Court dismisses wine industry's bid to overturn lockdown liquor bans

Court dismisses wine industry's bid to overturn lockdown liquor bans

2021-12-07 10:39:00 PM

Court dismisses wine industry's bid to overturn lockdown liquor bans

Vinpro says it is extremely disappointed in the court ruling on Tuesday dismissing the wine industry body's application to overturn the liquor bans.

Image:123RF/jeka81Vinpro says it is extremely disappointed in the Western Cape High Court’s ruling on Tuesday dismissing the wine industry body's application against the liquor bans.The non-profit, which representsclose to 2,600 South African wine producers, cellars and industry stakeholders,

launched its application when the liquor ban was put in place in January. However, its application was heard only in August.In its challenge, Vinpro argued that the national government was the wrong level of the state to deal with decision-making regarding the sale of liquor during the state of disaster. It said the decision should be taken by provincial governments.

Vinpro also argued the implementation of the nationwide bans was too broad, unnecessary and unjustified.Vinpro said on Tuesday the high court found that the wine industry body’s application was moot, as the regulations has since changed. The court also ruled each party should be liable for its own legal costs. headtopics.com

Scopa will not summon Ramaphosa - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.

“We are extremely disappointed in the ruling,” says Rico Basson, Vinpro MD.He said government’s blunt approach, unwillingness to consult and lack of transparency regarding the empirical data used in decision-making had caused irreversible damage to the wine and tourism industries.

“The [wine] industry has not only lost more than R10bn in sales revenue, but also seen significant job losses and suffered international reputational damage. The only way for wine-related businesses to recover and rebuild is by creating an enabling environment for sustainable growth.”

Vinpro said it was concerned that the court had not provided clarity on important issues raised by Vinpro, especially in respect of government’s blunt approach to dealing with lockdowns, instead of a nimble, provincial-based approach. Vinpro said it reserved the right to again approach the court on an urgent basis should it be deemed necessary.

Death toll from tropical storm Ana in Mozambique, Malawi rises to 12 - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.

Read more: Sowetan LIVE »

Bongani Baloyi joins ActionSA

The party made the announcement during a press briefing on Monday. Read more >>

Jordan court jails health officials over Covid-19 oxygen deathsA Jordanian court sentenced five senior health officials to three years in jail on Sunday for causing the death of 10 Covid-19 patients following an oxygen outage in a major state hospital, state media said. Geesh please send that judiciary to SA

Alcohol industry body pushes for court to prevent bans as fourth wave loomsIndustry players fear the government may impose another liquor sales ban over the festive season U know something we don't I'm so happy I took part on this opportunity with LindaStouffes fear didn't want me to proceed at first but I just said to let go and gave it try. may you continue to excel LindaStouffes The alcohol industry needs a correction once this pandemic is dealt with. Running to courts at every opportunity for the unjustifiable. SA has an unhealthy relationship with alcohol that exacerbates the strain on a fragile public health system. Is that too hard to comprehend?

Myanmar court jails Suu Kyi for four yearsOusted leader found guilty for inciting dissent against the military and breaching Covid-19 rules

Basa takes government to court over previous 'irrational' alcohol bansThe association says any further liquor restrictions will serve as the final nail in the coffin as the industry has not yet recovered. Finish them.

CoCT willing to go to court to block govt from taking control of metro policeThis past weekend marked the 20th anniversary of the establishment of the Cape Town service.

N3 blockade truckers to appear in court on multiple chargesNumerous truck drivers parked their trucks across the N3 freeway blocking both carriageways. Surely their main charge is trying to PutSouthAficansFirst or PutSouthAfricaFirst Politicians never appears in court for looting and corruption Ethiopians were protesting and non of them was arrested. It is high time SA government listens to south africans .