Royal AM to appeal against the decision that saw rivals Sekhukhune win promotion

2021-06-14 07:43:00 AM

The protracted controversy over the winner of the automatic promotion spot to the Premiership is far from over after Durban side Royal AM indicated that they would appeal against the decision to award the plum position to rivals Sekhukhune United.

The PSL responded almost immediately on Saturday afternoon‚ releasing a press release with the updated log that declared Sekhukhune as GladAfrica Championship champions.But Royal AM will not go away quietly and have taken the matter to the Supreme Court of Appeal‚ with Safa‚ the PSL‚ Epstein‚ Sekhukhune‚ and Polokwane City named as the respondents.

EXCLUSIVE: Police accused of helping hijackers US to donate 500 million additional Covid vaccines to world DBN Sewerage Crisis | Experts warn of public health disaster

Safa were named as the first respondents and CEO‚ advocate Tebogo Motlanthe‚ confirmed to TimesLIVE that they have received Royal AM's urgent application for leave to appeal against the decision that saw Sekhukhune declared as GladAfrica Championship winners.

“Yes we have received that one‚” he confirmed on Sunday.The Durban club argue in their court papers that they are appealing against Sutherland's order because they believe he “committed various gross misdirections of fact and/or errors of law such that the appeal would have reasonable prospects of success and/or another Court would come to a different conclusion‚ more particularly in that: headtopics.com

1. The order is inherently contradictory because the very effect of granting the NSL declaratory order is that the arbitrator must have and did indeed commit a material error of law by unduly resorting to and applying the Fifa disciplinary code in respect of sanction‚ to a domestic dispute which had nothing to do with “eligibility” and/or a “fielded player” but everything to do with breaching rule 35.2 of the NSL Handbook which deals with the requirement to list a minimum of five (5) under 23 players in a team sheet‚ in respect of which the disciplinary committee in terms of rule 51.14.4 of the NSL Handbook had a completely free hand to choose from any one of the nine different sanctions listed in rule 57.13.16.

2. The arbitrator had committed material errors of law in breach of section 6(2)(d) of PAJA in awarding the three points to Sekhukhune United FC under the legally erroneous belief that the disciplinary committee did not enjoy a discretion in respect of sanction supposedly because:

2.1 The disciplinary committee was bound to apply the sanction of forfeiture prescribed in rule 57.13.16 of the NSL Handbook; and also2.2 The disciplinary committee was bound to apply rule 22.9 of the Fifa disciplinary code.3. Similarly‚ the learned judge issued an internally inconsistent order by upholding the award of arbitrator Cassim SC which was squarely premised on the existence of a discretion in relation to sanction and the principle that “teams must be encouraged to succeed on the soccer field and not through litigation”. Yet the learned judge dismissed the review application which was inter alia premised on the same principle.

4. The learned judge failed to take the following material factors into consideration:4.1 That the alleged transgression by Polokwane City FC was entirely caused by the situational emergency and unforeseeable emergency that three (3) players had unexpectedly contracted Covid-19-9; headtopics.com

SAA to resume flights on Thursday Absa plans R9.4bn BEE deal Tshegofatso Pule Murder | Shoba bail bid dismissed

4.2 While the unforeseen contraction of Covid-19 was not a justification of the transgression it was a major mitigating factor which must have played a major role in the disciplinary committee imposing the lesser sanction lawfully available to it of deducting points from the offending club;

4.3 There was nothing “disturbingly inappropriate” or “inducing a sense of shock” about the sanction imposed by the disciplinary committee‚ nor did the arbitrator make any finding to that effect or that the discretion of the disciplinary committee was improperly exercised;

4.4 That the discretion exercised by the disciplinary committee was a discretion in the wide sense as enunciated by the Constitutional Court in the Trencon case;4.5 That Polokwane City FC had commendably taken a major step to soften the blow of the transgression by voluntarily listing only 19 players instead of the required 20 players on its team sheet so as to ameliorate or eliminate any potential prejudice to Sekhukhune United FC which might have flowed from the transgression;

4.6 Sekhukhune United FC lost to Polokwane City FC by 1-0 on the field which loss was unrelated to the team sheet transgression; and4.7 The punishment meted against Polokwane City FC was accordingly sufficiently serious and exemplary and therefore there was no need to take the extra and illogical step rewarding Sekhukhune United FC‚ being the losing team‚ with three points. headtopics.com

5. The arbitrator’s award was not rationally connected to the purpose of theempowering provision‚ the information before him‚ and/or the reasons given for the decision by him in breach of section 6(f)(ii) of PAJA.B. SECTION 17(1)(a)(ii)1. There are other compelling reasons why the appeal should be heard‚ more particularly in that‚ the are conflicting arbitration awards and certainty is required.

2. Royal AM FC was already placed as log leaders and automatic qualifiers to the Premier Soccer League and therefore enjoyed the legal right of incumbency and legal occupier of that position.3. Royal won the Championship on the field of play which is in keeping with the universal culture of football and the best interest of football stakeholders including players and supporters.

ActionSA vows to tackle power outages ConCourt to hand down judgment on Unisa's revised language policy Lawyer arrested at Bellville court for being in possession of drugs

4. Sekhukhune United FC ought to have been penalised and not unjustly rewarded and enriched with promotion when it had surreptitiously reconfigured its protest from a rule 35.2 charge to a contrived “ineligibility offence” and the “fielding of an ineligible player”‚ both of which were inapplicable.

5. There are reasonable prospects of success‚ in the circumstances‚ that another court may and/or will come to a different conclusion. Read more: Times LIVE »

Mother reunited with baby after kidnapping

A 7-month-old baby has since been safely returned to his mother after a hijacking in Cape Town on Monday.

The sad part now they must decelebrated their qualification to OfficialPSL There’s a difference between working with someone reliable and one who’s not. This is really amazing, I just got another withdrawal from my investment with SilverAustinefx reach out to him and try something different. They have a game tomorrow to focus on, should they not pitch they will loose points,😂.

In the meantime play off are tommorow I saw several people testifying of making so much money with the help of Victorcordero63 on Bitcoin options fade and I dicided to gave a try and am gald he helped me and my colleagues to make allot of profit in one week , thank you for your transparency and trust

They can appeal as many times as they want cause they have alot of money to play with, rules are rules and PSL must abide by them, we know that she gave PSL top officials money so that they ignore the rules in their book and rule in her favour. Anyway I wish them luck in playoff I saw several people testifying of making so much money with the help of LisaJackson022 on Bitcoin option trade and I decided to give a try and now I'm glad now she helped me and my colleagues to make $1000 in one week, thank you for transparency and trust.

Trading and investment has been a lot more easier with SilverAustinefx $500 startup capital and got my returns of $3000 in just a week of trade he’s genuine and transparency has always been tested❤️SilverAustinefx, I’m forever grateful

Royal AM to appeal against the decision that saw rivals Sekhukhune win promotionThe protracted controversy over the winner of the automatic promotion spot to the Premiership is far from over after Durban side Royal AM indicated that they would appeal the decision to award the plum position to rivals Sekhukhune United. Hayi Bandla Much as we love seeing justice taking place, we don't want these scenes in the beautiful game honestly. 3pm on Tuesday, they are expected to play Richards Bay United. They should be training

Queen Elizabeth uses sword to cut a cake during royal engagement: 'This is more unusual' | ChannelWhy use a knife when you can use a sword, right? And that's just what Queen Elizabeth did when she had to cut a cake at an event. White people white peopling. Weirdos

Royal AM to appeal against the decision that saw rivals Sekhukhune win promotionThe protracted controversy over the winner of the automatic promotion spot to the Premiership is far from over after Durban side Royal AM indicated that they would appeal the decision to award the plum position to rivals Sekhukhune United. Hayi Bandla Much as we love seeing justice taking place, we don't want these scenes in the beautiful game honestly. 3pm on Tuesday, they are expected to play Richards Bay United. They should be training

Respect the rules, Safa tells PSL | CitypressThe league backs down after a high court ruling grants Sekhukhune United promotion to Premiership.

Court favours Sekhukhune United in first division promotion impasse | CitypressSekhukhune United have won their court case against the PSL to be declared the winners of the GladAfrica Championship. I just want to say a big thank you to LISAMARKDONALDT I was nobody until a friend of mine introduced me to you it has been nothing but financial success for me , I will continue to share your good name ma’am I think Royal AM should press the charges because winnings alone wont give you promotion, i think the court can do I noticed a crowd of people giving testimony about Miss LouiseConway57 Faith helping them earn a huge amount of money from trading. So I decided to give it a try and to my surprise my first investment was just $300 and I received a profit of $3,950 A very reasonable amount

Red-faced PSL finally toe the line and declare Sekhukhune GladAfrica Championship winnersThere will be some red faces on the Premier Soccer League's executive on Monday morning after SekhukhuneFc secured automatic promotion to the DStvPrem. By Herman_Gibbs | IOLsport