The suspended secretary general insists that his deputy lacked the designation to serve notice on him
The suspended secretary general insists that his deputy lacked the designation to serve notice on him
In the latest court papers filed in his legal battle with the ANC, Ace Magashule declares that not only did the party’s national working committee (NWC) lack the power to sanction his suspension as secretary general of the party, it jumped the gun while he was considering stepping aside.
“I have never refused to step aside,” he says in papers filed in reply to the answering affidavits of the ANC, President Cyril Ramaphosa anddeputy secretary general Jessie Duartewhich were filed last month.“I was prematurely suspended before being given a proper and due opportunity to make and communicate a decision one way or the other.”
He had planned to table his decision at the party’s special national executive committee (NEC) meeting which was eventually held from 8 to 10 May, he says.On 3 May Duarte sent a letter informing Magashule that he was temporarily suspended. He has asked the high court to overturn his suspension but to rule that his own attempt, on the same day, to suspend Ramaphosa was binding in law. Should the court agree, the president should apologise to him, he submits. headtopics.com
He argues that the ANC misconstrued the rule used to suspend him as well as the facts surrounding his suspension.But first he dismisses Duarte’s insistence, in her reply tohis application to have his suspension overturned, that rule 27.5 is in line with the Constitution, and then argues that she lacked the required authority to act against him.
He submits that the latest version of the ANC’s step-aside guidelines for those implicated in corruption is a “narrowing” of the resolutions the party adopted at its 54th conference, under which all members implicated in graft must step aside. This was done to selectively target himself and others in a factional purge, but the NEC lacks the power to rewrite the rules.
Magashule says if the court accepts his argument that the rule is unlawful, then it follows that his suspension must be set aside.But he argues that if it were to stand, his suspension was done in such a manner as to constitute “glaring noncompliance” with the requirements of the rule.
He stresses that the power to suspend rests with the secretary general, who must act on the authority of the NEC.He argues that Duarte lacked a mandate she sought to notify him of his suspension, and her submission that shewas authorised to do so by a resolution of the NWC headtopics.com
is factually incorrect. Neither is her reliance on rule 16.9 as enabling her to carry out the same functions as the secretary-general corect, he says.“Clearly the notion that the first respondent deputises the secretary general is lost on her, as is the meaning of that word,” he writes.
“The DSG [deputy secretary general] cannot suspend a person more senior than her, unless she was specifically authorised to do so, which she was not.”Magashule says the respondents tried to remedy the unlawfulness of his suspension after the fact by claiming, as an afterthought, that the NWC had deemed it in the best interests of the ANC. He says he was at the NWC meeting in question and nothing of the sort happened.
Furthermore, he adds, the party never gave him an opportunity to show why he should not be suspended and this violates the Constitution of the country and that of the ANC. He says in as far as the step-aside rules have been applied to him, but not to others also implicated in graft, his constitutional rights to fairness and dignity have been flouted.
In her papers Duarte rejected Magashule’s argument that he was the only person who held powers to suspend him, saying his interpretation of the ANC constitution was “clearly absurd”.She similarly rejected Magashule’s claims he was targeted for being part of a faction. headtopics.com
Magashule also accuses the respondents of failing to deal with several legal principles and statements of fact he put forward in his founding affidavit, and warns that this could prove fatal in court.“I am advised that it will be argued that the significance of the failure to deal with these and other issues ought to be fatal to the respondents’ case, in that the court will have no basis to reject the applicant’s legal contentions,” he submits.
Likewise, where the respondents failed to answer his version of facts and events as these played out around his suspension, or did so only with bald denials, the court should accept his account as common cause.A full bench for the high court in Johannesburg is set to hear the matter on 24 June.
Ramaphosa has dismissed Magashule’s bid to suspend him as vengeful. Magashule disputes this and insists the powers vested in him by the ANC constitution, including those of suspension, “have the force of law” and the resolutions adopted at the Nasrec conference empowered him to suspend anybody accused of corruption.
He further argues that to be lawful and in line with the resolutions, rule 27.5 would have to be amended to all those so implicated, and not just members indicted in a court of law.Such a rewording of the rule would mean that Ramaphosa, plus allies such as Deputy State Security Minister Zizi Kodwa, would also have to step aside.
In the case of the president, Magashule says the ANC cannot avoid dealing with his “confession” to the Zondo commission that R300-million wasat Nasrec, because using money to vie for power is in violation of the party’s principles.Subscribe to the M&G
Thanks for enjoying theMail & Guardian, we’re proud of our 36 year history, throughout which we have delivered to readers the most important, unbiased stories in South Africa. Good journalism costs, though, and right from our very first edition we’ve relied on reader subscriptions to protect our independence.Read more: Mail & Guardian »
Taxi violence: Golden Arrow bus driver struck by stray bullet in his ankle
A Golden Arrow bus driver was hit in the ankle by one of the bullets fired at a minibus taxi at the Borcherds Quarry drive this morning.
It's really dangerous going into online investment without any knowledge that's why I recommend you to contact Jeff_Arnhoff who everyone has been talking about since, I did contact him and now I'm glad and benefiting from the platform I noticed a crowd of people giving testimony about Miss LouiseConway86 For helping them earn a huge amount of money from trading. So I decided to give it a try and to my surprise my first investment was just $300 and I received a profit of $3,950 A very reasonable amount
“He stresses that the power to suspend rests with the secretary general, who must act on the authority of the NEC” Oh, so, there was NEC authority to suspend uSelil after all?🤔 Ace, is living in his own planet. Anyway jail looming. Ignores his failure to comply with the step-aside rule in the given timeframe.
Tears grips my heart knowing how hard I've struggled to find a legit trader. I never wanted to do this but I'll be guilty if i don't share this good news to people to join the best trader have ever know. Thanks for helping me and i will forever be grateful to you LisaJackson022 I saw several people testifying of making so much money with the help of LisaJackson022 on Bitcoin option trade and I decided to give a try and now I'm glad now she helped me and my colleagues to make $1000 in one week, thank you for transparency and trust.
Only a court can 'unsuspend' ANC president Cyril Ramaphosa, Ace Magashule argues in court papersSuspended ANC secretary-general Ace Magashule insists that ANC president Cyril Ramaphosa remains “suspended” until a court of law decides otherwise. Wjhere does the SG get the unilateral powers to suspend the President. There's the Chairman and Deputy President in top 6 . Aren't they highest ranked officials. I noticed a crowd of people giving testimony about Miss LouiseConway86 For helping them earn a huge amount of money from trading. So I decided to give it a try and to my surprise my first investment was just $300 and I received a profit of $3,950 A very reasonable amount 🤔 And yet the ANC President is going on with his work unhindered
Only a court can 'unsuspend' ANC president Cyril Ramaphosa, Ace Magashule argues in court papersSuspended ANC secretary-general Ace Magashule insists that ANC president Cyril Ramaphosa remains “suspended” until a court of law decides otherwise. le ANC eyakubo yini lo? Okay Lol...
New membership system encounters problems in ANC branches - The Mail & GuardianThe ANC’s new registration system faces major hurdles, with branches complaining that some secretaries are trying to manipulate the system, resulting in several disqualifications. Well the new system is kinda better than the old one even though secretary still approve or disapprove the application but on the renew part is super good because I can do it without secretary.
Embittered Royal AM's sense of entitlement knows no bounds, gloves off for courtroom battle“Whatever happens, we are champions. If we don't win the case, the league won't start on time,' says RoyalAM_FC owner Shauwn Mkhize, who went on to add that her club won't take part in the playoffs. By Herman_Gibbs | IOLsport RoyalAM_FC Herman_Gibbs sport They must pitch tomorrow to the first game of the play offs, failure to do that, NSL Handbook will apply. The clubs membership might be withdrawn 🤷♂️. Shaun... just go play the games tomorrow. RoyalAM_FC Herman_Gibbs sport Words alone won’t express how thankful I’m recommending you all to you LouiseConway86 .....,investing with you has been a good opportunity for me and my family I just received my profit of R95,500 within five days of investment LouiseConway86 RoyalAM_FC Herman_Gibbs sport The club is sponsored with money stolen thru tenders and this woman feels entitled to everything. WA gafa
From ‘holy cows’ to ghost workers, the ANC says excess staff will be cutANC treasurer-general Paul Mashatile has confirmed the party is auditing its employees and has found a number of ghost workers on its payroll
ANC to 'leave no office untouched' as staff cuts loom to lower party wage billANC treasurer-general Paul Mashatile says the party will leave no office untouched in reducing its bloated salary bill, including a possible reduction of staff by almost half. They are going to transfer them to Government departments. They must go on, so that voting cattles can starve Why not ask President Rupert to pay it?