The letter from FUL, chaired by former ConCourt Justice Johann Kriegler , came after the commission confirmed that Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe would on Friday participate in the interviews of candidates to fill two vacancies in his division.
The letter follows the commission’s insistence that the embattled Western Cape judge president will partake in this week’s interviews of candidates.
It also asked to be allowed to make representationswhen the commission meets on 4 June to consider his fate, and pressed the entity as to whether it envisioned reaching a decision on endorsing the finding on that date.The letter from FUL, chaired by former Constitutional Court Justice Johann Kriegler, came after the commission confirmed that Hlophe would on Friday participate in the interviews of candidates to fill two vacancies in his division as per usual.
RELATED JSC will deliberate Hlophe’s fate on June 4The JSC has been asked by the Cape Bar Council and Western Cape Premier Alan Winde to postpone the interviews.In a separate approach FUL last week asked the commission to replace Hlophe given the severity of the
finding of gross misconductmade public by the Judicial Conduct Tribunal on 10 April.This stemmed from Hlophe’s approaches to Constitutional Court justices Bess Nkabinde and Chris Jafta in the autumn of 2008 that amounted, in the conclusion of the tribunal, to a patent attempt to influence them in favour of then aspirant president Jacob Zuma in a pending matter relating to the corruption case against him and French arms-manufacturer headtopics.com
Thales.It found that Hlophe had sought to persuade the justices of the apex court to violate their oath of office and further, after a complaint was lodged, impugned not only their integrity, but that of then chief justice, without any evidence to substantiate his claims.
Should the JSC confirm its findings,by the National Assembly after a fractious tenure of some two decades at the head of the Western Cape division. RELATED Misconduct finding against Hlophe means long road to possible impeachment“The findings are of the most serious character and go to the very heart of the independence of the judiciary in terms of the cConstitution,” a letter by blue-chip law Webber Wentzel on behalf of FUL noted.
It added that not only was Hlophe allowed a seat at Friday’s sitting of the JSC, but that the commission appeared to have taken no steps “to address the consequences” of the tribunal’s report, including confirming its findings, forwarding these to the National Assembly and recommending his immediate suspension by President Cyril Ramaphosa.
“In fact, it is a product of the JSC’s failure to fulfil its last-mentioned constitutional obligation to advise the president which has now resulted in Judge President Hlophe’s continued participation in the JSC processes,” the letter said “Under section 237 of the constitution, all constitutional obligations must be performed diligently and without delay.” headtopics.com
FUL added that such failure risked eroding public confidence in the JSC and the judiciary as a whole. It submitted that the commission had both the power and a duty to recommend suspension in terms of section 177(3) of the constitution.It was of concern, the organisation added, that it remained unclear whether the JSC intended to reach a conclusion on the matter on 4 June. The JSC confirmed the date in a letter to the Cape Bar Council on Tuesday, as well as the fact that it would hear representations by Hlophe on the day.
Hlophe has termed the findings of the tribunal wrong in fact and in law, and vowed to have these set aside. His lawyer has suggested that this could include taking the ruling on review in the high court, which would further protract a matter that has now dragged on for more than 12 years.
FUL countered that, should the JSC elect to persist with the interviews on Friday with Hlophe in attendance, this in itself could be challenged in court.“The integrity of the judicial selection process and adjudication more generally will be impugned,” it submitted.
“The JSC will be aware that the improper participation of one member of a multi-member body is sufficient to invalidate the proceedings of that body.”FUL demanded that by 4pm on Thursday the JSC indicate whether it intended to recommend Hlophe’s suspension, planned to reach a decision on endorsing the findings of the tribunal on 4 June, and would allow it an opportunity to make representation on that date. headtopics.com
JSC spokesman Dali Mpofu said the commission would respond to these three questions within the deadline. He added that the JSC would make no rash decisions, but would follow the letter of the law so as to avoid the prospect of any further delays “which will not be in the interest of anybody”.
Lastly, FUL asked that the JSC reconsider its decision to allow Hlophe to participate in the selection of judges for the Western Cape bench, or to postpone the process.On this, Mpofu said the JSC was not in a position to reconsider.In a letter directed to the Cape Bar Council and copied to FUL and Winde, JSC secretary Sello Chiloane has said there was no legal impediment to Hlophe’s participation. However, he added, postponing the interviews would not only create logistical, but also impede access to the courts by delaying the filling of two vacancies in the division.
FUL has played a key role in the trajectory of the complaint against Hlophe. It successfully challenged a decision by the JSC in 2009 to dismiss it for lack of evidence in court.of allowing itself to be swayed by the “partisan” views of the organisation, as well as the official opposition.
Subscribe to the M>hese are unprecedented times, and the role of media to tell and record the story of South Africa as it develops is more important than ever.TheMail & Guardian Read more: Mail & Guardian »
eNCA Entrepreneurship Friday | 30 April 2021
Lufuno Netshithuthuni created a business that created modern traditional shoes for women who love cultural fashion. But in a saturated industry and COVID-19, how has the growth been affected?
CR doesn't take decision... he is playing backgammon with SouthAfrica's future... eish I still can't believe that real account manager exist I am so happy trading with MariaNMabry, i never took her serious because I taught he was a scam like others ,until my first withdrawal of $30,000 within just one week of trading! I am so grateful to her and i can't keep this
This white gorillas this respect us. Imagine issuing instructions to suspend a whole Judge President. Niyapaynelwa ne. Niphefumla ngenxeba FLU. Not gonna happen. Nonsense had a double mind when i wanted to invest but i thank God 🙏 i have invested with the right account manager kellybrian_ i got my money back with profit just as he said, i want everyone to start investing with kellybrian_ he's the best trader.