Tv, Race, Books, History

Tv, Race

The Good Lord Bird and the Bloody Comedy of John Brown

It’s the rare adaptation that deepens and enriches the novel on which it’s based.

10/25/2020 8:19:00 PM

Ethan Hawke’s Showtime series adapts James McBride’s novel with an eye toward the messiness of the past.

It’s the rare adaptation that deepens and enriches the novel on which it’s based.

that the subject of his book—the fire-breathing abolitionist John Brown—“was so serious, and his cause was so serious, that most of what’s been written about him is really serious and, in my opinion, a little bit boring.” Now, even more than in 2013, the belief that slavery in America can only properly be addressed with

Trump Push To Invalidate Votes In Heavily Black Cities Alarms Civil Rights Groups Chris Cuomo Gives Trump The Cold Truth About His Presidential Legacy Taylor Swift Is Dropping A 'Folklore' Concert Film On Disney+ At Midnight

prevails, and confessing that you find this approach a little bit boring seems almost taboo. ButThe Good Lord Birdis a comic novel, an exuberant if often dark tumble through the kaleidoscope of paradoxes, absurdities, and, yes, horrors that have made up American attitudes toward race and our national identity. Because it captures the many different ways that human beings come to terms with an essentially insane institution, Showtime’s seven-part series is the rare adaptation that deepens and enriches the novel upon which it’s based.

McBride’s obvious model for his novel isHuckleberry Finn;like Mark Twain, he creates an unsophisticated but perceptive child narrator, pairs him with an adult man of the opposite race, and sets the two on a journey that serves as the boy’s education. The humor often comes from the narrator’s straightforward and often unwitting observations of adult hypocrisy and self-delusion. In a scene taken from the novel, the series (created by Ethan Hawke, who plays Brown, and Mark Richard) shows Brown bringing young Henry Shackleford (whom he has rescued from enslavement and believes to be a girl) with him on a fundraising trip to the Northern states. Brown advises his young companion that he might be asked to recount the torments of bondage—whipping, starvation, deprivation. “Dutch ain’t never whipped me,” Henry (Joshua Caleb Johnson) earnestly tells the abolitionist of his onetime master, “and he fed me good. Never been cold before sleeping in the woods with you and the boys. And I ain’t never been shot at til I met you. Truth be told, I ain’t seen a person murdered til I met you.” The joke is that Henry has no idea how rhetorically inconvenient his individual truth is to the cause, but the scene also touches on an abiding theme of both novel and series: How much comfort does it take to persuade a person to abandon an uncomfortable principle?

Brown, portrayed with both mighty Old Testament majesty and tender humility by Hawke, is where all compromises go to die. As a member of Brown’s party, Henry (nicknamed Onion) witnesses the Pottawatomie massacre, in which Brown and his militia beheaded pro-slavery settlers. The similarity between those killings and the videotaped executions of Western captives by Islamist militants—more recent history in 2013 than it is today but still a vivid memory—runs like a shiver through the scene. The men Brown slaughters may be vile (just like Dutch, Henry’s former master, shows himself to be in the series’ initial scenes), but the blood and trauma that splash across Henry’s face as he looks on are also a truth.

Brown’s faith swings from the ridiculous to the sublime. His long-winded graces keep his famished ragtag followers from their dinners and he pauses midbattle to implore the Lord with prayers and quiz his sons on Bible verses. Religion saturated 19th-century America, yet few whites were rigorous enough to take their Christianity to the logical conclusion Brown arrived at: that slavery was an abomination to be eradicated at all costs. He had the courage of his convictions, sacrificing everything, including his own life, in that battle. On the other hand, as one of the abolitionist’s younger sons keeps pointing out, the bloodthirstiness of Brown’s crusade doesn’t seem exactly Christian, either. How much killing is a just cause entitled to? Who decides which causes are righteous enough?

At first, Henry regards Brown as mad and contemplates escaping the abolitionist’s “army”—in truth, a band of guerrillas not much bigger than the group recently charged with plotting to kidnap the governor of Michigan. At least then he could return to his former life, which was unfree but far less dangerous and included regular meals. The novel and series not only recount the years leading up to Brown’s doomed raid on the arsenal at Harpers Ferry, but also chart Henry’s evolution from a child primarily concerned with his own immediate needs to a committed follower of Brown’s. However, Henry’s is not really an ideological conversion; he’s too much of an everyman to be swept up in the riptide of an abstraction, even so pertinent an abstraction as freedom. When, in “gentle Canada,” Henry at last has the opportunity to strike out on his own, the collective fervor of an audience of free Blacks, rallied to serve in Brown’s militia by no less than Harriet Tubman, persuades him not to. But that’s only the last of many straws. The biggest—a veritable hay bale—is that he has come to love “the old man” like a father.

James McBride.Amy Sussman/Getty Images“Whatever he believed he believed,” is Henry’s much-quoted verdict on Brown in McBride’s book. “It didn’t matter to him whether it was really true or not. He just changed the truth till it fit him. He was a real white man.” It’s a beautifully double-edged blade of a line. Brown had the arrogance to regard himself as God’s instrument for liberating the slaves, and the confidence of privilege to believe that he could pull it off and remake the world to accord with the Lord’s will as he saw it. And despite the debacle at Harpers Ferry and Brown’s subsequent hanging, the raid did provide a crucial impetus to the Civil War by showing the South that white men were willing to die for abolition.

Dear Americans: Cancel Thanksgiving This Year. Love, Canada. Facing Pressure, Trump Relents On Starting Transition Purdue Pharma, maker of OxyContin, expected to plead guilty to charges related to nation's opioid crisis

The Good Lord Birdis a swirl of moral equations that resists absolutism and can never be made to add up tidily. The series, by transcending Henry’s limited understanding of what’s going on around him, makes this even more evident. Its many fine performances indicate how, for example, each of Brown’s sons was motivated by a different mixture of filial love, righteous indignation, and exasperation with his father’s single-mindedness. McBride’s Brown is a hero, and he is also a kind of monster. Many people, including his own kin, die as a result of his stubborn insistence on going ahead with the raid, a conviction borne of the same zeal that makes him so impressive. But every lost soul is also registered in Hawke’s eyes.

Read more: Slate »

Coronavirus live updates: Pennsylvania could run out of ICU beds by next week

A pandemic of the novel coronavirus has now killed more than 1.3 million people worldwide.

‘I’m Your Woman,’ ‘The Good Lord Bird’ Play SCAD Savannah FestivalSCAD Savannah Film Festival prides itself on involving the students at Savannah College of Art and Design in almost every aspect of its annual event, from welcoming talent on the red carpet to weig…

Borat Defends His Very Good Friend Rudy Giuliani in Livestream Q&A Event“Rudy will not hesitate to reach inside his legal briefs and take out his subpoenas,” said Borat during a virtual Q&A Kong 👹 I hope he was jerking off right in front of you and got away with it with the ‘shirt tucking’ excuse. That would be hilarious. “When a man becomes rich he goes bad. When a woman goes bad she becomes rich.” - old Chinese proverb When Rudy becomes President Trump’s personal lawyer the world goes bad. When the world goes bad Rudy becomes filthy rich. - new Russian proverb

Polish President Duda infected with coronavirus, feels good: ministerPolish President Andrzej Duda has tested positive for coronavirus but is feeling good, presidential minister Blazej Spychalski announced on Twitter on Saturday. Its not a virus, is scary about protests. That's so sad good boy

This Bra Is So Good for Big Boobs Chelsea Handler Owns 14 of ThemThe comedian, talk show host, and writer shares everything she's loving these days.

Bilingualism is good medicine for the brainA researcher at York University in Toronto has found that bilinguals are diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease four to five years later than their monolingual counterparts Did they control for other factors that might be tied to bilingualism? Such as ethnicity, diet, etc. And in other news....Rosetta Stones shares have gone up since a study that came out saying being bilingual can reduce your chances of Alzheimer's 😅 Good news for Pope Francis...

17 Very Good — Some Might Even Say Great — Things That Happened This WeekBehold, the greatness!!!