The Supreme Court of Appeal remitted the application by Thabang Phakula back to the Pretoria high court to be heard by another trial judge on all the issues; including whether he was unlawfully shot, arrested and detained.
A man who was shot by police and arrested for armed robbery will have another chance for his claim of unlawful arrest, assault and detention against the police to be heard.
When the matter was initially heard, the court decided to separate issues to be determined and decided to first deal with the question of whether police had acted lawfully when they shot Phakula.Judge Neil Tuchten held in February last year that police had lawfully shot Phakula to apprehend him. The court then did not deal with the two other issues raised in Phakula's claim.
Phakula was shot by members of the Special Task Force on the allegation that he was part of an armed gang that had conspired to commit armed robbery at the house of a businessman in Emalahleni (Witbank), Mpumalanga, on October 26 2010.Phakula's version was that he was on his way to visit his then girlfriend who was studying at Unisa.
He was arrested and charged with attempted murder and robbery. In November 2011, Phakula was found not guilty and discharged due to a lack of evidence.As a result of the injuries he sustained, Phakula was found to be medically unfit to resume work as an army officer in the South African National Defence Force.
He subsequently instituted proceedings against the minister of police in which he claimed damages arising from the shooting and for his subsequent arrest, assault and detention.When the matter was initially heard in the high court, it decided to separate the issues to be determined. The court held that police had lawfully shot him and did not deal with the question of assault and detention.
This led Phakula to appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal.In its judgment passed on Wednesday, the SCA said the high court should simply have heard all the evidence on all the claims and thereafter determined all the issues before it.“That would also have meant that the high court would not have fallen into the trap, as it did, of making factual findings on one leg instead of all three legs of [Phakula's] claim,” judge of appeal Baratang Mocumie wrote in her judgment.
Mocumie said it was never advisable to separate issues as a general rule.“Ill-considered separation of issues often result in a wastage of scarce resources as has been witnessed in this case,” she said.Mocumie said had the separation of the issues not been ordered, the trial court would have started evidence to determine first and foremost whether the arrest was lawful.
Then the rest of the issues including the assault and detention, substantiated by medical evidence, would flow naturally to help the court come to a proper conclusion on whether the police officers were justified in shooting.“But as is apparent from its judgment, the order that the high court granted brought an end to the whole action encompassing three claims when the two of those claims were not before it,” Mocumie said.
The Fix | 25 Ocitber 2020
Thuli Madonsela suggests an amnesty can help to clean up corruption. #eNCA Courtesy #DStv403
Let’s get the Jerusalema dance right | CitypressOPINION | As we move to level 1, we should do so cautiously. From what I have observed over the past few weeks, most parts of the country have been living in level 1 (and even level 0) already, writes Timothy Molobi The government is powerless to lead SAns to a path of compliance as most of its office-bearers are themselves not complying. Ward Cllrs and Ward Committee members are waiting for a plan from DlaminiZuma TauParks & ObedBapela to implement at ward level
Cops implicated in death of Nateniël Julies had a 'hunger to kill', court hearsA police officer in the Nateniël Julies case “lied” and “misled” the court into believing he had one conviction when in fact he had three, the Protea magistrate's court heard on Wednesday. and a lot of other policemen too! We are used to them coz it's looks acceptable to SAPS. 😕
150 people died in 2 years as a result of police action in Gauteng, court hearsState prosecutor Mzwandile Mrwabe made the revelation during the bail hearing of three police officers implicated in the killing of 16-year-old teenager, Nateniël Julies, in Eldorado Park, Gauteng. That is to be expected with vast spread lawlessness and an influx of foreign criminals.
Police reservist arrested for Boksburg cash heistRobbers held up security guards and stole an undisclosed amount of money on Wednesday morning. Thank you for rectifying this. Is he an immigrant? Crime is within I knew it, for the fact that no police was killed. Inside job.
150 people died in 2 years as a result of police action in Gauteng, court hearsAs many as 150 people lost their lives at the hands of police officers in 2018 and 2019 in Gauteng, the Protea magistrate's court heard on Wednesday.
Five suspects dead, two arrested after cash-in-transit robbery in SpringsFive suspects were fatally wounded by police during a cash-in-transit robbery in Dawn Park, near Springs, while two others have been arrested. The wages of sin is death. Good work to the police Lol Dawn park is in Boksburg, near springs?! lol.