Eskom, The World Bank, Medupi Power Plant, Medupi Power Station, South Africa (Country), Limpopo, Upington, Carbon Dioxide, Carbon Dioxide Emissions, Botswana, Climate Change, World Meteorological Organisation, Cyclone Idai, Madagascar, Mozambique, Zimbabwe, African National Congress, Kgalema Motlanthe

Eskom, The World Bank

Cancel Eskom’s odious debt to the World Bank

It was never in the public interest to incur a debt of $3.75-billion to build coal-burning Medupi

19.8.2019

OPINION: The Medupi power station, if completed, will be the largest coal-fired power plant on Earth, emitting more carbon dioxide than the 143 least-emitting countries.

It was never in the public interest to incur a debt of $3.75-billion to build coal-burning Medupi

Jonathan Cannard 19 Aug 2019 00:00 Comments COMMENT Despite significant and wide-ranging concern about the fate of Eskom, the World Bank has recently expressed its full confidence in the state-owned power utility’s ability to complete Medupi power station and ensure national electricity provision. The bank’s vote of confidence in the struggling entity is a product of the Ramaphosa government’s courting of international investors and financial institutions at the expense of South Africans. Given the overwhelming evidence of corruption and environmental degradation fostered through the World Bank’s 2010 loan to Eskom, the grounds for repudiating the debt are firm. Instead of accepting the World Bank’s vote of confidence in the struggling power utility, the public should use this moment of Eskom’s crisis to express a lack of confidence in the World Bank, an expression that must be accompanied by the repudiation of the debt incurred in 2010. The odious nature of the debt is clear, and it is only a lack of political will that prevents the state from standing up to the bank. In April 2010 the World Bank Group’s International Bank for Reconstruction and Development approved a US$3.75-billion loan to Eskom as a major part of the funding for the Eskom Investment Support Project, justified under the guise of promoting renewable and clean energy. Despite this rhetoric, $3.05-billion of the loan was dedicated to completing the Medupi coal-fired power station in Limpopo. This power station, if completed, will be the largest coal-fired power plant on Earth, emitting more carbon dioxide than the 143 least-emitting countries. Just $260-million was dedicated to building the Sere Wind Farm and the Upington Concentrated-Solar Project. A further $450-million that was meant for “low carbon efficiency components,” was mainly used for building a railway that transports coal. The doctrine of odious debt, long recognised in international law, rests on two pillars: debt that is (a) incurred against the best interests of the population of the borrower state, and (b) that this condition was known — or ought to have been known — by both borrower and lender. The Committee for the Abolition of Illegitimate Debt (CADTM by its French acronym) is an international network of finance and debt specialists, with extensive experience of studying odious debt dating back to 1980. CADTM defines odious debt as follows: “Debt, which the lender knew or ought to have known, was incurred in violation of democratic principles (including consent, participation, transparency and accountability), and used against the best interests of the population of the borrower state, or is unconscionable and whose effect is to deny people their fundamental civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights.” The climate degradation, local pollution and blatant corruption surrounding the 2010 loan clearly signify that the debt is odious. The World Bank repeatedly claimed that the 2010 loan was meant to increase South Africa’s electricity generation capacity through a progressive “energy mix”. To this end, the bank promoted Medupi as a power station that would employ efficient, ultra-supercritical “clean coal” technology. Clean coal has largely been shown to be a myth. Medupi may be one of the most efficient coal power plants ever built, but it still emits more carbon dioxide than most countries. The completion of Medupi power station is against not only the interests of the population of the borrower state, but also the world, given its enormous greenhouse gas emissions. The local air pollution from Medupi will directly affect nearby Botswana as well, and possibly other Southern African countries. A 2017 study found that Eskom’s coal emissions result in 2 239 premature deaths annually. Regardless of the exact number, Medupi’s local air pollution will inevitably contribute to numerous excess deaths, not to mention countless ill health effects and increased public health spending. The adverse effects of coal on local residents, and on the global environment, have been known for many decades. The scientific consensus on anthropogenic climate change shows that allowing global average temperatures to rise significantly will have drastically adverse effects on human, animal and plant life. One of the first major international meetings on climate change was in 1979, when the World Meteorological Organisation convened a conference of scientists to discuss the adverse effects of climate change on human societies, and its anthropogenic origins. There have since been regular climate change conferences, such as the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change meetings that have been held annually since 1995. The rise in atmospheric temperatures will not be experienced evenly across the globe: sub-Saharan Africa is predicted to suffer from twice the global average warming. The incidence rate of disasters such as droughts, famines and cyclones is expected to increase dramatically. The high death toll and damage caused by Cyclone Idai to Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Malawi, and Madagascar in March is exemplary of what is to come if radical action is not taken to mitigate the effects of the climate crisis. In 2010, the same year as the loan to Eskom, the World Bank itself released a long report detailing the harmful effects that climate change will have on development. A section of the report is unambiguously titled, “Unmitigated climate change is incompatible with sustainable development.” If the bank takes its own research seriously, it begs the question as to why it then approved a US$3.05-billion loan to complete a coal-fired power station. The 2010 World Bank loan was also mired in severe corruption. Hitachi Power Africa, the sub-Saharan African subsidiary of transnational corporation Hitachi, was contracted to build the boilers at Medupi. Chancellor House Holdings, an ANC investment arm, owned 25% of Hitachi Power Africa. The ANC is said to have been enriched by up to R1-billion through Chancellor House’s dealings with Hitachi, earning a roughly 5 000% return on investment. The links between Chancellor House and the upper echelons of the ANC have long been known, and were reported on in the media before the 2010 loan. In November 2006 the Institute for Security Studies published an exposé revealing that Chancellor House was an arm of the ANC; then ANC secretary general Kgalema Motlanthe later confirmed the connection. Hitachi Power Africa was formed at the end of 2005, with Chancellor House Holdings as a stakeholder. In 2007 Hitachi won R38.5-billion in contracts to build boilers for Eskom, including Medupi’s boilers. In 2015 the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) ordered Hitachi to pay a fine of $19-million because of Hitachi’s breach of the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. The SEC investigation found that Hitachi gave Chancellor House millions of US dollars in “success fees” in instances in which Hitachi was granted contracts “substantially as a result” of Chancellor House’s direct connection to ANC decision-makers. This ensured that it was profitable for the ANC to contract Hitachi. The investigation found that Hitachi was explicitly aware of the ANC-Chancellor House connection, and intentionally used this connection to win contracts. By loaning Eskom billions of US dollars, the World Bank was fostering and condoning such corruption. Following the SEC settlement, the Democratic Alliance requested that the World Bank carry out its own investigation. Suspiciously, the stunted probe, which concluded that a full investigation was not warranted, was approved by the bank’s then vice-president for integrity, Leonard McCarthy. As former head of the Directorate for Special Operations (Scorpions), McCarthy had clear conflict of interest in this probe given his political and social proximity to the ANC. He is also known for using the Scorpions as a political tool for influencing internal ANC leadership struggles in favour of former president Thabo Mbeki, which puts into question his integrity — and the earnestness of the bank’s investigation. Even the current head of the World Bank, David Malpass, has been critical of the corrupt dealings of the bank. As Bear Stearns investment bank’s chief economist, Malpass urged the public not to panic about the credit market, just months before Bear Stearns collapsed from exposure to subprime mortgages, indicative of the calibre of economic leadership the World Bank encourages. In a rare moment of honesty at a US House hearing in 2017, Malpass accused the bank of regular corruption when dealing in developing countries, explicitly mentioning South Africa. This serves as yet another example of the understanding at the highest levels that the World Bank’s loans are not in the public interest. Politicians, civil society, organised labour and numerous other stakeholders recognise that there is an urgent need to address the Eskom situation in some manner. One of the more common suggestions is the “unbundling” of Eskom. This will inevitably lead to privatisation, turning electricity provision into a commodity rather than a public service. A more appropriate measure would be to cancel the odious Eskom debt. In the face of the current government’s constant appeasing of international financial institutions, South Africans must demand accountability to the public. Repudiation of Eskom’s debt to the World Bank is a simple yet effective demand. The clearly illegitimate nature of the debt burden could be used to rally popular mobilisation, allowing the public to hold the South African government and the World Bank responsible for the adverse effects of the 2010 loan to Eskom. Jonathan Cannard is an intern at the Alternative Information & Development Centre, working on trade, climate change, and the Global Campaign to Dismantle Corporate Power Jonathan Cannard Jonathan Cannard is an intern at the Alternative Information & Development Centre, working on trade, climate change, and the Global Campaign to Dismantle Corporate Power Read more: Mail & Guardian

World Bank flags Eskom project Eskom will urgently have to find about R10 billion for a new mega construction project to avoid severe penalties on it’s World Bank loan for its two mega-construction flops – Medupi and Kusile.

Debt-relief law will further weaken economy, warns Banking AssociationHowever, others say estimates of what the bill may cost the economy are over-exaggerated, and it will have almost no impact on lenders

Credit bill means people might escape repaying their debt, banking group warnsBanks will either have to price in higher risks or avoid lending to low-income customers altogether, the Banking Association SA says

Debt-relief bill hits financial services stocks and retailersShares in financial services groups and retailers fell on Friday morning after the president signed the National Credit Amendment Bill into law 🔒

Brian Molefe to pay Solidarity R700,000 and Eskom R10mThe former Eskom CEO has now exhausted every avenue to appeal against the court ruling and will have to pay back the money



Soweto residents want free electricity

DA tables new motion into fitness of Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane | IOL News

Soweto residents adamant they will not pay for electricity - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.

R5m ransom demanded after Joburg Grade 8 pupil kidnapped at school | IOL News

No young person should lose their life during initiation – Ramaphosa

You are creating unemployment in KZN, Premier slams SAA business rescue practitioners | IOL News

Cannabis is king in Gauteng: Makhura says the industry will create jobs

Write Comment

Thank you for your comment.
Please try again later.

Latest News

News

19 August 2019, Monday News

Previous news

Should I vaccinate my child for HPV?

Next news

The new draft copyright Bill could help unlock the doors of learning and culture
Mshengu confident he will be vindicated over R100K car hire Phones belonging to Ayanda Dlodlo and other SSA officials found to be cloned Somhale wedding takes the crown as Showmax’s most watched show ever on its premiere day Kidnapped Queens High School learner found - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. What we can learn from apartheid 26 years later and government is still failing our children Eskom announces increased probability of load shedding on Thursday Let the smarter German stand up: Mosimane on the Soweto Derby - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. ANC, Sanco in Soweto serve Eskom with demands Donovan, Jason Goliath to appear in film with Vin Diesel Car theft at UCT rising, 10 stolen so far this year Education Department suspends use of pilchards at schools
Soweto residents want free electricity DA tables new motion into fitness of Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane | IOL News Soweto residents adamant they will not pay for electricity - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. R5m ransom demanded after Joburg Grade 8 pupil kidnapped at school | IOL News No young person should lose their life during initiation – Ramaphosa You are creating unemployment in KZN, Premier slams SAA business rescue practitioners | IOL News Cannabis is king in Gauteng: Makhura says the industry will create jobs Missing Queens High School pupil found at Maponya Mall SA’s most expensive mental health hospital cost R2bn but is half-empty Bosasa scandal: Magistrate Desmond Nair provisionally suspended - Ronald Lamola 'Students need the help': Duduzane Zuma's fees pledge welcomed | IOL News Bolt driver shot dead in Langa | Cape Times