The ballistics report doesn’t fully support the attorney general’s claim.
The state asserted there was no body camera footage. But that's not fully true.
Michael M. Santiago/Getty ImagesLast week, the state of Kentucky announced that the three officers involved in the killing of Breonna Taylor would not be charged with any crimes directly connected to her death. Since then, several new pieces of evidence have emerged complicating the picture the state—and the police—have painted.
Here are the new developments.Hankison pleaded not guilty.Brett Hankison, the only officer to be charged with a crime stemming from the incident, pleaded not guilty in court on Monday. Hankison was charged with three counts of first-degree wanton endangerment over bullets that pierced a neighboring apartment occupied by a man, a pregnant woman, and a child. According to the state, Hankison fired his gun 10 times through “a sliding glass door and through a bedroom window.” Hankison was fired in June for violating department policy but is appealing that decision. The attorney general’s office has said that Hankison’s actions showed “extreme indifference to human life” but that they did not know if any of his bullets hit Taylor.
Critics have demanded to know why Hankison was charged with endangering Taylor’s neighbors but not Taylor herself, given the alleged recklessness of his shooting. If Hankison is convicted on all three charges, he faces between three and 15 years in prison.
The ballistics reports doesn’t fully support the state’s account of events.Kentucky attorney general Daniel Cameron’s narrative is one of self-defense: the three officers who fired their weapons did so because Taylor’s boyfriend Kenneth Walker had shot at them first, hitting Sgt. Jonathan Mattingly in the thigh.
According to Walker, he and Taylor were awoken to hammering at the door—but no identification from police—and called out to ask who was there. (Police say they announced themselves before knocking down the door.) Walker and Taylor, alarmed at the prospect of an intruder, dressed quickly and walked into the hallway. When Walker saw one or more figures on the other side of the hallway, he fired a warning shot out of fear, he said. He has said that he was afraid that the intruder was Jamarcus Glover, Taylor’s ex-boyfriend and the subject of the drug investigation that led to the raid. When Mattingly entered the apartment, he was struck by a bullet in the thigh, and he and the other officers began firing at Walker and Taylor in response.
Under the state’s reasoning, it does not matter if Walker, using a legally owned firearm, thoughthewas acting in self-defense against a home invasion. The state reasoned that neither Walker nor the officers were wrong to fire their weapons: Taylor’s death was a tragedy brought about by misunderstandings, fear, and bad luck.
New evidence from the state ballistics report adds some uncertainty to the police version of events. According to a screengrab of the report published byVice Newson Friday, the initial ballistics report included in the police department’s file did not prove that the bullet was Walker’s. Instead it concluded that “due to limited markings of comparative value, [the bullet] was neither identified nor eliminated as having been fired from” Walker’s gun. The FBI also conducted a ballistics report, but the finding of that report is not public. In his press conference last Wednesday,
Cameronstated that Walker had shot Mattingly as a matter of indisputable fact. He did not mention the inconclusive report.The bullet hit Mattingly in the thigh, puncturing his femoral artery and putting him in danger of bleeding out. He was rushed to the hospital and underwent surgery. The medics who aided Mattingly did not deliver aid to Taylor, who died within minutes of being shot. Vice reported Friday that photos from Mattingly’s wound “depict a bruising pattern and coloration consistent with having been shot from close proximity”—something that could indicate he was not shot by Walker standing at the other end of the hallway. However, Vice acknowledged that Mattingly’s wallet, which was pierced by the bullet, might have also caused bruising.
It’s possible we will never know exactly what happened. If Mattingly were a victim of friendly fire, the thought would be upsetting, but it wouldn’t change much. Walker has never contested that he fired a warning shot at the person he thought was an intruder (he has said he fired it toward the ground). If in the confusion that followed the warning shot, Mattingly was hit by a bullet fired by one of his fellow officers, the officers would still be able to justify their actions as self-defense.
Video shows officers violating policies meant to safeguard the integrity of the investigation.On Saturday,Vice posted a clipfrom body camera footage in which Hankison can be seen entering Taylor’s apartment as investigators were working the scene. According to the Louisville Courier-Journal, Hankison’s presence there would be a clear violation of department protocol for the aftermath of a police shooting.
In the video, Hankison can be seen standing near a shell casing and saying, “That’s theirs?” An officer responds, “That’s ours, it looks like.” He then tells Hankison to “back out” until the department’s public integrity unit can arrive. But Hankison does not leave, and he instead asks the officers on the scene more questions.
In Louisville, according to the Courier-Journal, when officers are involved in an incident in which police fire their guns, they are meant to be separated from one another afterward and paired up with an independent “escort officer.” The escort is meant to remain with their paired officer through the entire initial investigation, monitoring the officer’s interactions and ensuring the officer makes it to the public integrity unit office. But according to Vice, the footage from the body cameras showed that none of the officers involved in the raid followed that protocol. Instead, Detective Michael Campbell, one of the officers involved in the raid, helped interview neighbors while Detective Myles Cosgrove remained at the scene. According to the FBI, Cosgrove was the one who fired the fatal shot. He fired 16 times in total, according to the state.
More videos from the scene appeared to circulate on social media. Read more: Slate »
Presidential debate live updates: Trump, Biden clash over key issues
President Donald Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden face off in the final presidential debate of the 2020 election from Belmont University in Nashville Thursday.
Mother of Trayvon Martin speaks out on Breonna Taylor caseTrayvon Martin’s mother shares her thoughts on the decision in the Breonna Taylor case: “You can’t run down the street ... you can’t do anything, and now we’re not even safe in our own homes.” You can't even hold money for drug dealers anymore. What is the world coming to You news is destroying the country and making victims out of able people. Glad I left the Democrats
Breonna Taylor evidence leaks appear to show charged Louisville officer in her unit after shootingJust days after a grand jury issued no charges against the Louisville officers who fatally shot Breonna Taylor, evidence from the case is leaking out on social media and digital news sites, raising questions about the investigation into her death Yall are literally the conspiracy theorists now😂 You are endangering the lives of police and others both in Louisville and around the country by printing LIES! Get some integrity. Always love to start my day with some fear mongering, not like there wasnt any precedent to not charge the officers
Former Louisville detective pleads not guilty in Breonna Taylor caseThe only police officer indicted after the killing of Breonna Taylor in Louisville, Kentucky , during a botched raid pleaded not guilty on Monday on three counts of wanton endangerment of Taylor's neighbors, local media reported. It's NOT the Breonna Taylor case. It's the neighbors of Breonna Taylor. The cop wasn't charged for shooting her, he was charged for missing. He was never charged on Breonna case He better just admit to shooting Breonna neighbor's wall. Thats the only charge You mean murderer.
Breonna Taylor Case: Brett Hankison Pleads Not Guilty to ChargesFormer Detective Brett Hankison pleaded not guilty on Monday to three counts of wanton endangerment.
Louisville Citizens Seek Mental Health Help After Breonna Taylor DecisionLouisville citizens are seeking mental health help as they have a hard time coping with Breonna Taylor case. Its a science experiment at this point and we the test subjects Lmaoooooooo more 2020 for ya
Breonna Taylor Crime Scene Aftermath, New Body Cam FootageThe first body camera footage ever to be seen as it pertains to Breonna Taylor's case has surfaced. BLM ACAB KAM2020 ABORTION ISNT MURDER I’ve been hearing from a lot folks “the police did knock and announced themselves” But still no body cam footage of police announcing themselves yet? Why?