land expropriation without compensation WATCH | Soweto undertakers promote vaccinations

The scientists conclude that “rapid and far-reaching” changes are needed in the economic system to keep temperature increases below 1.5°C.We also believe that in the process, creating a more equal society is an imperative: “climate justice.” We remain the world’s most unequal society, with the poverty rate of roughly R50/person/day well over 60%, so whatever we do to address climate crisis must simultaneously address social injustice.

From politicians and big business, we have been hearing chatter about a Just Transition for low-income communities and workers that will be affected by de-carbonisation, like those in South Durban, but after all these years of such rhetoric, there has been zero progress.

Instead, the elites have introduced carbon trading, which allows those firms which reduce emissions to sell credits to ‘offset’ the emissions of others which want to keep polluting. Our Treasury has introduced a carbon tax law, with provision for offsets, which is at heart a market strategy. The real cost of CO2 emissions is now estimated at $3000 (R43496)/ton, new research suggests, but Treasury charges firms as low as $0.42/ton, and even that trivial tax will in future be offset.

Offsetting now underpins the phrase ‘net zero’. It relies on what Greta Thunberg terms ‘accounting gimmicks.’ They include supposed ‘natural climate solutions’ that assume carbon absorbed by restored sinks (wetlands, forests and grasslands) will permit more emissions from fossil fuels. While eco-system restoration is essential, it can only restore what was previously lost by eco-system destruction.

Offsets also rely upon ’carbon capture and storage,’ which is a hypothetical engineering solution to strip carbon from the exhaust gas and bury it under the earth. It is very expensive, very energy-intensive, and would require massive construction of new infrastructure. The few pilot schemes at power plants are technical and economic failures. In some cases, the CO2 is then sold for ‘enhanced oil recovery’ to restore pressure in ageing oil wells and so to extract more fossil fuel.

A genuine Just Transition must be based on the needs of the planet and must be generated bottom-up, by workers in high-carbon industries, by communities who will suffer, and by everyone whom the current system makes poor. The specific care-giving roles of women, the result of their subordination within patriarchal relations, means they and the youth should be central to the deep transformation needed for a Just Transition worthy of the name.

Shudufhadzo Musida shines at Miss World Top Model competition | Channel Mandatory vaccination at workplaces should be finalised – Nxesi | Citypress A letter to Ramaphosa: Your administration is dastardly corrupt, and ...

The youth and people of the world have spoken ‘’no to any more delays and compromising of tour future’ Act now and do the right thing for the planet and its people!* Desmond D’Sa is chairperson of the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance.** The views expressed here are not necessarily those of IOL and Independent Media.

Read more: IOL News »

LIVESTREAM: Police Minister testifies at SAHRC hearings

The Human Rights Commission hearings into the July unrest continues on Friday.

I wish everyone can be like you Sir I haven't lost since you have been managing my trading account, I love you so much Geoffreypreud Start with the smog in Newcastle, kzn. Unbelievable I love this post The size of the experiment should have been limited in proportion to the risks-adjusted potential of the opportunity, Geoffreypreud I can wining and learning because my payment of $45,000 has just arrived

My encounter with Geoffreypreud actually change my life and for that I'll keep upgrading people for his good job thanks once again Geoffrey

US will defend Taiwan in event of China attack, says BidenWhite House spokesperson says president was not announcing any change in US policy

Taking Action: Feeling helpless about the climate crisis? Here’s what you can doThe climate crisis can be overwhelming to understand and to take action against. One Our Burning Planet reader asked, ‘What is the best way for me to contribute to action and activism on this crucial [climate] crisis, both in the way I live, and in law?’ Here’s what we found out Words alone won’t express how thankful I am 💐, I'm recommending you all to you shantelll_142 .....,investing with shantelll_142 has been a good opportunity for me and my family I just received my profit of $5000 within 7 days of investment with the help of shantelll_142 Great opinion referenced article, but do you ever check the source of your reference articles? And then your referenced article's source reference? No, that is why you have stupid people, believing stupid things....

Sponsored Content: Climate 360: Have you joined the movement for climate action yet?Irreversible climate change is almost upon us, but it can be stopped – if we all act. Now. As South Africa faces pressing challenges such as unemployment and inequality, we have to seize all climate action opportunities that can unlock sustainable development. Now WTF? You really allow this garbage to be published on your platform. It takes away from all your wins... But you covered as it is only an opinion.. weak name them please so we can have a nice economic laugh ! I started with R3000 and in 5days I was credited with R25,500 excluding my R3000 that's over 8x my startup capital. Imagine how much you will make with a higher startup capital. Thank you PackSheriff

Eastern Cape teacher jailed for R45,000 funeral policy fraudAn Eastern Cape teacher has been handed a suspended jail sentence for funeral policy fraud. Another Ndlovu

Eastern Cape teacher jailed for R45,000 funeral policy fraudAn Eastern Cape teacher has been handed a suspended jail sentence for funeral policy fraud. peterbroggs Nomia Ndlovu again

Blame government for Lucky Maselesele's deathOne can only imagine how Lucky Maselesele's peers, while growing up, admired his football skills and salivated at his achievements, particularly after signing for a professional football team. Was he really stealing cable? If yes then this letter is nonsense he got what he deserved