Services/Consulting

Services/Consulting

This recent report suggests steady saving for retirement is not important

This recent report suggests steady saving for retirement is not important

15.8.2019

This recent report suggests steady saving for retirement is not important

ICI conclusions rest on shaky assumptions and exaggerate levels of Social Security benefits

The thrust of a recent Investment Company Institute (ICI) study, “Who Participates in Retirement Plans, 2016,” seems to be “Don’t worry if young people and others aren’t saving for retirement. Retirement saving isn’t high on their agenda. They will start saving when they feel they need to.” This sanguine assessment of participation in retirement plans is buttressed by selective information on participation rates in retirement plans and amazing replacement rates from Social Security. The ICI report starts with the basic question of how many workers are participating in a retirement plan. The report turns to Statistics of Income (SOI) tax data, which show 57% of tax filers ages 55 to 64 were actively participating in a retirement plan in 2016. (This number is compared with participation data from the Current Population Survey, which many analysts agree have gone off the rails since 2013.) The implication is that we should be happy with 57%, because this number includes older and richer people for whom retirement saving is important and Social Security produces very high benefits for the rest. A couple of points on the 57%. First, it includes public employees — virtually all of whom are active participants. If public employees are taken out of the equation, participation would drop to about 52% for private sector workers. In addition, “active participants” include workers who have a plan but do not make a contribution in a given year. Taking these people out further reduces the participation rate. Finally, participation rates are not improving: according to the SOI data the rate was 56% in 2008 and 57% in 2016. So, participation rates are simply not as high as ICI reports, and they are not getting better over time. In terms of Social Security benefits, ICI shows a chart with a 63% replacement rate — benefits relative to preretirement earnings — for those in the middle of the earnings distribution. How is such a high replacement rate possible? Two steps. First, select a really low measure of preretirement earnings. Among the options are average earnings in the last five years, average wage-indexed lifetime earnings as used by Social Security, and average inflation-indexed lifetime earnings. Average inflation-indexed lifetime earnings produces the lowest number and is always the measure of choice for those saying everything is fine. Second, assume everyone claims benefits at the Full Retirement Age (FRA), which will be 67 for the 1960s birth cohort. In fact, as the folks at ICI well know, most workers claim benefits before the FRA, and low earners are particularly likely to claim as soon as benefits become available at 62. Benefits claimed at 62 are only 70% of those claimed at 67. So realistic Social Security replacement rates tell us that all but the very lowest earners need to save for retirement The bottom line is that contrary to the thrust of the ICI study, continuous saving is important across the earnings distribution. Just because middle-income households don’t cite retirement saving as a major motivation for saving does not mean that they are correct. It is not enough for people to start saving when they feel the need to. At current 401(k) contribution rates, intermittent saving simply will not produce adequate resources. Alicia H. Munnell Alicia H. Munnell is the director of the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. We Want to Hear from You Join the conversation Comment Related Topics Read more: MarketWatch

WeWork is beginning to offer its employees a 401(k) match — but don’t ask if it’s a good oneContributing to a workplace retirement plan is one of the best ways to save for the future Thanks to tRump, today our 401k’s resemble 101’s-Barely BankruptcyKing

'We definitely see storm clouds on the horizon,' $93 billion money manager warnsWilmington Trust's Anthony Roth suggests it's not too early to worry about next year's presidential election. TradingNation Of course it does not look good. Everything realdonaldtrump touches turns to crap. EVERYTHING.

15 Redditors Shared Life Advice For Thirtysomethings15 Redditors Shared Life Advice For Thirtysomethings, But TBH It Works For Just About Everyone Obvious, but useless for some, I guess.

Russian scientist in city near nuclear accident warns locals not to fish, says agency 'committed a crime'Secrecy still surrounds the failed nuclear-powered missile test near Severodvinsk, in northern Russia, which killed five scientists. Good job you boneheads. The next site for a Trump Tower Sounds racist.

Russia Orders Evacuation of Village Near Site of Nuclear ExplosionAfter a nuclear accident, doctors at a nearby hospital were not told of radiation danger as patients arrived, Russian media report. After treating the patients, the doctors found that their scrubs were causing radiation meters to click. They’d better get the good dosimeters from the safe Beyond just another day at work this, the speculation of your newspaper and I’m ready to argue, you do not have accurate information - just fantasy!

Russia Orders Evacuation of Village Near Site of Nuclear AccidentThe Russian authorities on Tuesday announced the evacuation of the village nearest to the site of a nuclear accident in northern Russia, suggesting dangers more grave than initially reported u kno its bad when the Hillary supporters admit how bad it is Meanwhile on state TV: Não cuidam nem do quê é deles e querem dar pitaco aqui no Brasil.🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️



In The Garden Of Eden: How This Self-Taught Producer Is Crafting K-pop's New Sound

Kobe Bryant's widow files a wrongful death suit against helicopter company over crash

CNN town hall in South Carolina: Live updates from Sanders, Buttigieg and Steyer - CNNPolitics

Two cheetah cubs were born for the first time by IVF. The breakthrough offers hope for the threatened species

Under Trump, America is less prepared for a coronavirus outbreak

At Kobe Bryant memorial service Vanessa Bryant opens up, Michael Jordan wipes away tears

Harvey Weinstein Had Heart Palpitations After Guilty Verdict But 'He's OK,' Lawyer Says

Write Comment

Thank you for your comment.
Please try again later.

Latest News

News

15 August 2019, Thursday News

Previous news

Advice for weaning your grown kids off your credit cards

Next news

Trump and senators are talking gun control, but will anything really happen?
A wrongfully convicted man who spent 23 years in prison will receive $1.5 million from the state of Kansas World's oldest living man has died at age 112 in Japan Coronavirus cases in Italy rise to 272 Seven dead, 90 injured in New Delhi clashes ahead of Trump's arrival 21 of the world's 30 cities with the worst air pollution are in India Teen sentenced to life on Klobuchar's watch claims she 'never took the time to look into this case' A 'wayward' sea lion found wandering miles from the water in Washington needed a little rescuing TSA bans employee use of TikTok for the agency's outreach amid national security concerns China Sentences Bookseller Gui Minhai to 10 Years in Jail UK football authorities ban children from heading footballs in training Novel coronavirus cases top 80,000 as markets plunge on pandemic fears Coronavirus: 12 Italy towns on lockdown, most infections outside Asia - Business Insider
In The Garden Of Eden: How This Self-Taught Producer Is Crafting K-pop's New Sound Kobe Bryant's widow files a wrongful death suit against helicopter company over crash CNN town hall in South Carolina: Live updates from Sanders, Buttigieg and Steyer - CNNPolitics Two cheetah cubs were born for the first time by IVF. The breakthrough offers hope for the threatened species Under Trump, America is less prepared for a coronavirus outbreak At Kobe Bryant memorial service Vanessa Bryant opens up, Michael Jordan wipes away tears Harvey Weinstein Had Heart Palpitations After Guilty Verdict But 'He's OK,' Lawyer Says Sanders stands by Castro comments, knocks Democratic critics As Fears of a Pandemic Mount, W.H.O. Says World Is Not Ready New Poll Finds 80% Of Americans Would Just Fucking Destroy Pan Of Brownies Steyer’s six-word argument for term limits: “Mitch McConnell, Lindsey Graham, Ted Cruz” A legendary woman, a trailblazer, an American hero -- Katherine Johnson