National Assembly Speaker Thandi Modise told the Zondo Commission of Parliament ’s duty, as the people’s representative, to question and probe — and how it hasn’t always managed to do that. But she did not quite manage to sidestep the quicksand of party politics in Parliament .
Last Thursday, ANC National ChairpersonGwede Mantashe said parliamentarians owed their allegiance to the political party for which voters had cast their ballots.Mantashe’s apparatchik-speak at Zondo Commission undermines ParliamentOn Monday Modise moved on to damage-control Parliament’s reputation regarding its constitutional responsibility for oversight and holding the executive to account. It was an important moment.
“It is important for us as Parliament to say it is not just about prestige. It is about service. It is not just about holding the executive to account. It is also to hear on behalf of the people and to speak on behalf of the people,” said Modise.“It’s important to ensure nothing that is in the interest of the people is derailed. No committee has an excuse for not asking pointed questions… for not summoning people.”
Committees can call anyone, or any document, interrogate any matter at any time — and determine their own ways of doing so — as part of the ordinary parliamentary rules that have been there from the get-go of the democratic Parliament.Lawmakers have always had the powers and the right “to pointedly put the executive on the spot”, not only in committees, but also in the House. headtopics.com
And while there are cracks — the track and trace system to follow up on ministerial statements and pledges is still not in place — tools exist to moderate flailing about, as the 2009 oversight and accountability model is yet to be fully implemented.“It is not only about having a tracking device, but it is also about having members of Parliament experienced enough to push their point in committee and on the floor of the House,” said Modise.
And this included what’s happening now, writing to ministers to follow up on their commitments — and, ultimately, drafting a report card to the president on his ministers.But sometimes when things fall through the cracks it is because of a lack of resources, according to Modise, who again appealed for the resources to fully capacitate parliamentarians.
Retaining institutional memory was another appeal from the speaker. The parliamentary benches generally, but in particular of the ANC, were decimated after the May 2019 elections as a majority of experienced MPs did not return.That was the easy bit. Her testimony fell apart somewhat over the role of study groups in Parliament where ministers of the governing party and often also senior officials, or (non)deployed cadres, brief ANC MPs.
Modise deflected commission evidence leader Alec Freund’s point that evidence suggested that ANC MPs went into committee meetings having decided on what position to take during their study group meeting.There was “nothing wrong” with inviting ministers and others to a study group as this was distinct from a committee doing its oversight. headtopics.com
“If the intention is to get information and advice, there’s nothing wrong,” said Modise, adding that any other party represented in Parliament in their study groups set up for research and learning could do the same.That’s disingenuous, as only the ANC has study groups. That opposition parties have not invited ministers and officials to brief them in their party structures, as Modise has suggested, is a failure of those opposition parties.
And perhaps it’s time to change that, with invitations to ministers and others to also brief the opposition in their party political structures. It would be an important test for Parliament — and executive accountability across the party political fault lines.
But reputational damage control also fell somewhat apart over Parliament not having a committee on the Presidency, and things falling through the cracks because of that, particularly as Freund pointed out that many of the State Capture claims revolved around the former president.
That line of questioning brought out the ANC tradition of protecting its president by all means. It also brought out the governing party’s nervousness about opposition politicking — such as calling the president to appear before a Presidency committee. headtopics.com
“Most of the work the president does is already there in committees. And the president is not a member of the House. He is this coordinator that must have space to coordinate all three spheres of state,” was how Modise deflected the need for a committee on the Presidency.
“We wanted to reaffirm our commitment to the republic, but also to say to you [that] as Parliament, we will do everything in our power to follow up not only on corruption, but all issues. We do support this commission.”That was the line taken later on by Mantashe, who returned to the State Capture Commission to continue his testimony for the ANC.
“The president has no portfolio; he is overseeing ministers,” said Mantashe. “What we are conscious of is the portfolio committee is an oversight structure. Sometimes there are serious tensions.”Zondo pushed the point that there may still be a need for parliamentarians to be able to pointedly ask questions directly to the Presidency.
Mantashe backed down, saying he would “not go to war” about such a committee, but maintained his course against “an assumption we are not having the best president” and how the push for a Presidency oversight committee may “be dictated to by people outside. That’s a dangerous assumption for society.”
Mantashe has testified for the ANC, even though, strictly speaking, the governing party’s submissions to the commission were made by ANC Secretary-General Ace Magashule. Given the current contestation around corruption claims and pressure to step aside, it may well have been argued that Magashule was not the best possible representative.
It is understood similar considerations could have been at play in deciding against testimony by former speaker Baleka Mbete, during whose watch in the national legislature many of the State Capture claims played out. That effectively left Modise, who during those years chaired the National Council of Provinces (NCOP), in the often tricky position of being asked about National Assembly matters she would not have knowledge of.
ANC submissions to the commission included a proposal for a so-called joint oversight and government assurance committee to deal with the broader transversal and cross-cutting issues.It wasn’t a committee for the president, or the coordinator-in-chief as both Modise and Mantashe described it, but seemed more crafted towards dovetailing the continued efforts to reshape the executive structures. Or, as Mantashe put it, to “ destroy the silos and integrate them into a government machinery”.
Modise as speaker, and NCOP chairperson Amos Masondo made no references to such a proposal, signalling again a disjunct of where decisions about Parliament are actually taken, and the persisting party political quicksand.But Modise held the line — and remained adamant that Parliament would do its job.
“We wanted to reaffirm our commitment to the republic, but also to say to you [that] as Parliament, we will do everything in our power to follow up not only on corruption, but all issues. We do support this commission.” Read more: Daily Maverick »
COVID-19 | Warning of possible third wave in Gauteng
Gauteng has more than 4,000 active COVID-19 cases and infection numbers are doubling on a weekly basis in some areas.
Pathetic! JvanLogg Yip they normally fall asleep when they overeat. ANCisTRASH She must think we’re stupid. Final document with recommendations for prosecution and restructuring parliamentary processes that will speak to a SAn situation, Zondo Commission is a conduit through which submissions were adequately made to understand and address holes experienced in 9 years of hell
Pleads to who, Zondo? Why plead to Zondo for resources when she could in any time write a letter to president Ramaphosa? And when was this parliament 'sleeping', only during Zuma years?
LIVESTREAM: NA Speaker Thandi Modise testifies before Zondo CommissionThe Zondo Commission will hear testimony from the Speaker of the National Assembly, Thandi Modise , and the National Council of Provinces' Amos Masondo. Sound is very soft Now that the PARLIAMENT is AWOKE about THE STATE CAPTURE, and that they need to know EVERYTHINGS, I also believe that the PRESIDENT is READY to TESTIFY AND DEFEND THE LEGACY, THE CONSTITUTION AND THE COUNTRY so that CITIZENS be PROTECTED AND BE SAVED FROM THE PANDEMIC AS WELL.
WATCH LIVE: Modise, Masondo and Mantashe at Zondo commission | The CitizenThe Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture will on Monday hear Parliament ary oversight-related evidence
Mandy Wiener | The catharsis of watching the Zondo commission | News24OPINION | While the process of the Zondo Commission may not prove to be cathartic for the ANC, it indeed is serving that purpose for the greater South African public watching it play out, writes MandyWiener
Ramaphosa tells Zondo commission how Zuma would 'short-change' him with ANC deploymentsPresident Cyril Ramaphosa told the inquiry that there were instances where critical appointments were made in the government which did not go through the ANC's deployment committee. For all those who are new to this working from home Bitcoin trading options Here's a little tip: Get a trusted Bitcoin expert and stick to her MALYAROVALARA_ Invest and play at similar times each day. Because : In times of chaos, your investment is your anchor to success⚖️ It's so hard to do this as a man but I'm a single father. Please assist my daughter and I with a food parcel or food voucher or any form of food donation. I'm able to go days without eating but she can't😭💔. I'm desperate for her🙏 It is reported that over 3000 of the 9000 senior government officials are not qualified for their positions. The system is broken!
Ex-Prasa head Lucky Montana calls out ANC on feeding Zondo commission liesThe former Prasa group chief executive said the ANC leadership had pretended to support the commission but did not assist to solve the fundamental problem. I said this before gore state was not captured by bosasa or Guptas but ANC itself Why Montana can't tell who did what in ANC than trying to be a messiah who actually never assisted the commission with any tangible information I stand with honesty and I always will promote honesty. LisateddyBTC You are indeed a honest person. Hey PEOPLE contact LisateddyBTC for a successful BITCOIN investment and trading, You will be PROUD you DID. Thank me later🕺🕺💼💰💵💡