Why the arguments against immigration are so popular

  • 📰 TheEconomist
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 107 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 46%
  • Publisher: 92%

United States Headlines News

United States Latest News,United States Headlines

Many of the things that voters fear about migrants are not true, and some of their objections can be answered with smarter policies

people oppose immigration, it is worth visiting Tilbury, a port town outside London. Thurrock, the local parliamentary constituency, is 81% white British. Many residents moved here from London as the capital filled with migrants and house prices soared. London’s white-British population fell from 60% to 45% in a single decade, between 2001 and 2011. Some whites moved out because they sold their flats for tidy sums and bought nicer homes with gardens farther from the centre.

In all rich democracies, locals grumble that immigrants drain the welfare state. “If I go to the doctor, I have to pay for it. Foreigners come and they get childbirth and operations all paid for. They should be made to pay, too. If they can’t, send them packing,” says Joan Smith, a 73-year-old in Tilbury. Again, this is not an accurate picture. Migrants pay taxes.

Another fear, that migrants will steal jobs from locals, is as widespread as it seems logical. “Migrants in construction are much better workers than the English, who show up late and leave early,” says Danny Proctor, who manages building projects in Tilbury. “Foreigners aren’t lazy like that. I have a lot of plasterers from Lithuania and Poland. For 20 years they’ve been the best workers.” An English plasterer listening to Mr Proctor might despair. But the supply of jobs is not fixed.

The notion that Australia is overcrowded seems absurd. The empty plains of North Dakota are three times more densely populated. But migration in the rich world is highly concentrated. Newcomers head for the most dynamic cities, where everyone else wants to live, too. Congestion and high house prices are big problems in places like Sydney and London, but they can be eased by better policies. Restrictive zoning rules do more to inflate house prices than immigration does.

Some opponents of immigration fret that it will increase inequality. Some think it unjust that people from poor places might come to rich ones to work as servants. But if the migrants thought that, they would not come. Workers from a poor country who start at the bottom in a rich one will, statistically, make their new home more unequal. But their moving will reduce global inequality.

But step back and a more hopeful picture emerges. America’s population has risen 60-fold since 1800. It has absorbed migrants from Tsarist Russia, Hitler’s Germany, Ho Chi Minh’s Vietnam and nearly every other dictatorship of the past 200 years, without losing its democratic soul. On the contrary, migrants head to America because they prefer its institutions to the ones back home.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

Fear of immigrants is about the underlying, unspeakable fear people have about their peer group & culture. People fear the latent anger in the group so they turn against the outsider. They secretly suspect that their culture is second rate & project this thought onto the other.

Smarter policy may not be useful for dumber voter, they can't see things even just in next week.

Diversity means chasing down Whites.

They’re popular bc they play on people’s fear of the “other”. Not a new concept.

Sorry my friends 🙏🏾 please stop lying.

Really FAKE NEWS. Over Population isn't real? You stink. Lets send them to your house.

There’s a UN charter that clearly spells out its ambition for 8 countries:6 European,USA and Japan in which they have angenda for “ replacement populations.” The Economist is becoming the evermore Neoliberal Bullhorn. FUHQ 🖕🏻

Most are not worried about migrants. They just prefer a yearly cap on immigration and migration.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 6. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Why it matters that a Trump budget aide is breaking silence on impeachmentWith aid to Ukraine being central to the Trump impeachment inquiry, here's why it could be really bad for the president that a federal budget employee is reportedly ready to talk to Congress. That the Democrats and their media are corrupt liars Wait...wait ..wait, lemme guess: Lies... lies.... lies.... all y’all do is lie lie lie...
Source: MSNBC - 🏆 469. / 51 Read more »

Why Do I Feel Like a Fraud?Why so many successful people feel like frauds—and how we should really measure competence I can claim many things- Imposter syndrome is NOT one of them. Those are people who are actually competent & successful. Can’t check that box
Source: PsychToday - 🏆 714. / 51 Read more »

Why Fox News wants you to think impeachment hearings are 'boring''The biggest threat to Donald Trump's presidency has always been independent actors with inside knowledge unwilling to repeat the administration line. So Fox News...has to find a way to undermine the evidence' in hearings, writes Nicole Hemmer, CNNOpinion Opinion Evidence. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means... Opinion Opinion Hello it is live on the television watch it for yourself no news channel should have to tell you anything come to your own conclusion
Source: CNN - 🏆 4. / 95 Read more »

Why people should leave the countrysideIn rich countries 81% of people live in urban areas. In the rest of the world half the population still lives in the countryside wrathofgnon check this shit out TonyFratto Why people leave the country and move to cities? Show me the money. Duh! If you have enough money, stay in the country. Much better. But you need some cash to do so.
Source: TheEconomist - 🏆 6. / 92 Read more »

Why eating bugs is so popular in CongoOnce they are boiled and salted, a large handful of caterpillars will sell for $1.20—the same price as ten bananas Because they are starving. The bias in this thread! One man's meat is another man's poison. Stop chastising other people's food just because you were lucky to be born in well off countries
Source: TheEconomist - 🏆 6. / 92 Read more »