Reports of race or gender disparities miss the disparities of race and gender together.
Most pandemic reporting overlooks how demographic categories intersect.
During the coronavirus pandemic, public discourse generally accepted the premise that disparate outcomes among racial groups were not due to any biological differences between those demographics. Discussions instead focused on the socioeconomic and political factors that fuel health inequality.
The same cannot be said for disparate COVID-19 outcomes between men and women. Overall, men are more likely to die should they contract COVID-19. Analysis of that fact has largely clung to assumed sex-related variables around genetics and hormones and how that could potentially affect the immune system.
AdvertisementThe result, however, is the overlooking of one of the most adversely affected demographics: Black women, who, based onfrom Harvard are more likely to die from COVID-19 than any other demographic except Black men.AdvertisementAdvertisement headtopics.com
Researchers Tamara Rushovich, a Ph.D. student in the Population Health Sciences Program at Harvard University, and Sarah Richardson, the director of Harvard’s GenderSci Lab, spoke with Slate about how their findings “could save lives.” This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Let’s get started with an overview of the study.Rushovich:We started back in the summer. There were reports showing the mortality and case rates among men and women, and we were beginning to see reports by race and some other variables, but generally in individual identity categories: the mortality rates among men, the mortality rates among women, and lots of things coming out about how men were dying at higher rates than women broadly.
AdvertisementWe wanted to understand that a little bit more deeply, knowing that there are so many social factors for historical reasons related to racism, discrimination, history of economic deprivation, etc. that shape someone’s risk of exposure, access to testing, access to hospital resources, etc. If you look just at sex alone, you get one picture, but if you look across more axes, what does that look like and what does that mean for the sex disparity in COVID rates?
AdvertisementTo get data to even look at mortality rates by more than one variable was initially hard to do because it was not available at the federal level. You could only see COVID rates either by sex or by race or by age, but not in a format where you could look at it across multiple variables. And we really wanted age because we know that COVID is different across age groups and older ages are at higher risks. We were able to get data from Michigan and Georgia, which were the only states publicly reporting data in that format. And that’s the basis of our study. headtopics.com
AdvertisementOur main findings centered around that, within racial groups, the sex disparity varies. The ratio between the rates among white men compared to white women is smaller than the ratio of the deaths among Black men compared to Black women. And the ratio within Asian men and women is comparable to the white men and women. When looking across, we saw that the disparity between Black women and white women is much larger than the disparity between white men and white women.
When you only look across one axis, you miss some of that variation and where are there actually quite high rates among particular groups that is not seen if you only look at race groups or at sex groups or age groups.AdvertisementAdvertisementRichardson:
That is an incredible finding that the disparity among women of different racial groups is larger than the disparity between white men and white women. The suggestion is that the disparity we really need to be looking at is that race by sex intersection, going back to the framework of intersectionality and structural gendered racism, as a key driver of outcomes in this pandemic. And the point that the disparity between Black women and Black men is larger than the disparity between white men and white women also tells us something about how those disparities are working within each group racially defined.
How much larger is the disparity between Black women and white women?Richardson:It’s over three times the disparity between white men and white women.AdvertisementRushovich:The headlines have been “Men Fare Worse Than Women.” But who disappears in that picture? Black women who are dying of COVID at extremely high rates. That specific vulnerability is lost. It’s the Kimberle Crenshaw intersectionality story. headtopics.com
It’s very true that Black women end up missing in the narrative when we look at the data one way or the other. What does this data say about the way racism functions in America?AdvertisementRushovich:It’s showing that racism intersects with discrimination along gender and sex lines to become amplified, or work together, to both affect Black women and amplify sex disparities between Black men and Black women in a way that is reduced between white men and white women.
Advertisement[Some of our hypotheses for why this might be the case] are things like occupation, where you see both racial and gender discrimination in terms of who’s performing what types of occupations and which of those are essential workers. There is an overrepresentation of Black women in home health aide and nursing positions, which are high exposure routes for COVID. There’s also the effects that structural and gendered racism has on comorbidities in terms of shaping the many different avenues that influence health.
Richardson:It’s well known that this exact pattern is what you would find if, for example, you looked in Georgia at heart disease rates by race and by sex. You would find Black men at the top and Black women after that. And a disparity among white men and white women that is less of a disparity and the rates overall are lower in those two groups. What that tells us is, like my colleague Evelynn Hammonds always says, COVID-19 did not create race disparities. It makes them visible.
AdvertisementAdvertisementAnd what we have observed in the discourse around sex differences is a focus, a rush to biological causal variables. But our research has shown that there are extreme variations in the degree of the sex disparity similarly across states.
All of this shows that biology would be a very poor candidate to explain these kinds of variations, just like we consider biology a very poor candidate to explain the extreme racial disparities that have been seen. Instead, they pattern along these well known social trajectories.
Why is it important to see that this disparity is due to structured gendered racism?Rushovich:Where you see the cause coming from is where you then look to make the changes to fix it. If you see the cause, like Sarah was saying, in biological or genetic areas, then you’re going to lean towards medical and other kinds of treatment. But if you see it more coming from social and gendered structural racism as a cause, then you really have to look at institutional policy and social factors as needing to change to address the disparity.
AdvertisementRichardson:A ton of research and resources have gone into investigating these hormonal and genetic variables in the sex disparity. But Black feminist health scholars have been calling since the beginning of the pandemic for attention to structural gendered factors, such as the greater exposure of women of color in essential worker positions, special attention to protection from evictions—which overwhelmingly affect women of color and Black women.
Our findings support a much more cautious approach to making claims of sex disparities without considering interacting factors, because then you obscure those extreme vulnerabilities. If you only look at the claims about sex disparities, you would think the group to target is just men. And as our figures very clearly show, there are differential vulnerabilities within the group of men and within the group of women.Read more: Slate »
Inside a Black Hole
Don't let the name fool you: a black hole is anything but empty space. Black holes are some of the most extreme, bizarre and fascinating objects in the universe. Regina Caputo and Jeremy Schnittman describe what it might be like to go hunting for one.