Donald Trump still banned by Facebook but where to from here?
Its oversight board gave Facebook credit for evaluating Trump's actions during the January 6 attack on the US Capitol against the Rabat Plan of Action
Paresh DaveUS President Donald Trump. Picture: REUTERSFacebook’s oversight board’s extension of former US president Donald Trump’s banishment from the social network failed to settle how it will balance political leaders’ freedom of speech and its responsibility to make sure hateful rhetoric does not incite violence.
The 20-person board, which includes legal scholars, activists and a former prime minister, upheld Trump’s suspension from Facebook for the time being but said the company needed to do far more to prepare for volatile political situations.The company’s policies on these issues have huge importance not just in the US but in countries including India, Brazil, Myanmar and the Philippines. Political leaders there have turned to the social network to stoke hate or spread misinformation, both with deadly consequences, according to critical reviews by the UN and other bodies.
“Facebook has become a virtually indispensable medium for political discourse,” the board said in its Wednesday ruling. “It has a responsibility both to allow political expression and to avoid serious risks to other human rights.”The Oversight Board gave Facebook credit for evaluating Trump's actions during the January 6 attack on the US Capitol, which prompted his ban from the service, against the Rabat Plan of Action, a globally accepted test for distinguishing incitement of hatred and violence from what should be protected as free speech. headtopics.com
The six-point Rabat plan considers the context and intent of the speech, the speaker, the content itself, its reach and the imminence of harm. Trump, president at the time, told protesters in a Facebook video that they were “very special,” even as some were still storming into the Capitol. Trump’s account had 35 million followers.
The board concluded that Trump “used the communicative authority of the presidency in support of attackers,” and his violation of Facebook's policies against glorifying violence was “severe in terms of its human rights harms”. It did not exercise its authority to tell Facebook it must ban Trump permanently.
But the board chastised Facebook for not having a process for reapplying that or some other test to determine when Trump’s privileges should be restored. It gave Facebook six months to decide on Trump’s status and urged the company to develop a policy to handle crises in which its existing options would not prevent imminent harm.
Facebook said it is reviewing the feedback.India turmoilTrump’s suspension was the first time Facebook blocked a current president, prime minister or head of state. In March, it booted Venezuela President Nicolas Maduro for 30 days for spreading Covid-19 misinformation. His administration called the penalty “digital totalitarianism”. headtopics.com
As it has become a major information source, Facebook has mostly given leeway to political leaders because what they say is newsworthy and important to the functioning of governments. Still, its policing of rule-breaking politicians, and political speech more broadly, has prompted backlash from governments and new regulatory threats in India, Hungary and Mexico.
Many civil society advocates say the company is too ready to silence political dissent and has no toolkit for dealing with the many ways authoritarian governments are manipulating its services, which also include Instagram and WhatsApp.The issue is especially fraught in India, where users since 2020 have criticised Facebook for being slow to police hate speech and other actions by politicians of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party. Meanwhile, the government demanded that Facebook remove posts critical of its handling of the pandemic, including some by local legislators.
At the heart of the board’s order in the Trump case is the view that every Facebook user, including Trump, deserves clarity on actions that will get them banned forever and steps they can take to ensure temporary suspensions are lifted.UN conventions, which establish a widely respected though voluntary framework for international human rights law, hold that freedom of expression is a bedrock right, and thus people should not be subject to arbitrary muzzling by Facebook. The company committed to upholding such human rights in a corporate policy unveiled in March that includes annual follow-up reports.
“If you believe in the international human rights law principles that guide the decision, it is hard to see how a lifetime ban could ever be permissible for any content violation,” Nate Persily, a Stanford University law professor, tweeted on Wednesday. headtopics.com
But human rights law also holds that people must be protected from violence and other forms of harm.Sarah Morris, director of New America’s Open Technology Institute, said the board's decision indicates Trump's repeated problematic postings in the run-up to January 6 and their effect on the attack “make it a particularly egregious case that warranted deplatforming” him.
The board declined to go down the road recommended by a minority of members that Trump should not be reinstated until the company is satisfied that he has stopped making false claims about widespread fraud in the election he lost in 2020 and disavowed support for those involved in the Capitol attack.
If Facebook adopted that requirement, Trump’s return may be far off. He has called Joe Biden’s 2020 presidential election victory “the big lie,” repeating the claim as recently as Monday. Read more: Business Day »
Mother reunited with baby after kidnapping
A 7-month-old baby has since been safely returned to his mother after a hijacking in Cape Town on Monday.
Why do they fear his ideas of sovereignty of states ? Getting one legitimate trader is almost impossible 😅. But LISATOWNSENDC is a legitimate trader that trades with your funds and takes his own percentage while you get your profits 100%. She's a trader with difference 👌
Donald Trump still banned by Facebook but where to from here?Its oversight board gave Facebook credit for evaluating Trump's actions during the January 6 attack on the US Capitol against the Rabat Plan of Action The best choice I've made this year was investing in cryptocurrency and forex trading and earning from home. With the help of KevinKatch2 I've been earning ZAR70,353.00k weekly I've never regretted this decision fellow RSA, 🙏🏻
Trump still banned from Facebook, but will get a review in six monthsFacebook’s policies do not authorise an indefinite suspension, and users must not be left in a ‘state of uncertainty’ about their accounts, according to its oversight board
Trump still banned from Facebook, but will get a review in six monthsFacebook’s policies do not authorise an indefinite suspension, and users must not be left in a ‘state of uncertainty’ about their accounts, according to its oversight board Thank God for bringing bitcoin to man,it has being a great source of blessing to all of man kind who have passion for bitcoin trading. Now the poor are getting rich over night and the rich getting richer. MALYAROVALARA_ thank you for your proper management . Words alone won’t express how thankful I’m recommending you all to you LISATOWNSENDC investing with you has been a good opportunity for me and my family I just received my profit within seven days of investment .
Trump launches place to post ahead of Facebook board ruling on his banFormer US President Donald Trump on Tuesday launched a space on his website where he can post messages that can be shared by others to Twitter and Facebook, sites where he remains banned. Words alone won’t express how thankful I’m recommending you all to you LISATOWNSENDC investing with you has been a good opportunity for me and my family I just received my profit within seven days of investment . Hahaha. Wow.
Donald Trump launches his own Twitter-like platformThe former President of the United States, Donald Trump, has delivered on the promise to launch his own social media platform - except that it’s just a WordPress blog. TechIol Swamp news by the creature himself 😼 TechIol Prophet Muhammad SAW makes dua (supplication) for his ummah (nation) and cries for them like no one ever cried before. He is deeply aggrieved over his ummah and makes dua for the astray. Muhammad Qasim has seen many dreams of our Prophet SAW. TechIol He wish he could tweet his madness so bad