BMW loses appeal against Sars findings over employees' tax obligations | Cape Times

“In terms of their tax equalisation policy, they will have to bear the additional tax burden on behalf of the expatriate employees.'

10.9.2019

German automobile giant BMW has lost in the Supreme Court of Appeal against findings relating to individual tax obligations of its employees. CapeTimesSA

“In terms of their tax equalisation policy, they will have to bear the additional tax burden on behalf of the expatriate employees.'

Cape Town – German automobile giant BMW has lost in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) against findings relating to individual tax obligations of its employees. The question at the centre of the appeal was whether payments totalling R6.8 million made by BMW SA to tax consulting firms KPMG, Price Waterhouse Coopers and Raffray Tax Consultants CC for services to expatriate employees in respect of their domestic tax obligations, constituted a taxable benefit and formed part of gross income. As part of the group's international business policy, employees are required to work for short or medium-term periods in locations where the group has a presence, other than in their home countries. Such employees retain their connection with their home countries and continue to submit tax returns there. Additional costs are incurred by the expatriate employees, as a result of the group requiring them to work in foreign countries. The employment relationship between the expatriate employees and the group operates on an agreed "tax equalisation" basis, the SCA judgment read. This means that the group, wherever it has a presence, will ensure that the net income of their employees, in countries where they are placed, is no less than in their home countries. According to the SCA judgment, BMW SA, in order to facilitate tax compliance by their expatriate employees, engaged the services of the firms to complete their registration as taxpayers. According to the judgment, the SA Revenue Service (Sars) had in 2009 queried why payments to the firms did not constitute a taxable fringe benefit, in respect of which each expatriate employee would be liable. In Sars’ view the payments to the tax consultants by BMW SA constituted such a benefit. BMW SA wrote back, denying that the payments constituted a benefit. Sars, unmoved, issued an assessment for the tax years 2004-2009. BMW SA objected to the assessment and Sars disallowed the objection. BMW SA, in turn, lodged an appeal against the assessment that was heard in the tax court. The tax court dismissed the appeal by BMW SA and made no order as to costs. The case then went to the high court in Gauteng, which found with the tax court. The SCA subsequently found that the services were utilised for the employees’ private or domestic purposes. “In terms of their tax equalisation policy, they will have to bear the additional tax burden on behalf of the expatriate employees. "BMW SA's policy and terms of employment cannot dictate the application of the provisions of the act. The conclusions by the tax court and the court below confirming the assessment cannot be faulted,” the SCA found. BMW SA manager for business communications Alexander Parker said: “BMW SA notes the judgment of the SCA and will not be commenting further.” Sars did not respond to requests for comment by deadline. Cape Times Read more: IOL News

Ramaphosa apologises to Malema family for abuse allegations



‘Desperate act of personal defence’ – Malema apologises to Ramaphosa

Malema apologises to President Ramaphosa - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.



Denying apartheid was a crime against humanity is 'treasonous', says Ramaphosa | IOL News

Lesotho's Prime Minister to be charged with murder - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.



EFF describes Pompeo's utterances on land expropriation as senseless - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.

Loyiso Gola celebrates his first sold-out show in London



Meet the blackest of black BMW X6sLight-swallowing black paint shows off SUV’s shape, but eats details

Rashid leads Afghanistan to famous Test win over BangladeshRookies secure victory with less than four overs left

Protests hit Hong Kong tourismArrivals down 40% in August in biggest year-on-year decrease since 2003 Sars epidemic

Police officer killed on patrol in Mfuleni, colleague in a critical condition | Cape TimesA 52-year-old warrant officer with 32 years' service and a 29-year-old constable with three years' service were shot on patrol last night.

Apartheid spy teaching history at Westerford High | Cape TimesQuestions have been raised about the employment of a former apartheid spy as the head of history at one of the top schools in the province, Westerford High. CapeTimesSA

Hostel residents march against foreigners as Buthelezi appeals for peaceFP president emeritus Mangosuthu Buthelezi on Sunday battled to quell tensions in Johannesburg as he spoke out against xenophobic violence.



Herman Mashaba to form private prosecution team to pursue corruption cases | IOL News

Experts tentatively approve of Malema's idea for a ‘borderless continent’ | Cape Argus

The ANC has nothing more of value to offer South Africans

Woman shot and killed during ANC branch meeting | The Star

Boy Mamabolo refuses to apologise to Malema family

BREAKING NEWS: Tazne van Wyk's body found in stormwater drain | Cape Times

UPDATE: Action to be taken against irregular appointment of security guards: Makhubo - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.

Write Comment

Thank you for your comment.
Please try again later.

Latest News

News

10 September 2019, Tuesday News

Previous news

R14.8m paid to house Zondo commission | IOL News

Next news

Old Mutual heading to court after barring Moyo from returning to work | IOL Business Report
Ramaphosa apologises to Malema family for abuse allegations ‘Desperate act of personal defence’ – Malema apologises to Ramaphosa Malema apologises to President Ramaphosa - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. Denying apartheid was a crime against humanity is 'treasonous', says Ramaphosa | IOL News Lesotho's Prime Minister to be charged with murder - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. EFF describes Pompeo's utterances on land expropriation as senseless - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. Loyiso Gola celebrates his first sold-out show in London Lesotho's prime minister Thomas Thabane will be charged with first wife's murder | IOL News From the archives: For the first time, an insiders’ account of the Third Force - The Mail & Guardian Shabalala described as an epitome of a true African identity - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. Ramaphosa makes peace with Malema over gender-based violence comments - The Mail & Guardian SA footballers and their finances discussed at summit - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.
Herman Mashaba to form private prosecution team to pursue corruption cases | IOL News Experts tentatively approve of Malema's idea for a ‘borderless continent’ | Cape Argus The ANC has nothing more of value to offer South Africans Woman shot and killed during ANC branch meeting | The Star Boy Mamabolo refuses to apologise to Malema family BREAKING NEWS: Tazne van Wyk's body found in stormwater drain | Cape Times UPDATE: Action to be taken against irregular appointment of security guards: Makhubo - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. Boy Mamabolo in hot water with ANC for setting off GBV row in Parliament | IOL News PICS and VIDEOS: UKZN professor attacked with brick as more violence erupts on campus | Daily News Land expropriation without compensation will be disastrous for SA economy: Pompeo - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader. Government must take Pompeo’s warning on expropriation seriously, says AfriForum Malema's wife files defamation suit against ANC's Mamabolo