Man who raped girlfriend at rave fails to have convictions overturned

Man who raped girlfriend at rave fails to have convictions overturned

2021-11-28 11:30:00 AM

Man who raped girlfriend at rave fails to have convictions overturned

A man jailed for raping his girlfriend during a rave festival has failed to convince the high court to overturn his convictions.

The group of friends “then descended onto the dance floor”. “En route, they stopped at the restrooms before reaching the dance floor.  The deceased complained that she felt unwell,” the judgment reads. “[Phillip] then handed certain further drugs to the group.  [The witness] consumed this drug with water and assumed everyone else also did so, but she did not specifically observe that everyone else in the group had consumed these drugs.  [The witness] testified that she felt ‘energised’ after having consumed these drugs.” 

Such Unluckly Moment Has Never Been Seen! The Scariest Sports Accidents

The witness told the court she saw Chauhan being taken to a medical tent.“While she was at this medical tent, she observed the deceased being carried on a stretcher into the medical tent.  She thereafter spoke with [Phillip],” the judgment reads. 

“[Phillip] stated that the deceased wished to have sexual intercourse with him but he refused because she was acting strangely.  He showed her a scratch mark on his stomach. Thereafter, when she spoke to [Phillip] at the hospital, [Phillip] remarked that it appeared that the deceased had been raped.  headtopics.com

“She asked [Phillip] if he had sexual intercourse with the deceased and [Phillip] stated that the last time they had sexual intercourse was prior to Christmas.”Phillip told a police officer that Chauhan acted weirdly before having convulsions.“She (the police officer) made contact with [Phillip] and asked him to meet her at the campsite. At the tent the appellant informed her that the deceased had consumed recreational drugs and that the deceased had undressed herself and insisted on having sexual intercourse with him," the judgment reads. 

Zuma takes another legal tilt at Zondo

Chauhan rolled around inside the tent. Phillip called for assistance after she started having convulsions. According to the police officer, the tent was neat and tidy inside with no indication that anyone had been rolling around.  In his appeal, Phillip argued that the court that convicted him “wrongly interpreted the facts, specifically in not finding that it was ‘reasonably possibly true’ that the deceased’s vaginal and anal injuries could have been self-inflicted and not caused as a result of any rape”.

He also argued that the court “wrongly rejected certain expert evidence regarding certain ‘other’ injuries to the deceased’s body and that the evidence pointed away from non-consensual sex and finally that the evidence of one of the state witnesses was not credible and fell to be discarded and rejected outright”.

But judges Robert Henney and Derek Wille were not convinced.  “We find that what is contended for by [Phillip] amounts to speculation and conjecture.  Put in another way, there are no positive facts underpinning or in favour of the position and stance charted by [Phillip].  We find that [Phillip] had sexual intercourse with the deceased at a time when she was unable to consent thereto,” they ruled. headtopics.com

Umlando dance moves land Ranaka in hot water with SABC | Citypress

They upheld Phillip’s convictions and sentence.Judge Vincent Saldanha, in the dissenting judgment, said “the evidence with regard to whether the deceased was able to consent to sexual intercourse, in the circumstances of this matter, was wholly inadequate to sustain a conviction of the rapes beyond a reasonable doubt”.

He added: “{Phillip] was in my view entitled to the benefit of the doubt that existed on the evidence with regard to what exactly the mental condition of the deceased was when she entered the tent, and whether she was in fact able to have consented to sexual intercourse.” 

Read more: Sowetan LIVE »

This investment undoubtedly is the key to financial liberty 🗽 thanks to Iamcallaway_B who’s maximum interest is the success of his investors and I’m grateful the outcome of my investment which was R15,000 with him try invest with Iamcallaway_B and thank me later

Man surrenders after rape of deaf girlA Tshwane man, 40, has handed himself over to the police for allegedly raping an 11-year-old deaf girl.

Hawks arrest man suspected of selling explosives to cash-in-transit and ATM bombersA man suspected of dealing in explosives used in cash-in-transit heists and to bomb ATMs has been arrested.

Man under fire for call to set up Phoenix barricadesKrishna Naidoo‚ founder of KZN VIP Protection Services‚ has denied his call for barricades played a role in racial profiling and killing of black people in Phoenix, Durban, during the July riots.

Man arrested for allegedly raping 15-year-old Free State girlA 30-year-old man has been arrested for allegedly raping a 15-year-old girl in Thaba Nchu in the Free State, police said.

Man who raped girlfriend at rave fails to have convictions overturnedA man jailed for raping his girlfriend during a rave festival has failed to convince the high court to overturn his convictions. honestly how does it happen that couples rape each other

Man arrested for allegedly raping 15-year-old Free State girlA 30-year-old man has been arrested for allegedly raping a 15-year-old girl in Thaba Nchu in the Free State, police said. My daughter and I slept hungry last night. I didn't want that to happen again today💔. Please just help us with mealie meal just so that my daughter can eat. We'll eat it with sugar water🙏. For my 4 year old